Saturday, November 21, 2026
Jim Lobe
- President George W. Bush’s administration did serious damage to its credibility in Latin America by praising — prematurely, as it happens — an apparent military coup d’etat in Venezuela, regional specialists here said Monday.
Washington welcomed news Friday of the ouster of Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez Frias, who returned to office in triumph Sunday after the coalition that led the coup fell apart.
“This whole episode does not reflect well on the U.S. administration,” said Michael Shifter, vice president of the think tank Inter-American Dialogue. “It badly damages U.S. credibility on democracy questions and revealed that the U.S. had completely isolated itself on this issue.”
Other analysts, including State Department officials who spoke on condition they not be identified, blamed political appointees — particularly Assistant Secretary of State for Western Hemisphere Affairs Otto Reich and the senior director for Democracy, Human Rights and International Organisations at the National Security Council, Elliott Abrams — for what is being described here as a major policy debacle.
“This erases just about everything we’ve been trying to do in Latin America in terms of ensuring support for democracy,” said one foreign service officer. “Didn’t anyone think how this would be seen by Latin Americans?”
She referred to a statement issued by the State Department Friday afternoon and read in part by White House spokesperson Ari Fleischer after businessman Pedro Carmona was installed by the military as transitional president and moved to dissolve Venezuela’s congress and supreme court.
In the statement, the State Department declared that Chavez had provoked his own removal and had resigned. It praised the military for its role and blamed Chavez’s supporters for firing, on orders, upon protestors outside the presidential palace.
“They were awfully quick to embrace the opposition’s version of events,” noted Bill Spencer, director of the non-governmental Washington Office on Latin America. “They should have been extremely cautious about the apparently unconstitutional removal of an elected head of state from power.”
The State Department also refused to describe what had taken place as a coup or an “unconstitutional interruption or alteration of the democratic order,” as defined by the Organisation of American States (OAS) Democracy Charter, adopted with U.S. support Sep. 11. Instead, it called Chavez’s ouster a “change of government.”
In its position, Washington found itself completely isolated from other OAS members, particularly the 19 Latin American governments represented at the Rio Group Summit in San Jose on Friday. In a joint declaration issued at almost the same moment as the State Department put out its statement, the Group condemned the action against Chavez and called for an urgent OAS meeting under the Charter’s authority.
Washington subsequently modified its position late Saturday, when the OAS met and, with the U.S. concurring, voted to “condemn the alteration of constitutional order in Venezuela.” On Monday, State Department spokesperson Philip Reeker still said Thursday’s events did not amount to a coup d’etat.
More damage had already been done Sunday, however, when Abrams’ boss, National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice, appearing on a national public affairs television programme, again blamed Chavez for his own overthrow.
“He needs to respect constitutional processes,” admonished Rice. “We do hope Chavez recognises that the whole world is watching, and that he takes advantage of this opportunity to right his own ship, which has been moving frankly in the wrong direction for quite a long time.”
“Hers was an especially regrettable tutelary presentation,” retired U.S. Ambassador Robert White told IPS. “How is it possible we reacted the way we did unless we had foreknowledge?” he asked, adding that he did not know personally of any U.S. complicity in the affair.
The damage to Washington’s reputation in Latin America was likely to be extensive, he said, adding: “Democracy is truly the one thing that we have going for us. And this incident says, ‘We believe in democracy as long as people vote our way’.”
“On September 11, the U.S. signs the Democratic Charter but then suddenly things seem to be back to the old days of the Cold War, when you embrace people who are friendly to you and oppose people you don’t like,” said Spencer, who added that the Bush administration’s outspoken opposition to Sandinista candidate Daniel Ortega in Nicaragua’s recent elections also showed an abandonment of even-handedness in partisan conflicts in Latin America.
Calling for Congressional hearings, Spencer added that “a lot of questions should be asked about what role the U.S. had in fomenting or encouraging the opposition and its quick embrace of this as a way to change governments.”
“Clearly, people up here were waiting and hoping (for Chavez) to be ousted. I don’t know how much more they were doing.”