Saturday, November 21, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The U.N. Security Council, quick to condemn the deployment of child soldiers, has been slow in approving a draft resolution that seeks to penalise those who systematically abuse children in the world’s war zones.
The resolution, which calls for travel restrictions on government and insurgent leaders and the imposition of an arms embargo, has been kicked around the Council chambers since last February.
"I keep hearing that the resolution is imminent," says Casey Kelso, director of the London-based Coalition to Stop the Use of Child Soldiers.
"But what we hear from diplomatic sources in New York is that negotiations are extremely slow and difficult," Kelso told IPS. "We don’t expect anything concrete in the near future."
Last week, in an editorial titled ‘Children in Combat’, the Washington Post was equally critical of the slow pace of the ongoing negotiations.
"Perhaps fearing the specificity of these recommendations, the Security Council has not yet developed a resolution based on them," the editorial said.
But U.N. Under-Secretary-General Olara Otunnu, while conceding there is a delay, points out that the draft resolution is still under negotiation because the 15 members of the Security Council have sought clarifications and are studying the implications of some of the proposed penalties.
Otunnu, who is the U.N. Special Representative for Children and Armed Conflict, says the Security Council has already expressed its intention to take "concrete and targeted measures" against those found guilty of abusing children.
"It is most important that the Council make good on its promise on this occasion," Otunnu told IPS. "On that depends the credibility of this exercise."
"The imposition of carefully calibrated and targeted measures can have the desired impact on governments as well as insurgents," he added.
Besides travel restrictions and arms embargoes, Otunnu has also proposed a ban on military assistance, restrictions on the flow of financial resources, and the exclusion of government and insurgent leaders from any governance structures and amnesty provisions.
According to one diplomatic source, these far reaching penalties have to find unanimity among the 15 members before the draft resolution can get off the ground.
"It’s a tough call," he said, "but it also a valid excuse for the Security Council to drag its feet over the draft resolution."
Otunnu said that although overall figures have decreased over the last few years, there are still more than 250,000 children who continue to be exploited as child soldiers – used variously as combatants, porters, spies and sex slaves.
"Tens of thousands of girls are being subjected to rape and other forms of sexual violence, including as a deliberate tool of warfare," Otunnu said.
Since 2003, over 11.5 million children have been displaced within their own countries, and 2.4 million children have been forced to flee conflict and take refuge outside their home countries.
Otunnu also said that about 800 to 1,000 children are killed or maimed by landmines every month. In the last decade, over two million children have been killed in conflict situations, and over six million seriously injured or permanently disabled.
In a report to the Security Council in February, Otunnu listed 17 situations of "grave concern" relating to children, and also named 54 offending parties, including governments and rebel groups.
The 54 include either government forces or rebel groups – or both in some cases – in countries such as Burundi, Cote d’Ivoire, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Somalia, Sudan, Colombia, Myanmar, Nepal, the Philippines, Sri Lanka and Uganda.
Kelso said his Coalition to Stop the Use of Child Soldiers has been asking Security Council members for support to adopt "an incremental approach to sanctions".
"Our research indicates that the continuing flow of weapons, particularly small arms, to parties recruiting and using child soldiers helps to perpetuate this abuse of children," Kelso told IPS.
He said the Coalition wants the upcoming resolution to incorporate a ban on the provision of small arms, other military equipment, or military assistance to parties using children in conflicts – specifically in Cote d’Ivoire, the Democratic Republic of Congo, Somalia and Sudan.
This involves the Council adding an end to child recruitment and use as a condition for the lifting of already existing sanctions, he added.
Kelso also said that the recent referral of war crimes in Sudan to the International Criminal Court (ICC) in The Hague is a great step forward in demanding accountability, but more can be done now.
Rima Salah, deputy executive director of the U.N. children’s agency UNICEF, has already made a strong case for ICC involvement. "The time has come to subject those who recruit and use child soldiers to the full force of national legal systems and the ICC," she told the Security Council last February.
Salah also said that the Security Council "has the ability to take decisive action to protect children in situations of armed conflict by translating the commitments of international legal and other standards into action."
In the past, Kelso said, the Security Council has shown "true leadership" in the adoption of three previous resolutions that have urged governments to consider "legal, political, diplomatic, financial and material measures" against those using child soldiers (Resolution 1379 – Nov 2001); called for consideration of "additional measures for parties that fail to demonstrate progress" in ending this abusive practice (Resolution 1460 – Jan 2003); and expressed intent to consider imposing "targeted and graduated measures", including arms embargoes, against parties that refuse to take steps to release children from their ranks (Resolution 1539 – Apr 2004).
"This year, however, there is a change: a reticence to follow through on threats to actually impose sanctions," Kelso said.
At recent lobbying meetings, "we’ve been told that ‘adding extra elements such as an end to the use of child soldiers will be seen to be moving the goal posts and that would not be helpful to the resolution of an ongoing conflict’, and that it is ‘unrealistic’ to expect a Security Council resolution backing up three years of condemnation with such follow-up action," he added.
Kelso said that member organisations of his Coalition – including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch and Save the Children Alliance – are now urging the Security Council to adopt concrete measures, including strengthening arms controls against those forcing children to kill and be killed in war.