Friday, November 20, 2026
David Cronin
- Air travel needs to be quickly included in a European Union programme for addressing climate change if pledges on curbing greenhouse gas releases are to be kept, a new study has found.
Since 1990, emissions of carbon dioxide have more than doubled from flights taking off in EU airports, making aviation the Union’s fastest rising contributor to global warming.
But despite that exponential growth, aviation has been granted exemption from the EU’s Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS), under which industries are given limits to the amount of pollution they may cause.
In December last year, the European Commission proposed a law to end the exemption for aviation. Yet all flights leaving and entering EU airports would only be brought within its scope by 2012, under the Commission’s plan.
A report published Sep. 4 concludes that 2012 would be too late, and urges that the date should be brought forward by at least two years. As EU passenger numbers are growing by 6-7 percent per year, aviation emissions in 2012 could be as much as 60 percent higher than 1990 levels.
Prepared by the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research at the University of Manchester, the study suggests that EU policy makers are “deluded” if they believe that the ETS will help honour a pledge made by the Union’s governments earlier this year to ensure that the earth’s temperature does not increase by more than two degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels.
“The current ETS proposal on aviation must be significantly strengthened so as to both drive down emission growth rates and force the adoption of more efficient aircraft technologies and operation,” said Kevin Anderson, director of the Tyndall Centre’s energy programme.
As well as bringing the date for including aviation in the ETS forward to 2010, the report advocates that permits on emitting a certain level of carbon dioxide should be auctioned to airlines, rather than being given to them for free. This would differ from the Commission’s plan to give 97 percent of such permits without charge, based on the past environmental performance of airlines.
Environmental campaign groups are also arguing that only those airlines that improve the energy efficiency of the technology used to fly their planes by 3.5 percent each year should be allowed to buy carbon permits from other sectors of industry.
And they are lobbying for a new Europe-wide approach to air fares. This would be designed to make the cost of booking a flight reflect the environmental impact of aviation by introducing a tax on kerosene, the fuel used in aircraft, as well as subjecting air travel to a value added tax (VAT).
“Including aviation in the Emissions Trading Scheme would be one first step,” Matthias Duwe from Climate Action Network Europe told IPS. “It needs to be part of a series of policies.”
Although Europe’s aviation sector used to be dominated by state-owned carriers, they have been challenged in more recent years by the proliferation of no-frills budget airlines. Ryanair, Europe’s leading budget carrier, has admitted that it has been given preferential treatment from some regional authorities so that it can operate in their airports at low cost. On that basis, Ryanair decided in 2001 to make Charleroi, an airport in an economically depressed part of Belgium, the hub for its European operations.
In a report on the economics of climate change prepared for the British government last year, Nicholas Stern from the London School of Economics identified the rise of low-cost airlines as especially problematic because they encourage “frivolous” travel.
“Airlines enjoy all kinds of little privileges that stem from another era, where national governments were trying to build up their national operators,” Duwe added. “This is extremely antiquated.”
During the autumn, members of the European Parliament (MEPs) will discuss numerous amendments to the Commission’s 2006 proposal on the ETS. The final shape of the revised scheme is then likely to be approved by the Union’s 27 governments in 2008.
Chris Davies, a British Liberal MEP, is calling on his colleagues to insist that the scheme is strengthened.
“The Commission’s plans to bring aviation into the Emissions Trading Scheme hardly scratch the surface of the problem and will not come close to delivering the necessary cuts in emissions,” he said.
Major airlines are seeking that an emissions trading scheme should be global, rather than restricted to the EU, so that European carriers are not put at a competitive disadvantage to those in other parts of the world.
David Henderson, spokesman for the Association of European Airlines, said he did not see “what could be gained” by bringing aviation into the ETS earlier than previously envisaged.
He said that airlines will oppose efforts to increase their tax burden. “A well-designed ETS should mean that taxation will not be necessary,” he told IPS.
But Richard Dyer, aviation campaigner with Friends of the Earth, said that the EU needs to have a comprehensive approach to air travel that will include curbs on the expansion of airports.
“Current proposals to include aviation within the EU Emissions Trading Scheme are a totally inadequate response to the threat that the growth in aviation emissions poses to efforts to tackle climate change,” he said. “MEPs and EU ministers must show vision and leadership and substantially strengthen the aviation ETS during the legislative process this autumn.
“Other political measures are also needed to tackle the growing climate impact of flying. This should include VAT on air tickets, a tax on aviation fuel and opposition to new runways.”
Friends of the Earth is calling for rail to be promoted as a feasible and more environmentally friendly alternative to air travel. It points out that half of the top ten destinations served by London’s airports could be reached if the high-speed train connections between Britain and continental Europe are improved.