Asia-Pacific, Development & Aid, Headlines | Analysis

FOOD-CHINA: Taking a Serious Look at Food Security

Analysis - Yojana Sharma

HONG KONG, Oct 9 1995 (IPS) - China insists its grain problem has not reached crisis proportions, but several studies warning of a looming grain shortage in the world’s most populous nation have prompted Beijing to take a hard look at long-term food security.

Last year Chinese economists were shaken by an article entitled ‘Who Will Feed China?’ by U.S. environmental economist Lester Brown, head of the Washington-based Worldwatch Institute.

Brown said the world faced “the shadow of global scarcity in human history for the first time” because of the growing demand for grain from China with a burgeoning population whose standard of living is improving.

China has to feed more than 20 percent of the world’s population with only seven percent of its arable land.

Assuming the current low population growth of 13 million new Chinese mouths to feed each year and no further improvements in the Chinese diet, China will need to import all the world’s grain exports of 200 million tonnes by the year 2030, he said.

And what if China’s economy continues to improve? China now consumes 300 kg per head of grain per year compared to 400 kg per head in Taiwan and 800 kg in the United States.

If China reaches the Taiwan level of consumption by 2030 it will need to import 370 million tonnes — nearly twice as much as is currently available on world markets.

The Worldwatch report had prompted swift denials from China, which questioned its figures and methodology and declared “China will feed itself.” Beijing issued memorandums saying every province must become self-sufficient in grain without providing the wherewithal to achieve this goal.

But the months that followed saw some hard, realistic thinking in China. “For the first time China is taking a more considered look at the whole issue of longer term food security,” noted one Beijing-based diplomat.

As recently as six months ago the official view was that China would be a net grain exporter this year. Now the discussion is not just how much grain China will have to buy to tide over the shortfalls caused by natural calamities — drought in the north and floods in the south — but how much it will have to buy over the next decades.

This year’s National People’s Congress plenary in Beijing warned: “China is facing a looming grain crisis, with a rise in imports the only apparent solution to the demands of a growing population on a shrinking farmland.”

Last week the official ‘China Daily’ quoted two senior researchers from the prestigious Chinese Academy of Social Sciences in Beijing as saying the balance between grain supply and demand would be “fragile” at best in the near future.

Han Yu and Yu Xian of the Academy’s Institute of Rural Development warned high population growth in some regions meant grain supply and demand “will not be balanced” unless governments at all levels use their increased tax revenues to support farm production and growth.

They predicted a rain shortfall of 40 million tonnes by the year 2000 and 50 million tonnes by 2020.

Last month a study by China’s Agriculture Ministry and Japan’s Overseas Economic Cooperation Fund echoed the Worldwatch report saying China’s increasing wealth would mean a rise in demand for meat, causing a shortage of grains for animal feed.

It said China should develop its grain production and transport infrastructure to head off a shortfall of some 23.84 million tonnes by 2000 increasing to 136.31 million by 2010.

Whatever the exact size of the predicted shortfall, Brown’s report had a very big effect in Beijing, says Lei Xilu, a Beijing- based agronomist. “It has forced the government to devote more investment to agriculture.”

In the past administrative measures were geared towards placating disgruntled peasants and ensuring that just enough was done to keep the lid on any discontent in the countryside which could erupt into open unrest.

“It was not a policy on agricultural production as such, despite the lip-service paid in Beijing to improving agriculture,” says one agronomist.

According to analysts here, Beijing has taken note not just because of the figures being bandied around or even the question of “who will feed China”, but the spectre of famine which plagued China till well into the 1960s, killing millions.

The crux of Brown’s argument was that arable land was being converted to non-farm uses and grain yields were nearing their maximum, making it difficult to raise productivity to meet the upcoming challenge.

But a cold hard look at the problem has elicited a considered Chinese response which is more than just a public relations exercise geared towards refuting Brown’s thesis.

“China’s grain problem is not one of shrinking agriculture but simply a slight decrease in grain production,” said Lu Mai of the State Council’s Research Centre for Rural Development. “The country has 14 million hectares of farmland which should be sufficient to produce enough grain to feed the population.”

“As long as the government can raise its purchasing price to the level of the market price and remove the ‘border blockades’ among the different provinces, farmers can benefit from shipping the products directly from the production sites to consumption sites,” he said, adding farmers also need to be given enough incentive to remain in agriculture.

And yields must be improved through technology. In April the ‘China Daily’ reported China will replace all crop species “deemed to be outdated” with new strains of rice, corn, wheat and cotton over the next five years to meet the farm production target over the next decade.

The Agriculture Ministry plans to plant high-yielding cross- bred maize on 18.7 million hectares of land and some 50 strains of fine wheat on 3.3 million hectares of arable land by 2000.

Even overseas there are many who believe China can still expand its grain production. “With higher yielding seeds, better management and additional inputs, yields should rise,” says a U.S. Department of Agriculture report. “They haven’t come close to hitting the ceiling.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags