Friday, November 20, 2026
David Cronin
- Pakistan is the world’s seventh largest country but it does not receive a proportionate level of attention from European Union officials dealing with foreign relations.
Between now and 2013, Pakistan, where a third of 161 million inhabitants live in poverty, is set to receive 200 million euros (266 million dollars) in EU aid. Though significant, this pales in comparison to the Union’s total allocated expenditure on development assistance of 40 billion euros (53 billion dollars) over that period.
Alain Délétroz from the International Crisis Group, an organisation working on conflict prevention, says that the Union has also been “silent” on human rights abuses in Pakistan following the dismissal of Chief Justice Ifikhar Mohammad Chaudry in March.
He says that Pakistan has been viewed by EU policy makers as a security matter, given its proximity to Afghanistan and allegations that al-Qaeda and Taliban members are active on Pakistani soil. As a result, the Union has tended to leave deliberations over how Pakistan should be handled to the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation, which also has its headquarters in Brussels.
Délétroz is calling on EU foreign ministers meeting in Luxembourg Jun. 18-19 to condemn the crackdown on dissent by Pakistani authorities. This has included the mass arrest earlier this month of political activists protesting new legislation giving the country’s military ruler President Pervez Musharraf a greater say in regulating the media.
Délétroz also believes that the Union should closely monitor general elections due later this year.
“It is time for the EU to raise its voice,” he told IPS. “If it doesn’t do anything, it will look ridiculous.”
Choudry was removed from his position by Musharraf for alleged misuse of his authority. This sparked fierce protests from lawyers who insist that Musharraf did not have the power under the national constitution to sack a judge in this way.
Among the subsequent events that have destabilised Pakistan were the killing of 50 people, when armed party workers loyal to the Islamabad government blocked Choudry’s arrival in Karachi May 12 to address a demonstration called by barristers.
Amnesty International, meanwhile, stated in its newly published annual report that scores of Pakistanis suffered arbitrary detention and enforced disappearance during 2006. At least 446 people were sentenced to death and 82 executions were carried out last year, a sharp rise on 2005.
Musharraf was initially shunned by the EU when he took power in a 1999 coup. Yet his declared willingness to cooperate in the U.S.-led ‘war on terror’ following the Sep. 11 attacks in New York and Washington led to something of a rethink.
In November 2001, Belgian Prime Minister Guy Verhofstadt signed a cooperation agreement with Musharraf on a visit to Islamabad as head of the EU’s rotating presidency. The agreement contained a clause committing the country to respect for human rights and democracy.
A Pakistani human rights activist said that the EU’s engagement with Pakistan has not led to improvements on the ground. An EU team monitoring allegedly rigged elections in 2002 made a series of recommendations for democratic reform. “None of these recommendations have been implemented,” said the activist, speaking to IPS on condition of anonymity. “There is no sign that the government is trying.”
The activist complained that the only real interest of EU policy makers with regard to Pakistan concerns its policies towards Islamic militants, particularly in areas bordering Afghanistan, and its dispute with India over the province of Kashmir.
“We haven’t seen much interest by the EU in Pakistan,” the activist added. “You can’t look at Pakistan through the prism of Afghanistan or Kashmir. Pakistan itself needs the EU’s full attention.”
Despite his pledges to undertake democratic reforms, Musharraf has refused to allow two leading Pakistani politicians, Nawaz Sharif and Benazir Bhutto, return to the country so that they can participate in elections.
After Indonesia, Pakistan is the world’s largest Muslim nation. A woman human rights activist said that persecution of those who adhere to other religions is growing. “I had never heard of the forced conversion of non-Muslims until recently,” she said. “But now I’m hearing about it. This present regime is not seriously working against violent extremism. Musharraf must be told to take off his uniform.”
But a spokeswoman for Pakistan’s embassy in Brussels said that the question of Choudry’s dismissal is a judicial one, as he is now challenging his removal from office in the Supreme Court.
“The media in Pakistan has full freedom,” the spokeswoman said. “We have 45 independent TV channels operating. It was a decision of the Supreme Court, not the government, to ask journalists not to comment on this case as it is sub-judice.”
The spokeswoman also said that the Islamabad authorities would have “no problem” with allowing the EU send election observers to the country.