Development & Aid, Headlines, Latin America & the Caribbean

RELIGION-MEXICO: Few Indians Interested in New Indigenous Saint

Diego Cevallos

MEXICO CITY, Jul 24 2002 (IPS) - The imminent canonisation of 16th century Mexican Indian, Juan Diego, has not abated controversy even within the Catholic Church, and few of the country’s 10 million indigenous peoples place much importance on a ceremony that will not improve their miserable living conditions.

The sainthood ceremony for Christian convert Juan Diego, which Pope John Paul II will officiate Jul 31, is an action of faith that will have no impact on the lives of the Indians, said José Dibildox, bishop of the Tarahumara diocese, where a large portion of the population are indigenous peoples.

The priest stated that even though Juan Diego, an Indian, is made a saint, one can be certain that the Vatican has not made the indigenous situation a priority, nor is it fully aware of the problems those communities face.

“I believe that we are more an object than a subject of this canonisation,” indigenous Nahua writer Fortino Rosas told IPS.

There are few Indians who understand the meaning of the Juan Diego’s sainthood, and devotion to his personage is minimal, said Rosas.

More than 10 percent of Mexico’s population of 100 million are indigenous and most profess the Catholic faith, but as in the rest of the Americas, Indians are among the poorest of social groups.

The Mexican Catholic Church arranged for an indigenous family to give an official welcome John Paul II to Mexico when he arrives the evening of Jul 30.

For the canonisation ceremony of Juan Diego, to be held in the Basilica of the Virgin of Guadalupe, indigenous groups chosen by the local Catholic Church will have an important presence.

According to research carried out by the church, the Virgin Mary, mother of Jesus Christ, appeared several times to Juan Diego in 1531. On one occasion her image was miraculously imprinted on his cloak, which for at least a century has been the focus of worship for many Mexican Catholics.

However, a series of historical and even religious experts, who the Vatican threatened with excommunication, maintain that Juan Diego never existed and that Indians painted the image of the Virgin of Guadalupe on the piece of cloth.

The story of Juan Diego was concocted to convert Indians to Christianity and weaken a brewing insurgency, say many historians.

They point out that the church built where the Virgin Mary supposedly appeared just happened to be constructed on Tepeyac, the very site of an Aztec temple dedicated to Tonatzin – earth goddess and mother of the gods – which had been destroyed on the orders of a Catholic bishop.

Nevertheless, according to the Vatican, the existence of Juan Diego, “has been absolutely proven.”

Mexico’s top Catholic official, archbishop Norberto Ribera, declared that this canonisation is dedicated to indigenous peoples for their faith and devotion to Juan Diego, as well as to the Virgin of Guadalupe, who the Vatican proclaimed “patron saint” of Latin America in 1920 and “the mother of the Americas” in 1960.

On this three-day visit to Mexico, the pope’s fifth in his 24 years as leader of the Catholic Church, he will also beatify Indians Juan Bautista and Jacinto de los Angeles, who died in 1700.

Juan Diego was beatified — the step before full sainthood — by Pope John Paul II in 1990.

The Church in Mexico, where no bishop is Indian and very few of them speak an indigenous language, unveiled its official image of Juan Diego. It is a representation of a dark-skinned man but, contrary to what many had expected, he has a beard and clearly European traits.

Furthermore, the canonisation is to take place while the Vatican maintains its refusal to lift a ban on designating Indians as deacons, imposed in February 2001 upon the San Cristóbal de las Casas diocese in the southern state of Chiapas, where more than a million indigenous peoples live.

The Catholic hierarchy justifies its position by stating that the indigenous deacons, promoted by former Chiapas bishop Samuel Ruiz, have not received a solid and balanced education.

“It is contradictory for the Vatican to attempt to make the sainthood of Juan Diego a form of recognition of the indigenous peoples and their faith,” said Elio Masferrer, researcher at the National School of Anthropology and History, “when the likeness given the saint is that of a European and there is a ban on Indian deacons.”

Local anthropologists have said that, within the religious expressions of the indigenous peoples, the new saint is a marginal figure, one that is always subordinate to the Virgin of Guadalupe.

Writer Rosas commented that the pope may be making Juan Diego a saint in order to reposition Catholicism with respect to indigenous peoples, who today are continuously being tempted to join other religions or churches.

For his part, the bishop of San Cristóbal, Felipe Arizmendi, expressed his desire that the canonisation and beatification of Mexican Indians will foment the recognition “of the dignity and rights of indigenous peoples, with an evangelical appreciation of their culture.”

His colleague in Tarahumara, Father Dibildox, hopes that Juan Diego’s sainthood serves “at the very least” to draw the Vatican closer to the Indians.

Rául Vera, bishop of the city of Saltillo, stated that the canonisation of Juan Diego, who will be the first indigenous saint in Latin America, “should lead to reflection about the inhumane treatment given the various ethnic groups in this country.”

In Mexico, life expectancy among Indians is 69 years, while the national average is 74. Infant mortality among indigenous children is 58 percent higher than the national average.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags