Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Latin America & the Caribbean, Population

POPULATION-PERU: Growing Debate over Family Planning

Abraham Lama

LIMA, Jun 13 2002 (IPS) - Health authorities in Peru are increasingly inclined towards natural methods of birth control approved by the Catholic Church, a tendency that women’s groups are fighting as they defend the government’s strict family planning programmes in place for over a decade.

The Flora Tristán, Manuela Ramos and Demus local women’s groups are complaining about what they describe as the government of Alejandro Toledo’s “conservative fundamentalism in reproductive health.”

Activists urged Health Minister Fernando Carbone to leave in place the reproductive health policies followed by the governments of Alberto Fujimori (1990-2000) and Alan García (1985-1990).

Carbone responded that the current government-funded family planning programmes would not be eliminated, although he said a few aspects might be “revised.”

Women’s activists in this staunchly Roman Catholic country complain that the government has stopped providing adequate information on birth control methods. They are also demanding that the official campaigns for tubal ligations, the insertion of IUDS, and the distribution of contraceptive pills continue at the same pace.

Carbone admitted that he did not have “sufficient information” on the morning-after pill (emergency contraception), or on Manual Vacuum Aspiration, a simple, low-cost early abortion procedure that uses a hand-held syringe. Activists want both methods to be legalised in Peru, where abortion is illegal.

But the health minister said that “many governments have not yet reached a decision on the use of emergency contraceptive pills, because they can have secondary effects, and in practice their use constitutes an abortion by preventing the implantation of an already fertilised egg. We have to defend the health of the mothers as well as that of the unborn child.”

The Catholic Church is opposed to the morning-after pill, which can be used up to 72 hours after intercourse, because it considers the method abortive.

Women’s groups are demanding approval of the pill, especially in cases of rape. They point out that the transitional government of Valentín Paniagua (2000-2001), which replaced Fujimori after his impeachment, issued a ministerial resolution permitting the use of emergency contraceptive pills, which the Toledo administration has ignored.

“Instead of classifying emergency contraceptive pills as an abortive method, Carbone should understand that these pills keep women who have been raped or have become pregnant against their will from having to resort to an (illegal) abortion to interrupt unwanted pregnancies,” said activist Cristina Carrera.

Toledo has not stated his position on the morning-after pill. But the two health ministers he has appointed in his first year in office, Luis Solari and his disciple and successor Carbone, are doctors with links to the ultraconservative Roman Catholic organisation Opus Dei, which is opposed to most contraceptive methods.

Peru’s Catholic Church hierarchy harshly criticised the demographic policies of the governments of García and Fujimori, which brought down the birth rate from three percent to 1.7 percent.

The Church does not accept IUDs or pills that inhibit ovulation or prevent the implantation of fertilised eggs, methods they consider abortive. It also objects to the free distribution of condoms.

“In the view of the Church and Opus Dei, the only method acceptable for unmarried people is chastity or abstinence, while married couples must use the rhythm method, which consists of sexual abstinence on the days when the woman is fertile,” said Carrera.

Although Solari and Carbone “did not dare eliminate the family planning programmes, they have reduced their funding and are trying to impede the dissemination of contraceptive methods that allow women to make their own decisions regarding their pregnancies. They are stealthily trying to dismantle the government’s family planning policy,” she maintained.

Former minister Solari is one of the most prominent leaders of Peru Posible, Toledo’s party, and is well-known for his public opposition to family planning.

“Birth control is a Darwinist method that corrupts and destroys the supernatural transcendence of marriage and the transmission of life. The gender ideology is conflictive and has a neo-Marxist tinge,” Solari stated at an international medical seminar held in November 1999 in the Brazilian capital.

He later described as “perverse and immoral” the inclusion of sex education courses in high school, a policy adopted by the government of Fujimori to reduce the teen pregnancy rate.

When he was named health minister in July 2001, Solari pledged to leave aside his personal religious views as minister, although he did not conceal his opinion that most birth control methods were actually abortive.

Carbone, one of Solari’s closest associates, was appointed as his successor in February. He has not spoken out as loudly against the family planning methods still being promoted by the Health Ministry.

But a communique issued by women’s groups this month protested that Carbone was attempting to put priority on “traditional and obsolete methods like the Billings ovulation method,” which entails periodic abstinence based on a woman’s charting of her cervical mucus.

Roxana Vásquez, with the Demus women’s institute, said the delay in approval of emergency contraception undermined the health and lives of women.

She argued that because the morning-after pill would lower the rate of illegal abortions – an estimated 320,000 are practiced annually in Peru, 20 percent of which involve school-age teenagers – which are one of the most frequent causes of death among women from low-income segments of the population.

Vásquez noted that Peru’s maternal mortality rate is one of the highest in Latin America, second only to Haiti, amounting to 245 per 100,000 women of childbearing age, and that 31 percent of births in the past five years were unwanted, according to the National Institute of Statistics and Informatics.

The Latin American Centre for Health and Women reports that five of every 100 women in Peru have interrupted at least one pregnancy, thus risking their lives in what are usually dangerous back-alley abortions.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags