Friday, November 20, 2026
Zofeen Ebrahim
- ”I, for one, don’t want to take the extra baggage of going as a Pakistani at the World Social Forum (in India). I’d rather be known as a South Asian citizen,” claims Pakistani activist Aly Ercelawn. But Karamat Ali, another participant, says, ”But why go with any identity tag at all?”
So when the two attend this week’s World Social Forum, a gathering of 75,000 people from different social movements around the world critical of the economic and social world order, they want to go as ‘citizens of the universe’.
They would not like to take with them any specific ‘Pakistani thought’, but a broader ‘South Asian cooperation thought’ to share with the rest of the world. This is especially so in the weeks following the thawing of icy relations between nuclear rivals India and Pakistan, a rivalry that has made travel by Indians and Pakistanis to each other’s countries difficult. Attending conferences in each other’s countries is a struggle, as in the case of the WSF.
Does that mean they want to lose their Pakistani identity totally? ”It’s not blurring or losing one’s identity but taking on more identities, a South Asia identity perhaps,” stresses Karamat, director of the Pakistan Institute of Labour Education and Research (PILER). He adds that ”identities that we take for granted merely divide people on the grounds of ethnicity, religion and borders”.
With just days before the Jan. 16-21 WSF, Irfan Mufti, national organising secretary of the Pakistan Social Forum, says it’s ”still too early to say how many Pakistanis will be able to obtain the Indian visa”. Still, they are hopeful that the Indian government will fulfill its promise of facilitating the attendance of some 1,200 people to attend the WSF 2004 through ‘a special mechanism’.
”So far, their actions have not matched their claims and very few visas have been issued as of Jan. 8,” he says.
This is despite the fact that the South Asian summit in the Pakistani capital Islamabad from Jan. 4-6 helped create a sense of camaraderie – now that Indian and Pakistani leaders have agreed to start a peace dialogue in February.
One journalist here says the South Asian meeting in fact delayed the processing of visas by the Indian visa office in Pakistan.
”After the second attempt on President Musharraf’s life just a few days before the regional summit, Islamabad virtually became hostage to the VIPs who had come to attend the summit, with the diplomatic enclave becoming a no-go zone. Then the Indian High Commission put me off gear completely by announcing an unprecedented closure of its office for ten days during the summit,” the journalist says. ”So while I had sent my papers to Islamabad, my friend, who was supposed to submit the papers, could not get to the visa office.”
”I can’t make my bookings without the visa,” says one participant who wants to go to India, a country that is near but politically far from Pakistan. ”I envy those who can remain calm in unpredictability.”
”We don’t know for sure how many will be rejected. We’ll find out soon enough. They are mentally prepared (to be rejected),” Aly Ercelawn, coordinator of the non-government Creed Alliance, says indifferently.
Activists say that if the Indian government fixes any special quota for Pakistani delegates, they will have ”every right to protest” or even ”boycott” the WSF 2004 on the grounds that ”it will be a discriminatory policy, as it (India) has not fixed a quota for any other country since Pakistan played a leading role in the decision to shift the WSF to India”.
In any case, says an agitated Mufti, ”it’s a world forum and it’s not for India to decide who can and cannot come”.
Still, the advantages of holding the WSF in India are many, especially for the Pakistanis. ”More people can participate. More people can visit the place they had been yearning for, some can even visit their relatives they have not met in ages,” says Aly Ercelawn.
H Nayyar of the physics department of Quaid-I-Azam University in Islamabad adds: ”The participants from Pakistan will be able to express their solidarity with the rest of the world against globalisation, imperialist exploitation and war machines. They are going to join voices for an end to poverty, illiteracy and oppression in general, and against wars and militarisation and nuclear weapons.”
The fact that the WSF is being held in Asia makes a real difference to Pakistani activists. ”In the earlier forums (in Brazil), only a handful of Pakistanis could go, at the most ten or so each year. This time it is happening so near that thousands want to join,” explains Nayyar. ”The sheer number enhances the level of enthusiasm.”
However, the logistics have not been without its share of pains. The schedule of the Samjhota Express, the train line linking the border checkposts of Wagah and Atari between India and Pakistan, was announced late, so activists are crossing the Wagah border on foot instead and then catching the bus to Amritsar in India, followed by an 18-hour train ride to Mumbai.
India-Pakistan flights are due to resume, but the Indian Airlines schedule for Karachi-Mumbai will be announced only on Jan. 15, a day before the WSF begins. India closed its airspace to Pakistan in January 2002, following an attack on Indian Parliament that New Delhi blamed on Islamabad. Since then, Indians and Pakistanis travelling to each other’s country have had to fly through places like Dubai, then come back to the subcontinent.
So those who do make it to WSF from this side of the fence will take ”the message of peace to the WSF 2004,” says Mufti. ”That is why we have titled our delegation to Mumbai a ‘Peace Caravan’.
”Yes, ‘peace’ has always been a favourite word and is frequently used whenever there is an exchange of delegations between the two countries,” says Zulfiqar Shah sardonically, a journalist who is still waiting for his visa and who terms the WSF a ”big ‘mela’ (carnival) where there will be lot of interaction within civil society but where it is very difficult to reach any serious discussion”.
Karamat says, ”There’s a genuine feeling of goodwill among people of the region. And it is because of such peace initiatives that we are where we are today. It may take another 50 years for us to get there but people have to mobilise. The Indian and Pakistani governments are ”not nice guys”, so their arms ”need to be twisted” through these forums, he adds.
Adds Karamat: ”It is imperative that people recognise that the ‘eternal enemies’ just have to become friends, that they share the same history and come together as South Asians.”