Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Labour

BANGLADESH: Debate on Trade Union Activities Far from Over

Tabibul Islam

DHAKA, Dec 16 2003 (IPS) - The new year will see trade union activities finally being allowed in Bangladesh’s export processing zones (EPZs), a step that labour rights campaigners hail as a victory but which some in the government and in business fear will be bad for business.

The decision means that trade union activities are going to be allowed more than 20 years after the first export processing zone opened near the port city of Chittagong, offering foreign investors incentives that included a bar on trade union activities.

The Bangladesh government’s decision in December to reverse this in its six export zones, where more than 130,700 people work, came amid pressure from the U.S. government. But though the decision has been made, the debate is far from over.

It is high time that trade unions operated the export processing zones, argues trade unionist Mukhlesur Rahman. After all, he says, Bangladesh’s own laws, not to mention International Labour Organisation conventions, permit the right to association in almost all spheres of national life.

"The law ought to apply equally to all sectors of the economy, including the EPZs,” he observed.

Ali Reza Haider, president of the United Garment Workers Federation, says the truth is that the Bangladesh Export Processing Zones Authority (BEPZA), which oversees the export zones, had become a government within the government over the years.

But an investor from South Korea, the largest investor in the EPZs, sees a completely different picture.

Foreign investors are like migratory birds, he said on the condition of anonymity. ”We will settle where the condition for investment is ideal,” he said. ”With the decision of the Bangladesh government to allow trade unions in EPZs, we foresee trouble, we feel insecure.”

Diplomats from South Korea and Japan had also protested Dhaka’s giving in to the pressure from the U.S. government. In October, Bangladesh tried to tell the U.S. Trade Representative’s Office to give it three more years before allowing trade unions to operate in the EPZs.

In truth, the debate over giving employees leeway to organise in the zones, which account for much of Bangladesh’s exports such as garments, has been simmering for a decade, following the demand in this respect raised by the American Federation of Labour Institute (AFLI).

Despite concerns raised by some foreign investors, an official with the Bangladesh Export Processing Zones Authority said that giving in to U.S. pressure would bring bigger benefits, not least by seeing more U.S. investments coming in.

Allowing trade unionism also staved off the possibility of Washington imposing non-tariff barriers on Bangladeshi goods, including the suspension of the Generalised System of Preference (GSP) facilities, if Dhaka failed to establish the right of association in the special economic zones from January 2004.

The U.S. market matters to Bangladesh since it is the single largest buyer of Bangladeshi goods and services, taking in 36 percent of the South Asian nation’s exports. Under the GSP, Bangladesh’s exports to U.S. markets fetch about 40 million U.S. dollars annually.

The investment of U.S. firms in EPZs is about 31 million dollars.

More than 20 countries in 190 industrial units have invested a total of 674.54 million dollars. The biggest investor, South Korea, has invested 215.14 million dollars and employs 55,326 people, official figures say.

The 103 million dollars in foreign investments in the fiscal year 2002-2003 are the highest in EPZA’s 20-year history.

For their part, a number of top industrialists have been looking with concern at the labour situation in the export processing zones next year.

Disclosing his name only as Rahman, an executive of a reputed private firm, told IPS that trade unions in Bangladesh often serve political groups and owners.

”In this impoverished country, a trade union is actually the union of trade union leaders and not workers,” he said. ”The labour leaders exploit both the workers and owners of mills and industrial units for their personal aggrandisement and personal gains. They use workers as means to serve their selfish interests.”

Joining the issue, Advocate Abu Ahmed of Dhaka Bar Association says that while trade union organising was conceived with the noble idea of safeguarding workers’ interests, this was not always the case in the country.

"In Bangladesh, trade unionism has become synonymous with corruption of the trade union leaders, exploitation of the workers, unrest in mills and factories and hampering of production,” he said.

He recalls how over two dozen jute mills, including the Adamjee Jute Mills, the largest in Asia, had to be shut down after incurring heavy losses over the years due to frequent strikes and conflicts within.

"Look at the Chittagong seaport, look at the public sector banks, especially the Central Bank, Power Development Board, Telephone and Telegraph board and other government organisations, where strikes or the threat to strike on different pleas and uneasy situations have become the order of the day,” remarked Saiful Haque, a senior officer of a nationalised bank in the capital.

Already, the Bangladesh Employers Federation (BEF) says the government must see to it that the outsiders do not get involved in trade union activities in the export zones.

Haider, however, says that there is a lack of recognition that trade unionism is but a basic right that should have been available in the export zones in the first place, so that restoring it is not a liability.

The question of extending better wages, benefits and working conditions should not depend on the pleasure of the employers alone, he adds. ”These issues should be governed by the rules and regulations of a factory or industrial unit.”

Knowing they can assert their rights is also a plus factor in business, argues Haider. Granting trade unionism would spur workers to work more vigorously to earn more money and this, in turn, would enable entrepreneurs to make more as well.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags