Friday, November 20, 2026
David Cronin
- The European Union’s humanitarian aid policy does not draw a sufficiently clear distinction between responses to emergencies and longer-term development assistance, a new report has concluded.
During 2006, the EU provided more than 2 billion euros (2.7 billion dollars) in humanitarian aid, making it the biggest donor of emergency relief in the world.
Although such aid is reported to have provided comfort to 100 million people, a new European Parliament report contends that the purpose of humanitarian assistance should be outlined more precisely than it is at present.
Thierry Cornillet, a French Liberal member of parliament who drafted the report, said that the “time and space” of humanitarian aid has to be defined.
Cornillet’s paper responds to a proposal put forward by the EU executive, the European Commission, in June for a consensus between the Union’s principal bodies on the key principles relating to humanitarian aid.
While Cornillet has endorsed the broad thrust of the Commission’s blueprint, his report contends that there are “structural weaknesses” in how the EU handles humanitarian aid. He alleges, for example, that there is a dearth of cooperation between the Commission’s humanitarian office and its directorate-general for environment.
Because climate change is triggering a growing number of disasters, Cornillet also contends that there should be an increase in funding for disaster risk reduction measures in both the Union’s programmes related to humanitarian aid and development assistance.
Europe’s main network of emergency relief groups has echoed this call.
Voluntary Organisations in Cooperation in Emergencies (VOICE) is urging that 10 percent of all new humanitarian aid should go to disaster risk reduction.
The question of disaster risk reduction achieved international prominence in the wake of the December 2004 tsunami which caused immense damage in south-east Asia. The lack of a properly functioning early warning system in the region is widely believed to have left local communities ill prepared for the calamity.
An international strategy for disaster reduction drawn up by the United Nations has estimated that the global cost of dealing with emergencies could be as high as 300 billion dollars per year by 2050.
Kathrin Schick, director of VOICE, said it is vital that funding for disaster risk reduction will not be at the expense of existing humanitarian aid. “This must not take away money that is supposed to be used to save lives,” she told IPS.
But she also argued that risk reduction should be integrated into other forms of aid such as that for education programmes. Children in earthquake prone countries need to learn how they should duck under their tables if a tremor occurs, she noted.
A European Commission official acknowledged that there is room for improvement in humanitarian aid activities funded by the EU.
This was witnessed as recently as the past few weeks, when international donors encountered difficulties in providing adequate shelter to victims of the Aug. 16 earthquake in southern Peru. The official said that more groundwork is required for ensuring better coordination between donors, as well as in having emergency supplies in place to cope with disasters.
The official admitted, too, that bureaucratic hurdles can hinder a smooth transition between emergency relief and longer-term development. Whereas the Commission has devoted considerable time to studying the links between humanitarian and development aid, it has found that different procedures apply to each. “We find ourselves in a situation where we are doing humanitarian actions longer and longer in transition, when it could be argued that humanitarian aid should be kept short-term,” the official explained.
Nirj Deva, a British conservative member of the European Parliament (MEP), said that the Commission has been “brilliant” in responding swiftly to disasters. Yet he complained that it lacked an effective “interface” between ECHO and its sections dealing with international development.
Deva contrasted natural disasters and those caused by mankind, such as the conflict in Sudan’s Darfur province that have dire consequences for civilians.
“One of the most important things the EU can do is make sure we are able to have some sort of sanctions for breaches of international humanitarian law,” he added. “In countries where you have genocide – like in Sudan – sanctions should be automatic, so that every time something happens you do not reinvent the wheel.”
But Swedish MEP Anders Wijkman said there is a “blurred distinction” between disasters that may appear different in character on the surface.
“Many of the so-called natural disasters are to a large extent man-made,” he said. “Maybe it would be wise to pay a little more attention to climate change and what is likely to happen and what humanitarian organisations will be facing in the next decade.”
Former U.S. president Bill Clinton has used the slogan ‘build back better’ as part of his campaigning on humanitarian issues following the Indian Ocean tsunami.
Yet Wijkman said that most “rebuilt communities” in areas affected by the tsunami are as vulnerable now as they were before the disaster struck. “Most areas were not built back better,” he said.
German Green Frithjof Schmidt said the Union should insist that food aid is only used as an emergency measure in humanitarian aid. He noted that a U.S. tendency of giving food aid over lengthy periods has been blamed for having adverse effects on local economies, thereby undermining the livelihoods of farmers in poor countries.