Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Sarah O'Hara
- In 1937, when the Irish Constitution was written, it gave recognition to “the special position” of the Catholic Church.
By voting narrowly on the weekend in favour of introducing divorce – the margin was 9,000 votes – the Irish people have made a break with the Church, analysts here say.
The outcome also marked a divorce between church and state, and removed an anomaly between the Catholic Church and the law.
For the Church has itself officially recognised the ending of marriages, and given permission to couples to marry again when the Church determined this was appropriate. It granted annulments to thousands of Irish couples.
However any person from an annulled marriage who remarried was committing bigamy in the eyes of the state. In another anomaly, foreign divorces were recognised here. Irish people could also go abroad to get divorces, which were then recognised by the state here.
Liberal commentator Mary Holland hailed Saturday’s decision as a sign of maturity on the part of the electorate. Irish people were no longer exporting their problems, she said.
The margin of victory – announced at 6.45pm on Saturday – was originally only 7,000 votes. So narrow that the Government ordered a recount, anticipating such a move by the anti-divorce campaigners, The recount added an extra 2,000 votes to the Yes side.
This means that 50.28 percent of the Irish people have voted for divorce, versus 49.72 percent against.
“The Irish people made a warm-hearted decision,” the leader of one of the three ruling parties, Proinsias De Rossa of Democratic Left, said after the result was announced on Saturday evening. “Eight hundred and eighteen thousand people voted in favour of compassion.”
Of the 2.16 million adults eligible to vote, 1.6 million turned out on Friday to vote.
But pundits have warned that the vote to introduce divorce finally – in the only state in the European Union where it was banned – should not be seen as marking a new era of pluralism.
In an article in the liberal Irish Times published Saturday, Fintan O’Toole anticipated a narow result. “Whatever the result of the referendum,” O’Toole wrote, “it would be a mistake to see it as a decisive turning point.
“It will be neither a turning back towards a confident assertion of a conservative and secure Catholic identity, nor a confident step into a new era.
“The debate has revealed conservatives to be extraordinarily pessimistic about the future, seeing Irish society as so fragile that it could be destroyed by changing a single clause in the Constitution. And it has shown modernisers that their own optimism is contradicted by the existence of a deeply divided and anxiety- ridden society around them.”
The debate was conducted in terms of the right to remarry for those whose marriages had broken down irretrievably versus the effects on society if “a divorce culture” were introduced.
Thirteen years ago, the Irish people had voted to remove “the special position” of the Catholic Church from the constitution. Now they have faced up to the “concrete” implications of their 1972 vote, according to Declan Kiberd, a newspaper columnist and lecturer in literature at University College Dublin.
“It is simply a catching-up exercise with their earlier vote in 1972,” Kiberd told IPS.
Tom Glennon, the political correspondent of the Irish Independent, described the referendum as “a defining moment in the relationship between the politicians and the Catholic Church”. For the first time, all the major political parties had been united in supporting the introduction of divorce.
In the last referendum on divorce in 1986, which was defeated, the largest party in the state, Fianna Fail, had been “neutral”. (Officially, it was “neutral” while many of its parliamentary representatives had campaigned against divorce.) Nine years ago, the people voted 63% against removing the constitutional ban on divorce.
This time around, the leader of Fianna Fail, Bertie Ahern, backed the divorce campaign. Ahern himself is one of the 80,000 Irish people who are separated. The support of Fianna Fail was seen as key to getting the referendum passed.
But the vote in favour of divorce shows a chasm between the thinking in the countryside where most people voted No and the cities where most people voted Yes. To put it in geographical terms, less than a third of the areas of Ireland voted Yes to divorce. Only 16 of the Republic’s 41 constituencies recorded a majority Yes vote.
A 19-year-old science student, Michael D., who comes from the rural constituency of the prime minister, John Bruton, told IPS he had voted No for social reasons.
“I was worried that if divorce was introduced then abortion would be next. And then we’d be the same as America and England. We’d have no morals at all!” He is proud that his county, County Meath, voted No by a big majority.
Bruton, who is also the leader of Fine Gael, had argued for a Yes vote on the basis of a separation between Church and State. The prime minister greeted the narrow result with a conciliatory statement.
“We will have to address the anxieties that led to the size of the No vote and try and strengthen the family,” Bruton said at the weekend.
The Government urged a Yes vote – a move that was successfully challenged in the Supreme Court, on the grounds that it was undemocratic to fund only one side of the argument just days before the vote.
Now anti-divorce campaigners are considering whether to mount a legal challenge to the vote on the basis of the funding. The chairman of the No Divorce Campaign and a former High Court judge, Rory O’Hanlon, said that their side would have won — if like the Government they had received money to fund their campaign.
Chairman of the Anti-Divorce Campaiagn, Des Hanafin. who is also prominent in Fianna Fail, said he hoped his group would challenge the decision. “It’s not over till it’s over,” said Hanafin.