Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

MEXICO: Bishop Seeks Lifting of Ban on Naming Indigenous Deacons

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, May 20 2002 (IPS) - The Catholic diocese of San Cristóbal de las Casas, in southern Mexico, where the Zapatista National Liberation Army (EZLN) is based, hopes to obtain authorisation from the Vatican to once again appoint indigenous deacons.

Felipe Arizmendi, bishop of San Cristóbal since May 2000, said the Vatican had responded that it would consider his request to name new Indian deacons in his diocese, located in the impoverished southern state of Chiapas.

In February 2001, the Vatican ordered Arizmendi to stop appointing deacons from local indigenous communities for five years, on the argument that those who had been named did not appear to have “sound and balanced” training and background.

Among the leaders of the EZLN, a mainly indigenous organisation that rose up in arms to demand justice and rights on January 1994 and engaged in 15 days of fighting before an armed truce was agreed with the government troops, figure several former deacons and catechists from local Indian communities.

In addition, local anti-establishment political groupings have close ties to the Roman Catholic church in the state.

Bishop Samuel Ruiz, who headed the San Cristóbal diocese for 40 years until he reached the age of retirement, promoted the training of indigenous deacons and priests, following the postulates of the “indigenous church” mentioned by Vatican Council II, as well as liberation theology – the “option for the poor” or “progressive” current of the church.

Advisors to Pope John Paul II who questioned Ruiz’s work in Chiapas decided to put an end to the ordination of indigenous deacons in the diocese of San Cristóbal.

Andrés Aubry, director of the archive of the diocese of San Cristóbal, believes the ban was imposed by the Vatican in an attempt to bury Ruiz’s legacy.

Deacons, who are one rung below priests in the church hierarchy, can assist in the administration of the sacraments and carry out missionary work in the name of the Catholic Church. They are designated by bishops, and can be married.

In Chiapas, a state with a mainly indigenous population, there are around 400 native deacons, the largest number of any Mexican state.

Bishop Arizmendi, who has described Ruiz’s work in Chiapas as “highly positive,” hopes the Vatican will overturn or at least ease the ban on appointing new indigenous deacons.

“What I foresee is that perhaps they will allow us to make such designations within a reasonable time, certainly before the five years are up, and not of all of the current candidates, but of a reduced number” of those wishing to become deacons, said Arizmendi.

“With your word, do not close to us the door of the diocese…do not put an end to the strength of the indigenous church,” deacons ordained by Ruiz asked the Pope.

The ban imposed by the Vatican on the ordination of indigenous deacons in Chiapas “calls into doubt the native church’s ability to express itself,” said Aubry.

Local politicians in Chiapas accused Ruiz of contributing to the creation of the EZLN, and Church leaders investigated him for supposed deviations from Church doctrine.

However, Ruiz, who was labelled “the red bishop” by his opponents, remained in his diocese – whose leaders were inspired, he said, in liberation theology – until his retirement.

The diocese of San Cristóbal is one of the poorest parts of Mexico. It was the birthplace of the EZLN, which for years has remained holed up in a remote mountainous jungle area, and which so far has refused to resume the peace talks with the government that were broken off in 1996.

Tacho and David, two of the group’s indigenous commanders, were reportedly catechists who carried out local missionary work in the past.

“Subcomandante” Marcos, the group’s top leader, has been identified as Rafael Sebastián Guillén, who studied in Jesuit schools.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags