Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

DEVELOPMENT-INDIA: Cooperatives Fail Varanasi’s Silk Weavers

Anju Grover

VARANASI, Sep 30 2002 (IPS) - It takes Moinuddin close to 15 days of back-breaking labour to weave nine yards of shimmering multi-hued silk which is popular with South Asian and Western women the world over who wrap themselves in the elegant and fashionable garment called a sari.

Silk saris woven in this ancient Hindu holy city, 600 kilometres south-east of New Delhi, are especially prized for their workmanship and each piece can cost anything between 150 to 1,500 U.S. dollars depending on the tightness of the weave, fineness and brocade in gold thread.

But, like the 100,000-odd weavers in this city where the Lord Buddha once preached, Moinuddin considers himself lucky if he manages to earn 30 U.S. dollars a month from weaving three of those saris that carry the ‘Benarasi’ name.

“Poor working conditions including insufficient ventilation and lighting have damaged our health and reduced our output. Most of us suffer from respiratory illnesses and eye problems,” said Moinuddin who works in a dingy sweatshop that overlooks picturesque bathing ‘ghats’ (jetties) on the sacred Ganges river.

Weavers fall into three categories, individual weavers, master weavers and members of cooperative societies, and while all of them are exploited to some degree, individual weavers who work on their own looms and use their own dyes and designs suffer the most.

When a sari is complete the individual weaver considers his work only half done for he must sell his product to the hard-bargaining ‘Gaddidar’, or trader, who often doubles up as money lender.

Consequently the impoverished and indebted weavers end up in bondage to traders.

Master weavers are better off since they do little of their own work besides suggesting designs and colours and farming out work to daily-wage earners, like Moinuddin. But Moinuddin says wages are paid only at a piecemeal rate, per sari, and is therefore in violation of local labour laws.

K P Verma, the assistant director of Handloom Textiles in Varanasi, concedes that the ancient trade is now threatened by exploitation of the weavers at the hands of master weavers and traders. “This is because most of the industry is unorganised and weavers are exploited in the name of colour, quality and design.”

But weavers who join cooperatives are not better off, although these societies are entitled to government subsidies on raw material and marketing assistance. Less than one fifth of Varanasi’s 110,000 weavers are members of the city’s 462 cooperatives.

“Cooperative societies just hold meetings and do nothing concrete for the welfare of weavers. Nothing comes out of the meetings. Our condition is no better than that of individual weavers and we too suffer from improper facilities,” said Gaavesh Sarvar, a local weaver and cooperative member.

Long hours at the loom have ruined Sarvar’s health. He complains of swelling legs during the cold winters and worries that he has no insurance cover. “We often fall sick for days, and these are times when we cannot earn any money but have to borrow to pay the costs of medical treatment”.

Another cooperative member, Alam Ansari, said that profits rarely get to the weavers. “The balance sheets are never made at the end of the financial year and the rules are openly flouted,” he said.

“The cooperative societies are anti-women. When I was pregnant I got no medical benefits although there is a provision for maternity benefits in the cooperative society act,” said another cooperative member, Shabana.

According to Zuleikha Bano, president of the Handloom Silk Cooperative Society, playpens are rare and educational facilities for the children of female workers are non-existent.

But the condition of women who are not in cooperatives is even worse as they are paid less than their male counterparts. In fact, in traditional weaving families women are not paid at all although they form the backbone of the industry and work in every aspect of sari production.

One local weaver, Nizamuddin, says he prefers to have nothing to do with cooperatives. “Master weavers float bogus cooperatives to get raw material at subsidised rates and a platform to market the saris profitably — we get nothing.”

The Cooperative Societies Act dates back to 1904 when India was still under colonial rule. But since then, and following independence in 1947, the cooperatives have been turned into an instrument of exploitation of the very workers they were set up to benefit.

Lack of professional management, bureaucratic control and political interference have joined to deny artisans their true worth and have contributed to the downfall of India’s cooperative movement as a whole. So much so that in recent times cooperative operators have seen their scams and tales of embezzlement exposed in the media.

One notable exception, however, is the famed Anand Dairy Cooperative, in the western state of Gujarat, which has steadfastly resisted political and bureaucratic interference to become a model cooperative and has helped India achieve the status of the world’s largest producer of dairy products.

Sometime ago the government set up several Weavers Service Centres (WSC) that were supposed to help poor and small weavers. But a visit to any of these centres would show that those who actually operate them are sleek traders and master weavers.

“What has been happening is that master weavers, traders and even exporters corner the benefits with the connivance of officials and nobody really cares for genuine artisans,” said Arif, an individual weaver who says he would get out of the trade if he knew another.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags