Saturday, November 21, 2026
Julio Godoy
- The world’s biggest aid package from the EU could also be the most incoherent, experts say.
“European development assistance is the worst targeted,” former European Commission director-general for development Dieter Frisch said at a conference here on reform of European Union (EU) development policy. Complex structures have created a multiplicity of administrations, all covering development assistance but which seldom cooperate with one another, he said.
The two-day conference on ‘Europe and the South: A New Era – European Development Cooperation: towards policy renewal and a new commitment’ opened in The Hague Sep. 27. It is being organised by the Society for International Development (SID), a Rome-based international non-governmental association of individuals and organisations with members and activities in 125 countries. The meeting brings together some 250 experts from Europe, North America, Latin America, Africa and Asia.
The conference will explore relations between foreign policy, security, trade, and development.
“The total EU development aid accounts for more than half of worldwide official development assistance (ODA), including half of all global humanitarian assistance,” Sven Grimm, a researcher at the Overseas Development Institute (ODI) based in London said at the conference. The total world aid package is estimated at 57 billion dollars.
EU funds include more than 7 billion dollars the EU channels into development assistance through its executive arm, the European Commission, and member countries’ direct allocations for development policy that add up to another about 23 billion dollars.
ODI researcher Andrew Rogerson said no one would now come up “with the mess that European development today represents.” Rogerson said Europe could influence world development policy more effectively also if were not for insignificant political trade-offs such as heading the International Monetary Fund in exchange for giving the United States its way with World Bank policies.
Also, Rogerson said EU member states often oppose EU policies in international financial institutions.
EU official Luana Reale says reform of European development policy is under way. “The EU is revising its development assistance policy to establish major guidelines for allocating resources and to end duplication,” she told IPS.
But reform is raising new concerns. Frisch said the foreign affairs community of the EU now “speaks of security as sine qua non for development. That means that European resources could end up paying for paramilitary structures combating terrorism. That would be a major error.”
The reforms under way are raising concerns among non-governmental organisations (NGOs) that the EU could reduce support for development programmes. “We fear that the reform would provoke at least a colossal chaos, and at worst, would close down financing sources for specific programmes,” said Marta Monteso Cullel, EU policy assistant at the Stop AIDS Alliance. The group works mostly in Africa and Southeast Asia.
“Most of the NGOs have got accustomed to the dealings of the European Union,” Cullel said. “Now these dealings are changing, and we are experiencing a shutting down of important financial sources.”
Alfred Nhema, executive secretary of the Organisation for Social Science Research in eastern and southern Africa told IPS that “during the last couple of years, people like me have experienced that EU officials, who used to be our interlocutors for discussions, are now not available.” Nhema said this was one result of development policy reform.
The Latin American development group Chorlaví, named after a city in Ecuador says EU policy does not take into account the opinion of recipient countries. “I once received a working paper on development issues from EU institutions, which begin at page 46,” said Mariano Valderrama, a Peruvian scholar and senior advisor on regional governance at Chorlaví. “When I asked about pages 1 to 45, an EU official told me the rest of the paper didn’t concern me or other Peruvian officials.”
In face of such policies, some countries have decided to block all cooperation with EU institutions. Delegates pointed out that countries with high awareness of their sovereignty such as India refuse to deal with EU officials unless the limits of EU intrusion in national affairs are made clear.