Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Health, Population

VIETNAM: Surrogate Pregnancies Make Officials Uneasy

Tran Dinh Thanh Lam

HO CHI MINH CITY, Vietnam, Jun 28 2002 (IPS) - Tran Thi Lam Chi and Tran Thanh Phong have been married for five years now and want to have a child more than anything else.

But Chi has a kidney disease that doctors say make it too risky for her to have a baby, which is why she and husband Phong are now seriously considering in-vitro fertilisation.

And since Chi would also be unable to carry the foetus later, they also want to find a surrogate mother to take care of that task.

But there seems to be a growing unease over surrogate pregnancies among medical experts and government officials, most of whom are worried about the lack of legal guidelines for the practice.

Although in-vitro fertilisation has been around in Vietnam since 1997, surrogate pregnancy is relatively newer. In fact, the Ministry of Health has approved only two applications for surrogate pregnancies. That was in 1999, and no other application has been approved since.

Now, there is even a draft decree on in-vitro fertilisation that bans the practice altogether.

“Surrogate pregnancy is not technically difficult,” says Trinh Thi Le Tram, deputy director of the health ministry’s legislation department. “The major problem is the long-lasting legal issues that may arise afterwards.”

According to Tram, these issues include the problem of kinship, which could arise should a woman get hired by more than one couple. The issues of heritage, of birthright and nurturing rights may also arise, she argues.

Other health officials and even some doctors echo her views, saying that since surrogate parenting is something of an ethical landmine, it cannot be allowed without at least some regulations.

They say they do not want it to go the way of in-vitro fertilisation, which is now being done mostly in private clinics and therefore without state supervision.

Indeed, during a conference held here recently commemorating the 10th anniversary of the public health law, officials called for stricter management of in-vitro fertilisation cases.

Many doctors agreed with them. Some, like Pham Viet Thanh of the Tu Du Obstetrics Hospital — which was first to do in-vitro fertilisation in Vietnam — also noted that existing laws have failed to address matters such as egg and sperm donation, embryo selection, sperm banks and surrogate pregnancies.

To be sure, there were those like Dr Le Huy Bao, vice director of the Hanoi Obstetrics Hospital, who said that surrogate pregnancy in particular is a very sensitive issue. Bao added that “we should consider the matter on a case to case basis so as to conform to the Marriage and Family Law”.

The problem, though, is that the Marriage and Family Law only says that “the government regulates parental determination for children born through in-vitro fertilisation” and is mum on other matters, including surrogate pregnancies.

Still, some doctors say that an outright ban on surrogate pregnancies may not be a wise move. “Many women cannot bear children and thus put their hope on surrogate pregnancy. If implemented, Article 5 (of the draft decree on in-vitro fertilisation) would take away their hope of becoming mother,” says Dr Ho Manh Tuong, chief of Tu Du Hospital’s In-Vitro Fertilisation Department.

As it is, he says, they have already had too many cases of women dying because they pushed through with pregnancies that their doctors had said would put them at risk because of their illnesses. Had these women been able to opt for surrogate pregnancies, says Tuong, they may still be alive today.

Experts say there is a significant number of Vietnamese women unable to bear children for various reasons. Some have diseases, such those involving the heart and the kidney, which make it inadvisable for them to get pregnant. Others have undergone hysterectomies or have malformed uteruses.

The country also has a rather high rate of non-fertile women – between 13 to 15 percent. Experts say this is due in part to Vietnam’s war past, which has resulted in numerous women marrying late and are now having difficulty getting pregnant.

According to official data, there are now some 1.5 million Vietnamese women who are putting their hopes on “a scientific way of giving birth to children”.

Experts say chances are high that many of these women should be considering surrogate pregnancy among their options, but are not doing so because they are unclear whether or not it is really being offered by hospitals, or if the government will allow it.

Chi and Phong, however, do not see what the fuss is all about, and say that there should be no argument at all over whose baby it is that a surrogate mother is carrying.

Chi says that in their case, the child would “naturally” be “our baby, born from our own ovum and sperm. The surrogate mother is only the woman hired to help carry our child during the 40 weeks of gestation”.

She adds, “If the law in Vietnam does not allow surrogate pregnancies, we will carry it out in Thailand and bring the baby home afterwards. After all, is it so bad to long (to have) my own baby?”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags