Climate Change, Economy & Trade, Environment, Europe, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

CLIMATE CHANGE: EU Car Makers Have a Long Road Ahead

David Cronin

BRUSSELS, Aug 2 2007 (IPS) - Over the next few months, members of the European Parliament (MEPs) will mull proposed limits on the amount of greenhouse gases emitted by the traffic that clogs up the continent’s roads each day. If the experience so far this year is anything to go by, the MEPs will almost certainly be heavily lobbied by car makers determined to avoid measures that could prove vital in fighting climate change but which they deem too costly.

Soon after MEPs sitting on the assembly’s environment committee return from their summer holidays, they will resume deliberations to bring down the level of carbon dioxide (CO2) released from a car to 120 grams per kilometre (120g/km).

This has been an official target of the European Union since it was included in a 1996 strategy document. Yet despite a growing body of scientific evidence suggesting that climate change must be urgently tackled, the environment committee suggested in June that the date for realising the target should be extended until 2015. That would be three years later than a deadline supported by a separate committee in the Parliament, dealing with industry matters.

Although MEPs might like to portray themselves as defenders of the environment, some have been willing to recite almost verbatim the arguments put forward by car makers. The assembly even has a cross-party grouping called the Forum for Automobile and Society. One of its most active figures, German Liberal Jorgo Chatzimarkakis, has made plain his desire to have the 120g/km target weakened. “We will not completely dismantle this proposal but we will shape it in such a way that it will protect both the climate and the car industry,” he has said.

Earlier this year, car firms from his country scored a significant victory.

Whereas the EU’s executive, the European Commission, had indicated that it was going to propose that the 120g/km target should be made legally binding, it eventually recommended a less ambitious goal of 130g/km in February. The Commission has suggested that the 120g/km goal could be achieved through additional measures, which the industry could take on a voluntary basis.

The Commission’s volte-face followed a joint campaign mounted by DaimlerChrysler, BMW and Volkswagen. DaimlerChrysler predicted that the original target would make it impossible for it to continue manufacturing luxury vehicles. As a result, 65,000 jobs would be lost in the cities of Bremen, Sindelfingen and Unterkürkheim, it warned.

Environmental activists regard such tactics as scaremongering.

“There seems to be a consensus that everything that is good for the environment is bad for industry,” Jos Dings, director of the European Federation for Transport and Environment told IPS. “The only reason for this perception is that the car industry has been extremely vocal. It can get its message out loud and clear, while suppliers and those who would benefit from tighter rules to sell cars have more or less been forced to be silent.

“It’s a phenomenon we constantly see here in Brussels that the only ones we hear are those who see regulation as a threat, not the ones who will benefit. This enormously distorts the debate.”

The car industry has a considerable presence in Brussels’ ‘European quarter’, as the area where the most powerful EU institutions are located is known.

Corporate Europe Observatory, a group monitoring the power that industry wields over the Union’s policy makers, estimates that car firms have at least 70 people working full-time on EU affairs in Brussels. This figure does not include the various umbrella groups dealing with distribution, supply and dealership, who also have headquarters in the Belgian capital.

By contrast, the number of transport specialists working for non-governmental organisations (NGOs) may not exceed single figures. Greenpeace, perhaps the best-known ecological organisation in Europe, does not have any transport expert in its Brussels office but is due to hire one shortly, according to its spokeswoman.

With its vast resources, the car industry has also been able to make use of outside help, particularly from public relations firms. WeberShandwick, one of the largest PR agencies in Brussels, has been hired to work for DaimlerChrysler, Renault and Volkswagen. Other firms with car industries as their clients include Cabinet Stewart, Burson Marsteller, Arpi, Athenora and Clan Public Affairs.

Yet the European Automobile Manufacturers Association, known by its French acronym ACEA, denies that it can bend the ears of officials and politicians more effectively than ecologists can.

“It is a misconception that we have more influence than anyone else,” ACEA spokeswoman Sigrid de Vries said. “On climate change the environmental NGOs reign over the public arena and influence public opinion. This is not a David versus Goliath struggle.”

Most car makers have a long distance to travel before they will have reached the targets under discussion.

The European Federation for Transport and Environment has calculated that in 2005 only Fiat had succeeded in reducing emissions from its vehicles to 139g/km, the goal set by the EU for 2008.

Whereas Citreon and Renault were making good progress towards meeting that goal, BMW, Volkswagen and Audi were among the worst laggards.

The performance of car makers from some of the EU countries with the best reputation in protecting the environment has been found wanting, too.

In 2004, the average CO2 emissions from a car driven in the 15 countries that formed the Union at the time was 163g/km. In Sweden, however, the average emission level stood at 196g/km.

Some 40 percent of cars on Swedish roads are made by just two companies: Saab and Volvo. The latter is active in Brussels, especially in enticing policy makers to events that it hosts and sponsors. Many MEPs are listed as speakers at the Volvo-funded European Transport Forum, scheduled for Sep. 18-19.

Karim Harris, a policy officer with Climate Action Network Europe, says that such events can be viewed positively as they indicate the car industry is willing to engage in debate.

“The approaches of the car industry have been contradictory in some respects,” she told IPS. “Generally, it has acknowledged that there has to be a movement towards energy efficiency. But when it comes to legislation about this, it has been pretty strong in putting its foot down and in not wanting the legislation to be too ambitious.

“I don’t think we have seen the paradigm shift that we would like to see in the car industry yet. But our approach is not to be exclusive, we don’t believe that we shouldn’t sit down with our so-called enemies. We do make a general effort to speak to the car industry and our experience with these kind of lobbyists is that that they are not overly antagonistic. There are lobbyists here in Brussels who realise that the tide is turning and not necessarily in their favour.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags