Development & Aid, Europe, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines, Poverty & SDGs

DEVELOPMENT: EU Urged to Show Its Muscle

Stefania Bianchi

BRUSSELS, Sep 13 2005 (IPS) - Development groups here are demanding that the European Union uses its “political muscle” to guide negotiations toward concrete measures to implement the Millennium Development Goals at the UN summit of world leaders later this week.

As three European Union (EU) commissioners – José Manuel Barroso, president of the EU executive, Louis Michel, commissioner for development and humanitarian aid, and Benita Ferrero-Waldner, commissioner for external affairs – and several Europeans heads of state and governments head to New York for the summit starting Thursday, several international non-governmental organisations (NGOs) say Europe’s leadership is “key” to a successful meeting.

In a joint statement, the NGOs ActionAid, Oxfam, Eurodad and Eurostep say the EU must make full use of its political muscle to get an agreement over crucial commitments to poverty reduction, human rights and the protection of civilians.

The EU commissioners told media representatives that the bloc would keep its promise to help developing countries meet the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). These include specific goals to reduce poverty and disease and to promote education by 2015. They were agreed at the UN Millennium Summit in 2000.

“The 2005 UN World Summit is a unique opportunity to show Europe’s determination to keep our promises to the developing world and to bring others with us,” said Barroso.

“At the UN summit I will urge the developed world to follow the EU’s lead – to match our Everything But Arms initiative, match our readiness to fix a date to abolish agricultural subsidies and match our commitment to doubling aid,” he added.


Ferrero-Waldner said the three main themes of the meeting will be development, security and human rights.

“You cannot truly have any of these things without the other. And you cannot achieve any of these without effective multilateral cooperation. This is why proposed reforms of the UN are so important and we are talking about how to make world safer, fairer and more secure,” she said.

Michel acknowledged that the discussions in New York would be difficult, but remained optimistic about the outcome of the talks.

“At the end of this week I hope that we will be able to come back saying that the international community and major donors have raised theirs ambition and that the EU has set an example. Sometimes we’re accused of lacking in leadership but I believe that our imprint will be found in the final document,” he said.

The initial aim of the summit, which will bring together 191 countries, 175 of them represented by heads of state or heads of government, was to review progress on meeting the MDGs. But security, terrorism and UN reform will now feature strongly at the meeting.

The “outcome document” still contains strong statements on fighting poverty, but development groups fear that some countries are determined to water down this draft, and that the summit will result in failure.

They are particularly concerned that Pakistan, Egypt, Russia, India and the United States are among the states that seem determined to block or water down a proposal on governments’ “responsibility to protect civilians” that could stop genocides such as that in Rwanda.

“Governments must agree collectively to protect civilians facing large-scale atrocities such as genocide and ethnic cleansing. There is no space for negotiation here as the lives of millions of people living in war zones are at stake. The EU must make its voice heard and convince countries like the U.S., Egypt, Russia, India and Pakistan to support such a crucial move by the UN,” said Luis Morago, head of the Oxfam office in Brussels.

The EU is the leading trade power, the biggest aid donor, and provides 35 percent of the budget of the UN. The NGOs insist the EU has both the political weight and responsibility to reduce the gap between rhetoric and practice by influencing the decision at the UN summit.

“The EU has sought to claim moral leadership on the efforts to eradicate poverty and achieve the Millennium Development Goals. For this stance to be credible, EU leaders must deliver on their promises and ensure that the outcome of the UN World Summit is consistent with their rhetoric,” said Simon Stocker of Eurostep.

“None of the commitments made in 2000 will be reached unless the EU ensures that the UN declaration includes a strong commitment to development, and an explicit acknowledgement that additional efforts are required by all governments,” added Louise Hilditch, international policy director at ActionAid International.

Eurodad, the European network on debt and development, is calling on the EU to take collective action to ensure that the outcome document is ambitious on debt..

“Debt burdens that prevent countries from investing in the MDGs should be cancelled, and it is vital these principles be reflected in the outcome document,” said Gail Hurley, Eurodad’s policy and communications officer.

Concord, which represents several European relief and development NGOs, is also urging the EU to ensure the setting of a clear timetable to reach the long-promised target of 0.7 percent of gross national income (GNI) for development aid, and to “avoid the diversion of development funds away from poverty eradication and towards other objectives.”

It also is calling for the EU to guarantee that at least 70 percent of official development assistance (ODA) is spent in low-income countries. It wants the EU to support the full and immediate cancellation of bilateral and multilateral debts of the poorest countries, to improve aid effectiveness by fully untying aid to all developing countries, and in the short term to implement innovative mechanisms to raise resources for development such as international taxation.

Concord is urging the EU to reinforce the position of the international financial institutions and the World Trade Organisation (WTO) within the framework of the UN and to advocate a reduction in the “disproportionate influence” of the IMF and the World Bank.

“On 14 September, the spotlight will be on world leaders. They need to wake up to poverty and deliver their promises. In Europe, civil society organisations, like ourselves, will closely observe the results of the UN negotiations and monitor their follow-up,” the group said.

 
Republish | | Print |