Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

AUSTRALIA: Softening of Refugee Policy Gets Cautious Welcome

Bob Burton

CANBERRA, Dec 5 2002 (IPS) - Refugee support groups have cautiously welcomed a softening of hardline policy towards asylum seekers by Australia’s major political parties, but say Canberra needs to do more to uphold the rights of children who arrive with parents seeking asylum.

”The heartening thing is that both Labour (opposition) and the government to a degree, have shown they are responding to the community campaign,” said Howard Glenn, national director of Australians for Just Refugee Programmes.

On Thursday the leader of the Australian Labour Party (ALP), Simon Crean, announced the ALP would no longer support the ‘Pacific Solution’ under which asylum seekers arriving in Australian territorial waters were shipped to Nauru and Papua New Guinea for the processing of their refugee claims.

The ALP has also backed the closure of the Woomera detention centre in the South Australian desert, the site of major protests and hunger strikes by frustrated asylum seekers earlier this year.

”It is a big victory for our campaign’s first stage. The campaign to get the government to change its behaviour and convincing the alternate government (who are) the architects of mandatory detention to change their policy has been a great victory. The fight now will very clearly be with the government,” said Glenn.

While the ALP’s softening of its policy has been welcomed, its refusal to abolish the mandatory detention of asylum seekers has angered many within and outside the ALP.

Instead, the ALP proposes to allow families with refugee claims to be accommodated in low-security hostel-style detention centres while claims processing is done within 90 days.

In another controversial move, Crean announced that the ALP would maintain its support for excluding the remote Christmas Island from Australian immigration legislation, thereby denying asylum seekers appeal rights they would otherwise receive on mainland Australia.

Christmas Island, a remote part of Australia off the northern coast, is the most common arrival point for boats carrying asylum seekers travelling from Indonesia.

The Refugee Council of Australia also cautiously welcomed the policy but expressed its concern about the exclusion of Christmas Island from the immigration legislation.

”The announced policy does not address all of the issues about which we have concerns, but it does represent a very big step in the right direction,” the Council said in a statement.

Despite senior ALP members opposing both mandatory detention and the removal of Christmas Island from Australian immigration legislation, Crean emerged from a party room meeting victorious on Thursday.

”There are still differences within the party and these were argued out today. But those differences have been resolved by the adoption by Caucus (the ALP parliamentary members) of the document,” Crean told journalists.

The ALP’s caution reflects the need to respond to the dramatic growth in support for the Australian Greens over the last year. Greens leader, Bob Brown, dismissed the announced ALP changes as still leaving refugees locked up ”as if they were criminals”.

At the same time the ALP is wary that its new immigration policy would leave it open to accusations by the government coalition that it is being soft on ”illegal” immigrants.

Government’s exploitation of the racially charged issue in the lead up to last year’s general elections saw many working class Labour supporters back the government’s tough stance on asylum seekers.

On Tuesday, in a bid to pre-empt the ALP’s announcement, the Minister for Immigration, Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs, Phillip Ruddock, told parliament of changes to departmental procedures that would now see unaccompanied children generally being ”moved quickly to an alternative place of detention”.

The government policy on the detention of children of asylum seekers has also been under challenge this week in a series of hearings before the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission.

Australian Human Rights Commissioner, Sev Ozdowski, said on Monday that the objective of the hearings beginning this week is to determine ”the extent to which the Commonwealth has met the principles of the Convention of the Rights of the Child with respect to children in immigration detention”.

Appearing before the inquiry, the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs defended the imprisonment of children.

”The department takes seriously Australia’s international human rights obligations, including those contained in the Convention on the Rights of the Child … In all but a limited number of cases it is likely to be in the best interests of children to remain with their parents in detention,” it submitted.

”Refugee support groups are hopeful that the next softening of government policy will be to release parents and their children into community-based accommodation while their applications for asylum are processed,” said Glenn.

”With over 100 children still in maximum security detention – only half of whom are getting schooling, as the minister admitted this week – our immediate focus is to channel the community outrage about that and force a change,” he added.

While encouraged by the changes, refugee support groups see major challenges ahead.

”The big issue for next year is the treatment of refugees who have been here on (three-year) protection visas. We fear that the government will engage in mass deportation of these people,” Glenn warned.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines, Human Rights, Population

AUSTRALIA: Softening of Refugee Policy Gets Cautious Welcome

Bob Burton

CANBERRA, Dec 5 2002 (IPS) - Refugee support groups have cautiously welcomed a softening of hardline policy towards asylum seekers by Australia’s major political parties, but say Canberra needs to do more to uphold the rights of children who arrive with parents seeking asylum.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags