Friday, November 20, 2026
Bob Burton
- With over 18 months elapsing since any boats carrying asylum seekers have made their way to Australia, refugee support groups are urging the government to dramatically revise its hardline policy.
Sensing a shift in public opinion toward the plight of asylum seekers, the national umbrella group on refugee policy – A Just Australia – on Monday released proposals for the immediate release of the 219 children and their families still held in detention, and a system for the faster and fairer processing of humanitarian visas.
”Twelve hundred people are in immigration detention centres, around four hundred of these for over two years. Over eight thousand proven refugees remain on temporary protection visas,” said Howard Glenn, national director of A Just Australia.
The current government policy was devised in an attempt to appropriate the growing political support for the anti-immigration One Nation Party led at the time by Pauline Hanson.
In 2001, Australia instituted what it dubbed the ‘Pacific Solution’, forcibly relocating asylum seekers to Australian-funded prisons in Nauru and on Manus Island in Papua New Guinea because it did want to accept them on its shores.
Over 400 people remain on Nauru and three people on Manus Island. Those that had landed in Australian territory before the blockade started were incarcerated in harsh detention centres in the country.
”This is not protecting Australia – this is disgracing Australia,” Glenn said. While the government’s hardline policy won the political affections of Hanson’s supporters and divided the Labor Party opposition, it has slowly been unravelling due to public controversy over the revelation of the harsh conditions in the detention centres and the continued imprisonment of children.
A Just Australia proposes that the government provide permanent protection for those people who have been accepted as refugees, including access to financial assistance to return home if they wish to.
The present government policy is to initially only grant a three year ‘protection’ visa to those with proven refugee claims, which they then have to re-apply for when it expires.
Since the policy was introduced in 1999, just over 8,500 temporary visas have been granted – over 90 percent to Iraqis and Afghans. By the end of this year, approximately 2,200 of these will have been forced to argue that their fear of persecution in the home countries continues to remain valid.
Refugees from Iraq who applied for the renewal of their visas before the ousting of the Saddam Hussein regime in March are eligible for permanent residency. However, later reapplications will be required to go through the same process every three years.
It is a policy that the Refugee Council of Australia believes compounds the refugees’ trauma. ”It is an oxymoronic status of permanent temporary status. Failing to recognise that by keeping them in limbo they have caused considerable psychological damage, the separation from families – all these sorts of things so their ability to return is compromised,” said Margaret Piper, the executive director of the Refugee Council of Australia.
”We know from our past experience with the Vietnamese and Chileans and others that if you give them permanent residency and they get citizenship, they do all sorts of good things. When there is a significant change in their country of origin, many of them will willingly go back,” Piper said.
The prospects of the release of all children currently held received a boost 10 days ago, when the Full Family Court of Australia found in favour of five children all under the age of 15 who were appealing against their continued imprisonment.
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs Philip Ruddock argued that the Family Court of Australia did not have the power to adjudicate on the imprisonment of children held under the migration legislation.
It was an argument the majority of the judges rejected. ”The Migration Act should not be interpreted as permitting the indefinite detention of children in circumstances where there is no real likelihood or prospect in the reasonably foreseeable future of the children being removed and thus released from detention,” they stated in their judgement.
The majority of the judges found that the court did have the power to make orders to protect the welfare of the children, including that they could be released if it is found they have been illegally detained. The judges directed that the case be re-heard.
For his part, Ruddock last week lodged an urgent appeal to the High Court of Australia, claiming that the Family Court did not have the power to determine the legality of the imprisonment of the children ”or order the release of people from immigration detention”.
A spokeswoman for Ruddock said that A Just Australia’s proposal sounded similar to options that have been canvassed before. Due to a series of meetings, she said, the minister was unavailable for comment on the details of the proposals and it would ”not be high on his list of priorities for today”.
Glenn remains undeterred. He believes that the government’s policy will change, partly because of continuing community pressure, partly because of court decisions and partly because the economic costs of the policy are becoming more apparent.
He argues that the changes proposed would dramatically reduce the social and economic costs of the Australian government’s policies on asylum seekers. ”We believe that in making the right choice, this issue will quickly slip off the political agenda,” he said.