Monday, November 16, 2026
Tran Dinh Thanh Lam
- While Vietnamese government and mainstream religious officials are relieved that the U.S. State Department will ask Congress for more time to discuss with Hanoi how to end abuses suffered by some religious groups in the communist- ruled country before imposing sanctions, rights groups are crying foul.
They expressed concern last week that Vietnam’s government may be able to dodge sanctions by offering ”token” gestures and making empty commitments to improve religious freedom.
The U.S. accuses the Vietnam government of oppressing believers of non-recognised religions, especially ethnic minority Protestant Christians and independent Buddhists.
Human rights groups said officials in Vietnam’s Central Highlands had shut down many churches and managed to force ethnic minority Christians to abandon their faith. They also said that several priests and Buddhist monks had been in prison, some for more than 20 years.
In September 2004, the U.S. State Department labeled Vietnam, Saudi Arabia and Eritrea as ”countries of particular concern” (CPCs), joining a list already comprising Burma, North Korea, China and Sudan.
The 1998 International Religious Freedom Act gives the U.S. State Department up to six months to discuss problem areas with newly designed CPCs, and to announce economic sanctions ranging from restricting humanitarian aid to cutting off Export-Import Bank credits.
When the six-month time period ended Mar. 15, the State Department said it had asked Congress for several more weeks, and indicated the talks were bearing fruit.
”We made some important progress,” State Department spokesman Adam Ereli said, adding that ”with a little more time we can take care of some of the issues that were problematic for us.”
In February, the Vietnamese government set free six prominent prisoners of conscience. Last November Prime Minister Phan Van Khai also issued a decree condemning attempts by officials to force Protestants to abandon their religion. The decree, the Ordinance on Beliefs and Religions, also allows currently ‘unauthorised’ Protestant groups to apply for official recognition.
The government bans independent religious associations and permits religious activities only insofar as they are conducted by officially recognised churches and organisations whose governing boards are approved and controlled by the government.
”I was particularly shocked when I heard the U.S. had listed Vietnam among the ‘countries of particular concern’,” recalled Tang Van Hy, vice chairman of the Evangelical Protestant Church of Vietnam – South. ”Nothing could compare to reality, so let the U.S. State Department look at that reality.”
The reality, according to Pastor Hy is that ”since the reunification of Vietnam, the Evangelical Protestant Church has had ample opportunities to develop. In the highlands alone, the number of adherents has increased to more than 60,000”.
The government has many times pointed out that services at Catholic cathedrals and Protestant churches, sparsely attended in the 1989s, are now packed, and that new Buddhist pagodas have been built all over Vietnam.
Authorities also indicate that in 2001 they officially recognised the Evangelical Protestant Church of Vietnam-South.
”Religious practices in Vietnam are very open and are thriving,” assured Chuck Searcy, vice president of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund. The U.S. veteran has lived and worked in Vietnam for about 10 years, and said he did "not agree with the opinion of some (North) Americans who actually may not know much about life in Vietnam, but who accuse Vietnam of not allowing religious freedom”.
But Ngo Thi Hien, head of the Committee for Religious Freedom in Vietnam, remains sceptical.
”Talk about things improving in Vietnam, I don’t think that’s true,” she said.
Hien referred to a letter sent by Monk Thich Thien Minh of the banned Unified Buddhist Church of Vietnam (UBCV) who was recently released from jail after being detained since 1979. ”There is no amelioration in human rights and religious freedom … five reverend monks of the banned UBCV are still in jail, together with six dissident Catholic priests,” said Minh’s letter.
”I have exchanged my small prison for a bigger one,” he added.
According to Trung Doan, a human rights campaigner from Australia, the number of ‘religious prisoners’ released compared to the number in prison is only a small percentage. Doan said he had a list of 110 known religious prisoners and the real number was likely to be much higher.
”The recent steps taken by the Vietnamese government are token,” he said.
”We believe the U.S. government should not let Hanoi off the hook,” added Doan. ”The U.S. government is probably the only power in the world that has the power and the will to put some pressure on them.”
The New York-based Human Rights Watch in a letter to U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said Vietnam’s track record on respecting religious freedom and other fundamental human rights has continued to deteriorate since Washington granted normal trade status to Hanoi in 2001.
”The Vietnamese government brands all unauthorised religious activities -particularly those that it fears may attract large followings – as potentially subversive. Targeted in particular are ethnic minority Protestants, Mennonites, and members of the Unified Buddhist Church of Vietnam,” said the rights group in the letter urging the U.S. State Department to introduce specific benchmarks in its negotiations with Hanoi.
Among the benchmarks recommended by Human Rights Watch are for outside experts, including those from the United Nations and independent international human rights organisations, to have access to religious followers in Vietnam, including members of denominations not officially recognised by the government. But Nguyen Thanh Xuan of the governmental committee for religious affairs disagrees.
”The U.S. based its conclusion on wrongful information and therefore could not see the total truth,” he argued. ”Washington needs to remove Vietnam from the ‘countries of particular concern’ list.”