Headlines, Human Rights, Middle East & North Africa, North America

RIGHTS: U.S. Court Throws Out Suit by Child Camel Jockeys

Carmen Gentile

MIAMI, Jul 31 2007 (IPS) - A U.S. judge in Miami has ended – for now – a group of lawyers’ quest to sue two leaders from Dubai for allegedly enslaving thousands of children and forcing them to participate in camel races, a sport that dates back a millennium or more in the Middle East.

Judge Cecilia M. Altonaga decided Monday to throw out the case, saying her court had no jurisdiction, despite arguments by the plaintiffs that the case could be tried here because the defendants have interests in racehorses in the Miami area.

“Because the court concludes that it lacks personal jurisdiction over the identified defendants, it does not reach or address the merits of the other arguments raised,” said Judge Altonaga in her ruling.

Earlier this month, she openly questioned whether her court had jurisdiction in the case, while reserving her final decision for Monday. “None of the parties, none of the interests, none of the defendants are here,” said Judge Altonaga.

Lawyers for the defendants would not comment Monday on the ruling other than to say they were looking into other options and that they could appeal the judge’s decision to dismiss the case.

The attorneys for the former child jockeys – some now in their 40s – could seek to bring the case to the U.S. state of Kentucky, where the Dubai leaders were served with papers for the suit and also have thoroughbred horses.


Representing an estimated 10,000 children and their families, most hailing from Bangladesh, Mauritania, Pakistan and Sudan, the plaintiffs’ lawyers sought to sue Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al Maktoum, ruler of Dubai and the prime minister of the Emirates, and his brother Sheikh Hamdan bin Rashid al Maktoum, deputy ruler of Dubai and the country’s finance and industry minister, for unspecified damages.

The case against the Dubai brothers first came before a U.S. district court judge in Miami earlier this month. Lawyers for the defendants urged Judge Altonaga to throw out the case, saying the U.S. court has no jurisdiction on this matter.

The plaintiffs disagreed and used a 218-year-old law to bring their clients’ fight to U.S. shores. Under the Alien Tort Statute, federal courts can have jurisdiction over certain civil cases implicating foreigners.

The law has previously been invoked in dozens of cases, including a lawsuit against the U.S.-based oil and gas corporation Unocal for human rights abuses in Burma, and a landmark case against a Paraguayan police official for kidnapping and torture during the Alfredo Stroessner dictatorship.

Richard Samp, a lawyer with the conservative Washington Legal Foundation, a self-styled defender of “the principles of freedom and justice,” according to the group’s mission statement, has called the lawsuit against the sheiks “frivolous”.

“I know nothing about the facts other the events alleged to have taken place have nothing to do with the United States,” Samp said. “It is wholly inappropriate to make our courts judge standards that are applied throughout the world.”

Amid calls from the Washington Legal Foundation and others for the Florida judge to throw out the case, officials at the Justice Department said they were looking into the allegations and whether they want to play a role if the case goes to trial.

Justice officials would not comment on Monday’s ruling.

Meanwhile, lawyers and representatives of the Dubai leaders have noted that a programme headed up by UNICEF is already working to return the boys and men home and reunite them with their families, providing them with all the compensation they need for the cruel practice. The use of child camel jockeys was forbidden by law in the Emirates in 1993.

“This misguided lawsuit isn’t about solving a problem. We’re already helping the boys who used to work in camel racing,” said Habib Al Mulla, a representative of Sheikh Mohammed and Sheikh Hamdan.

Efforts by UNICEF and the UAE government aren’t enough, the plaintiffs’ lawyers contend, noting that cruelty against the boys extended well beyond races.

According to a State Department reported in 2005: “Camel jockeys are often sexually and physically abused”, including children as young as three years old, and are starved to keep their weight down for racing.

Lawyers for the boys also denounced assertions by Al Mulla that the South Carolina-based class action law firm Motley Rice was merely trying to “mine a new source of fees.”

In an interview with The New York Times last month, a lawyer with the firm said the case was not about collection money, but an effort to “right wrongs that have been committed.”

“It’s not about the money. It’s about exacting some form of justice,” said John Eubanks, who later admitted his firm will collect a fee if the case is won.

Following the hearing earlier this month, Eubanks told IPS that Judge Altonaga was “extremely even-handed” in her discussion of the issue and “didn’t give a quick impression about which way she was leaning.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags