Friday, November 20, 2026
Farah Khan
- After six years, South Africa finally passed a new immigration law this week, but analysts question whether it is an African piece of legislation geared toward an open continent.
“It’s a defensive law,” says Vincent Williams, the director of the Institute for Democracy (IFD) in South Africa.
Over the past fortnight, the ruling African National Congress (ANC) has worked to seal the borders, trying to put in place a quota system. Immigration analysts say a quota system – where the state sets quotas in areas of jobs needs – is old-fashioned.
Williams says the new law is not in line with the New Partnership for Africa’s Development (NEPAD) which President Thabo Mbeki sees as the policy document for an African Union that will be phased in over the next generation. This is because the law does not open its doors wide enough for skilled people who want to come to South Africa.
NEPAD is committed to keeping African skills on the continent; since the 1980s the continent has lost generations of graduates. “There’s no way this law will attract people who want to come here from Botswana, Uganda, Ghana and other countries,” says Williams.
He says that Mbeki has not lived up to his promise of opening the borders to skills as he promised in February 2001. “We need incentives to get people here,” argues Williams, who says skilled Africans from the rest of the continent should be granted benefits like free education to lure them to South Africa.
Research recently done by the Labour Department shows that South Africa is desperately short of skills in 33 categories, with the most pressing needs in information technology, engineering and financial services.
Standard Bank economist Iraj Abedian estimates that the economy is short of between 200,000 and 500,000 skilled people, based on employment agency surveys and scans of the classified advertisements.
In this, South Africa resembles developed economies which also face such shortages, but it cannot compete with countries like the United States, Canada, Germany and Ireland which are also on the prowl for skills.
“We need to be asking ourselves, why would people come here? How can we get them here? We need to think big in terms of tax reductions, free medical care and education,” believes Williams.
Instead of rising to the challenge, the law has become a parliamentary joke because it has taken so long to get through the system. The ANC decided this week that it would seal the borders, and allow in skilled foreigners only on a strict quota system. Then it changed its mind, deciding to open the borders and then changed its mind back again.
The law replaces the apartheid-era Aliens Control Act which was used to strictly control migration to keep South Africa as white as possible.
South Africa’s Constitution provides that the new immigration law should be passed by June 2, resulting in the scramble to pass a piece of legislation about which the ANC at parliament has been extremely nervous because joblessness is so acute.
South Africa has estimated an official unemployment rate of 29 percent and an unofficial rate of 41.5 percent. The official rate excludes people who have not looked for a job in the four weeks prior to the survey of joblessness.
Fighting between the ANC and the Inkatha Freedom Party, which controls the Home Affairs ministry, also has frustrated the new law. The parties were both conservative about the extent to which South Africa should open up its borders, but the IFP version of the new law would have opened the borders marginally wider.
The new law is better than the old because it is framed within the Bill of Rights and introduces categories of permits that make it easier to bring in skills.
But not all in the ANC are conservative about borders. Trade and Industry minister Alec Erwin tried to get his party’s changes, including the quotas, changed back at the last moment, but could not because the law needs to make its constitutional deadline. He believes that restrictive migration laws will prevent growth.
It is now likely that the legislation will be amended almost immediately to make it more immigrant-friendly. But for the legislation to be welcoming enough, the ANC will need to make a mind-set change: to realise that immigrants do not take local jobs. The legislation sets strict conditions to ensure skilled immigrants only get work permits if employers can show there are no locals who can do the job.
But Abedian believes that with South Africa’s huge skills shortages, it is unlikely that foreigners are displacing local jobs.
In fact skilled migrants can create jobs. “You bring in an IT person or even a dentist and the next day they’ve created a handful of jobs by employing domestic workers, medical care and clerical assistance,” he says.