Headlines

MSG055G/01E BRAZIL: Proposed Social Security Reform a Political Risk

Mario Osava

RIO DE JANEIRO, Feb 25 1995 (IPS) - The Brazilian government has decided to run the political risk of promoting a major reform of the social security system – a move that will bring it head-to-head with specific sectors and the population in general.

The highest-impact measure would eliminate retirement for years worked, replacing it with a minimum age of about 60 years.

Brazilian men may currently retire after 35 years of work and women after 30. Proportionately reduced benefits are available for those who work five years less than the periods specified.

Numerous “special cases” would also be eliminated. Teachers, journalists, Members of Parliament, pilots and people subject to unhealthy working conditions are currently entitled to full retirement after 25 years or less.

Because most of the past generation entered the workforce at a young age, many members of these professions retire in their early 40s, often earning a second pension at another job.

The plan would eliminate priviliges and easy routes to paid retirement, which is seen as incompatible with Brazil’s economic reality and long life expectancy, said Social Provision Minister Reinhold Stephanes.

Defending the reform in frequent debates, Stephanes cited the life expectancies of 80 years for members of the armed forces and 73 years for minimum wage labourers.

The minister, who retired at the age of 46, uses his own case as an example of the “absurdity” of the current regulations.

Brazil’s low birth and death rates and long life expectancy contribute to rising unemployment and a broader informal sector, causing a growing imbalance in the social security system.

Stephanes and President Fernando Henrique Cardoso stressed that reform today is indispensable to avoid a collapse of the system tomorrow, and “to assure everyone’s right to retirement in the future.”

Authorities warn that the system has reached a dead end. In 1980, 3.18 people made social security payments for every one already drawing a pension. Ministry officials say the ideal ratio is four to one, but the rate had fallen to 2.5 to one by 1990.

Brazil’s 15.2 million pensioners are expected to increse to nearly 23 million in the next 10 years.

When Cardoso vetoed a congressional proposal to raise the national minimum wage, he noted that well over half the current retirees receive minimum wage, and that an increase would raise the deficit already predicted for 1995.

The proposed reform, to be submitted to Congress in two weeks, calls for a single regulation for men and women, with at least 38 to 40 years of work required for full retirement at the minimum age – to be set at about 60 years.

Furthermore, a maximum pension of five to 10 times the minimum wage would be established, and people would be encouraged to complement their benefits through private insurance companies.

Like Brazil’s economic recovery plan and tax system, the reform has already met with strong opposition, especially from the union movement, with some threats of strikes and protests.

Brazil’s leading labour organisation demanded a clause that would keep the changes from affecting the current workforce.

Economist Paulo Nogueira Batista Junior of the opposition Labour Party warned the government against risking the popularity it won by introducing a new currency in July.

He advised that the government focus its efforts on the not-yet consolidated economic stabilisation plan rather than spreading itself too thin on fronts that could wait a while longer.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags