Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Mark Bourrie
- Canada will ratify Kyoto by mid-December, despite the powerful regional and financial opposition lining up against the accord.
Prime minister Jean Chretien, whose party has majority control of Canada’s parliament, says he has talked enough with provincial leaders and industry executives.
"We have had dozens and dozens of meetings with officials and ministers,” said Chretien, ”and it was always postponement, postponement and postponement. The time has come," he told the House of Commons this week.
Chretien announced at August’s Earth Summit in Johannesburg that his government would ratify Kyoto before the end of the year.
Under the treaty, drawn up in 1997, Canada, the world’s highest per-capita energy user, has committed to cut emissions of greenhouse gases, such as carbon dioxide, to six percent below 1990 levels by 2012.
Chretien says his government has already compromised on Kyoto limits. The country’s major industrial emitters, which account for one-half of Canada’s total emissions, will be permitted to emit 14 per cent more than in 1990, under special guarantees made last week.
The most recent federal plan also allows the transportation sector, responsible for more than 25 percent of emissions nationwide, to stay 27 per cent above 1990 levels.
Federal officials have been unable to clarify how these gaps will be closed, but they are counting heavily on Canada receiving credits for its forests and other so-called ‘carbon sinks’, a position that is still opposed by the European Union.
Although Ottawa says it has compromised, industry groups and some provinces, especially oil and gas-producing Alberta, continue to fight the deal, saying it will hurt business and cost thousands of jobs. Their campaign may be swaying popular opinion, depending on whose polling results you believe.
Earlier this week, federal Health Minister Anne McLellan, who is also responsible for Alberta, said that developing the province’s oil-laden tar sands must take precedence over the international treaty.
”We must ensure that there is nothing, as we move forward to implement Kyoto, that in any way would undermine or impede the growth of projects like the oil sands and, obviously, their contribution to the prosperity of this country,” she told reporters.
Alberta wants a special meeting of Canada’s provincial leaders before Kyoto is ratified. If Chretien refuses, "Alberta will consider all of its legal and constitutional options," Premier Ralph Klein said recently. The province is also considering unspecified "policy options" and the premier has even made veiled threats about leaving the Canadian confederation.
(Ironically, Quebec, the only province with an elected separatist government, is a vocal supporter of Kyoto.)
"Ratifying the Kyoto protocol now would be like signing a mortgage for a property you’ve never seen at a price you’ve never discussed," Klein recently told a news conference. "We still don’t know how much Kyoto will cost, how it will be implemented and what roles the different provinces will play."
In an open letter to Chretien this week, Klein said the federal government has not lived up to earlier promises of "meaningful and open" consultation on the issue.
The powerful oil industry has hired some of the country’s top lobbying firms and stands behind Klein, saying the treaty’s economic impact is still a mystery, and that ratification may be unconstitutional.
"We don’t know what measures that Ottawa is thinking about, so we can’t cost it and we can’t determine its legality," said Pierre Alvarez, president of the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers, the industry’s main lobby group.
Federal Environment Minister David Anderson, pointing to polls he said showed most Albertans supported ratification, told reporters that Ottawa would continue consultations.
"I think they will find that things are not perhaps as described in the debate to try to prevent us from ratifying Kyoto," he said in a conference call from South Africa.
Klein says his government will try to have the Supreme Court of Canada look at the legality of ratification.
"The reference would explore the issue of whether the federal government has an obligation to consult and/or receive the consent of provinces when it comes to international treaties," he said.
Environmental groups have blasted Alberta’s position, saying the province has tried to block Ottawa’s response from the start.
"When (Alberta provincial leaders say) there has been no discussion with Alberta – there has indeed been discussion with Alberta. But how do you consult with someone and come up with a compromise when that one side is consistently trying to derail the whole deal?" said David Hocking, spokesman for the Vancouver-based David Suzuki Foundation.
In the lower chamber of parliament, the Alberta-based Canadian Alliance Party continues to use procedural rules to monopolise debate on ratification. The government may have to use its majority to break the deadlock, officials say.
Mark Bourrie
- Canada will ratify Kyoto by mid-December, despite the powerful regional and financial opposition lining up against the accord.
(more…)