Saturday, November 21, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The Israeli government has again defied the United Nations, formally barring a U.N. fact-finding team mandated by the Security Council to visit the war-devastated Jenin refugee camp, officials said.
U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan, who first proposed a visit by the U.N. team, is likely to abandon his proposal because Israel has reneged on an agreement to cooperate with the United Nations.
Kieran Prendergast, Under-Secretary-General for Political Affairs, said Tuesday it was Annan’s view that a thorough, credible and balanced report on recent events in the camp would not be possible without the Israeli government’s full cooperation.
Prendergast, who addressed the Security Council on behalf of Annan, told delegates: “With every passing day it becomes more difficult to determine what took place on the ground in Jenin.”
Israeli attacks on the Jenin refugee camp early this month have led to widespread but unconfirmed reports of heavy civilian casualties, possibly running into the hundreds. The U.N. team was expected to set the record straight.
Since early March, the Security Council has adopted four resolutions, including two calling for Israeli withdrawal from the occupied territories. Israel has declined.
Late Tuesday, Arab nations were sponsoring a resolution demanding that Israel cooperate fully with the fact-finding team.
Israeli authorities had agreed to the team. On Monday, however, Foreign Minister Shimon Peres said on television: “We just don’t need a team.”
Annan told reporters Tuesday he had received assurances of cooperation from Peres and Defense Minister Benjamin Ben Eliezer.
“Of course, they raised some questions as to whether the team has enough military expertise and people with intelligence and counter-terrorism expertise. And we’ve dealt with that,” he added. “So, we’ve really done everything to meet them, to deal with their concerns. And I think we’ve been forthcoming.”
Israeli Communications Minister Reuven Rivlin, in news reports Tuesday, was quoted as saying: “This awful United Nations team is out to get us and is likely to smear Israel and to force us to do things which Israel is not prepared even to hear about.”
U.S. Ambassador John Negroponte told reporters Tuesday that the Security Council would respect Annan’s final decision on the fact-finding team.
He pointed out that a second option was also being considered: that the team remains in Geneva until the final terms of reference are worked out with the Israelis.
“There is some important progress being made”, Negroponte said, including the alleviation of the siege of Palestinian leader Yasser Arafat’s compound in Ramallah and a resolution to the problem of the Palestinians being held virtual prisoners in the Church of the Nativity in Jerusalem.
Ambassador Shamshad Ahmad of Pakistan said Annan’s initiative was “a well-meaning initiative”. The three members of the team, former Finnish President Martti Ahtisaari, former U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees Sadako Ogata and former head of the International Committee of the Red Cross Cornelio Sammaruga, were people of high calibre, he said.
Unfortunately, he said, the Security Council has lost is credibility and its authority because of its selective approach in implementing its resolutions.
“The Council’s whole approach is discriminating,” Ahmad told IPS, explaining that the body appeared to seek to implement some resolutions and to ignore others.
The Council’s preoccupation with recent events in the Middle East, he said, has sidelined some of the core issues, namely self-determination for Palestinians, the future of Jerusalem, and the withdrawal of Israeli forces from occupied territories.
“It is not the United Nations that has to be blamed but its membership,” he added.