Europe, Headlines

MEDIA-SLOVAKIA: Secret Service Caught Listening In

Ed Holt

BRATISLAVA, Jul 18 2003 (IPS) - The functioning of the Slovak Secret Service has been called into question again after it emerged that the phones at a leading daily were illegally tapped.

A military investigation team announced last week that the Slovak Secret Service (SIS) tapped the editorial offices of the SME newspaper, one of Slovakia’s largest dailies, over several months last year.

The SIS then proceeded to tap conversations of the investigation team’s members, it said.

The revelations have raised fears within the media. "There is a lot of talk that other media, politicians and businessmen are tapped in Slovakia," Martin Simecka, chief editor of SME told IPS. "I fear everything is much worse than we think and that this affair is only the tip of the iceberg."

The SIS may have targeted the SME because it carried a series of critical articles on the intelligence services, Simecka said.

"My personal guess why someone would do this is that for the last two years SME has written a lot of stories about the secret service and its problems, about suspicions of tapping, and about former StB (the secret service of the earlier communist regime) agents inside the SIS," she said. "Someone might consider us an enemy of the SIS."

The military investigation into the current scandal began last year after copies of a taped interview with Pavol Rusko, leader of the coalition party New Citizen’s Alliance emerged in public. He had been interviewed by an SME journalist.

Many observers speculated at first that Rusko had been the target of the illegal surveillance. But the team of military investigators which heard SIS surveillance tapes found that the phones at SME had been illegally tapped.

Investigators said eight SIS agents were suspected, but they were unable to lay charges against them for lack of evidence. They also said they were unable to find a specific motive behind the tapping. The eight have been suspended, and the SIS has ordered an internal inquiry. SIS head Ladislav Pittner has pledged a full investigation.

The investigation file is classified and it is not clear whether the group was acting on its own or whether senior officials were aware of the illegal tapping.

Several newspaper editors and international media organisations have called for an independent investigation.

The International Press Institute (IPI), a global network of editors, media executives and leading journalists from about 115 countries have written to President Rudolf Schuster and Prime Minister Mikulas Dzurinda to condemn the surveillance.

"This undermines the right of journalists to protect their confidential information sources and seriously undermines the right to freely publish information," the letter said. "The action also infringes on privacy and integrity."

Petr Sabata, chief editor of the Slovak daily Pravda said the affair was a "serious blemish" on Slovak democracy. "Plenty of people turn to media with their problems, often in very difficult situations," he said. "Now when people see that media can be bugged, it could result in a loss of mutual trust, and people may stop talking to media."

The revelations raise awkward questions about the functioning of the SIS as Slovakia prepares to join the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO) next spring. Analysts say the scandal is unlikely to stop Slovakia’s entry into NATO. But it could make Slovakia a "second rate" partner in the Alliance, says Ivo Samson, NATO analyst with the Slovak Foreign Policy Association (SFPA).

"Slovakia has been monitored over this problem for some time now," he told IPS. "As soon as the organ that should secure the transparency of security information stops working, it makes Slovakia seem a not particularly trustworthy partner in relation to a security organisation such as NATO."

NATO has said it is watching the progress of the case closely.

Only a few months ago NATO expressed concern over the functioning of the SIS following publication of an article in the British publication Jane’s Intelligence Digest.

The article claimed that the service was involved in illegal arms trading and had links with the former communist regime. It raised questions also about lingering ties with Moscow. About 10 percent of the employees in the service are former agents of the StB, SIS bosses have admitted.

That followed another scandal earlier in the year when it emerged that one of the country’s top journalists, Peter Toth, who had worked for SME, was the head of the counter-intelligence service of the SIS.

 
Republish | | Print |