Environment, Europe, Headlines

EUROPE-ENVIRONMENT: Dithering EC Leaves Nuclear Ball in the Air

Shada Islam

BRUSSELS, Oct 12 1995 (IPS) - The European Commission, seeking to avoid a head-on confrontation with France, has once again put off a key decision on whether to sanction Paris for refusing to supply data on its nuclear tests in the South Pacific.

Critics say the European Union’s executive is guilty of political cowardice for failing to act on the matter. They say this has undermined its credibility and could have serious long- term repercussions on its ability to deal with member countries which breach Union rules.

At a meeting in Strasbourg on Wednesday, Oct. 11, the 20-member European Union executive asked France to provide it with further information on the nuclear tests and said it will hold a special meeting in Brussels on Oct. 23 to review the case.

The Commission’s handling of the affair has been fiercely criticised by Greenpeace, the environmental organisation, and members of the Socialist group in the European Parliament.

Pauline Green, leader of the Socialist bloc, has warned that the Commission’s credibility is now “on the line.”

Greenpeace activists, who let off a loud siren at the European Parliament’s buildings in protest at the Commission’s decision to postpone any action against France, has denounced the EU executive as the “lapdog” of the French Government.

The environmental organisation said that the Parliament and the member states should take the Commission to court for its failure to act. Legal proceedings should also be started against France for breaching the EU Treaty, Greenpeace said.

“The role and the very existence of the European Commission must now be seriously questioned in the light of its failure to censure France’s nuclear testing programme, despite blatant breaches of European law,” the organisation said in an angry statement.

“The Commission’s own analysis clearly identifies major violations of the treaty. The Commission’s failure to take (French President Jacques) Chirac to task is a purely political decision,” Greenpeace’s Louise Gale stressed.

France’s decision this summer to resume nuclear testing in the South Pacific has been a source of deep embarrassment to its EU partners and to the European Commission whose President Jacques Santer has made it clear that he is personally opposed to the tests.

Several EU governments have urged France to stop the tests, arguing that the policy is ruining the EU’s standing and reputation in the Asia Pacific.

The European Commission is deeply divided on the issue. Environment Commissioner Ritt Bjerregaard, who is from staunchly anti-nuclear Denmark, believes that the Commission should use article 34 of the European Treaty to stop the French nuclear tests.

But, the EU Treaty can only come into play if France provides the Commission with the technical information it needs to establish if the tests could have “particularly dangerous” repercussions on the health and safety of people living in the South Pacific.

So far, France has refused to provide all the details concering the tests. Commission experts who visited the region last month said in a report that Paris’s refusal to allow access to radioactivity monitoring sites on Mururoa Atoll and to the nearby Fangataufa Atoll had made it “impossible to give an unreserved view on the efficiency and adequacy of the overall surveillance system.”

The experts said that data on the “geological and hydrological” aspects of tests were withheld, as were details on their long-term effects.

“If testing is so safe, why is France trying to hide the scientific findings on environmental impacts? ” Greenpeace’s Louise Gale asked.

Officials say that Commissioner Bjerregaard wants to start legal proceedings against France and has been straining at the leash to send Paris a warning letter, the first step in any future court action against the country.

Bjerregaard is believed to have the support of almost half of the European Commission. But, insiders say others in the EU executive are unwilling to cross swords with France on a sensitive defence and military issue.

Most EU Commissioners are unwilling to step the agency’s limited legal authority, especially on military questions which are still a matter for national governments.

Proposals to draw up a common European defence and security policy will be discussed next year as part of the inter- governmental conference on institutional reform.

There is concern that France and Britain could use the conference to try and trim the European Commission’s powers. If the Commission engages in a controversial legal battle with France, Paris will almost certainly make such a demand.

Commission President Jacques Santer told the Parliament that the Commission was “carrying out its duties seriously, but it takes time.”

But, critics say that while the Commission ponders over future action, Paris may explode a third nuclear device in the South Pacific, following up the tests on September 5 and October 1.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags