Thursday, November 19, 2026
Interview with Donatella della Porta, expert on social movements
- The peace march from Perugia to Assisi Oct. 7 brought back some memories of the massive march against the war in Iraq in 2003.
"I am cautious in talking about a crisis," says Donatella della Porta, professor of sociology at the European University Institute in Florence, and long-term observer of peace movements in Italy and abroad. "There is a drop in participation, but the movements have taken other forms."
Della Porta and her team have conducted a major research called Demos on the European social movement and participatory democracy from below, interviewing activists at earlier peace marches. The results were presented at the United Nations of the People meeting in Perugia in central Italy Oct. 6.
IPS journalist Stefania Milan spoke to della Porta at the end of the Perugia-Assisi peace march.
IPS: Some say the Italian movement is going though a crisis: is that true?
The global alter-mobilisation movement has been active since 1999: it is normal to register a drop in mass mobilisation after eight years. In Italy in particular the mobilisation was strongly linked to the abnormal right-wing government of Silvio Berlusconi. After the last elections that brought a change at the top, mobilisation has dropped.
The period 2001-2002 was an exceptional phase in Italy, with demonstrations gathering one or two million people. Recently there have been new occasions to mobilise, against the conversion of the dismissed airport Dal Molin in Vicenza into a United States military base, or against the high speed train in the Susa Valley. But even if there are occasions for mobilising, activists have become more selective.
IPS: What has changed?
DDP: Nowadays protest cycles work differently: they are more frequent but far less dramatic. So, the movement is not much focused on street protest: activists are engaged in a range of different activities, for instance the promotion of fair trade.
A lot of organisations remain active, but at a different level. They have got a bit professionalized, and are no longer only movements organisations. We are not in an acute phase determined by a concrete risk: cycles of protests have ups and downs, but now downs are less deep than in the past. Also, movements have become far less dependent on national contexts, which is still relevant, but less than in the past.
IPS: What is the effect on mobilisation of the left-wing government, that many consider a "friendly government"? Some argue that people are not taking the street to avoid protesting against the government they have elected…
DDP: There is an attempt at co-opting by the government, in particular by some parties such as the former communist party Rifondazione Comunista, coupled with more timidity among some organisations, like unions and some NGOs that have support within left-wing parties. But there seems to be a more autonomous attitude growing slowly, and gradually the movement is becoming less dependent, starting with the unions.
IPS: Over the last years, the Italian movement seems to have become a collection of "no": "No Tav" (in opposition to the high speed train in the northern Italian valley of Susa), "No Bridge" (against the planned bridge connecting Sicily to the mainland), "No Dal Molin" (against the creation of a United States military base in Vicenza), "No Triv" (against an oil plant in the Noto Valley, in Sicily). What are the features of the "no" movements?
DDP: The "no" is used as a rhetorical tool. Movements have derived it from the labels attached by external observers and the media. But these are not just movements that oppose something. They seem to be reactive and not proactive, given the perception of the pressing danger they face. They are born as "no" but, behind the "no" to some giant infrastructure or military base, they tend to defend some "yes": yes to environment protection, yes to sustainable development.
They are accused of suffering from the NIMBY syndrome, where NIMBY stands for "Not In My Backyard". But they tend to become NOPE movements, "Not on the Planet Earth": they shift from a self-definition of oppositional movements to proposing what should be done instead, elaborating alternatives of development or democratic participation.
IPS: What are the issues now in the movements' agenda?
DDP: The issue of water as a public good and the issue of peace are central in the movements' agenda in Italy. A third tier is the reflection on what democracy means and how to make democratic processes more participatory. Also, opposition protests such as the No Dal Molin and No Tav have at their back a criticism of democratic processes and an attempt to create alternatives.
IPS: What are the challenges for Italian movements in the near future?
DDP: Current movements are networks between diverse groups, and thus have a weak collective identity: they must think about forms of internal democracy capable of working effectively despite the weak identity. Secondly, Italian movements must think through the role of what is called a "friendly" government and how to interact with it. Indeed, many groups would define it as "enemy", not "friendly", but somehow they are still shy. Thirdly, movements need to think about how to have a real impact on political decisions: it is particularly relevant at a moment like this of declining mobilisation.