Monday, November 16, 2026
Analysis - Johanna Son
- Two years after setting its lofty goal of lifting all trade and investment barriers by 2020, a bloc of 18 Asia-Pacific economies is facing the toughest test yet of its free- trade mettle.
After talking about grand plans for a virtually borderless economy from North America to South-east Asia, members of the Asia- Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) forum this week are to submit detailed plans on implementing that vision starting Jan 1, 1997.
This should be the most concrete step yet that APEC members will take in a journey that began with the vision of an Asia- Pacific community set in Seattle, United States in 1993, a 2020 deadline for free trade set at the 1994 summit in Bogor, Indonesia, and an action plan agreed on in Osaka, Japan in 1995.
Extracting from its members bold schedules in reducing tariff rates and opening markets has not been easy, especially since the process is voluntary, and coincided with elections in countries like the United States and Thailand.
Thus, Philippine President Fidel Ramos, host of this year’s APEC meetings, last week sent out letters to 17 fellow leaders asking them to make substantial commitments to open markets in a bid to ensure the meeting does not remain an annual talkfest.
He wants APEC members to present bold tariff reduction plans or individual action plans (IAPs) to be collectively called the Manila Action Plan For APEC 1996. “This will serve as APEC’s road map to the 21st century,” Ramos said.
But the challenge does not lie only in the free-trade momentum, which businessmen would like to speed up but which activists say is already proceeding at too fast a pace.
The seven-year-old APEC faces growing pressure to go beyond trade and investment as its driving force and to heed the concerns of developing countries undergoing free-trade pains.
The tug-o-war over APEC’s future direction is due in part to a membership that includes developed and developing economies with different state policies. APEC has 40 per cent of the world’s population, accounts for 56 per cent of world production and 46 per cent of merchandise trade.
APEC’s members are Australia, Brunei, Canada, Chile, China, Hong Kong, Indonesia, Japan, South Korea, Malaysia, Mexico, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, Philippines, Singapore, Taiwan, Thailand and the United States.
The twin concerns in APEC — pursuit of free trade and sustainable development — have given rise to debates on how to strike the right balance between them.
Indeed, APEC’s free-trade goal has not produced as much controversy as it has in the Philippines in the months leading to the annual meeting of APEC ministers this week and the leaders’ summit at Subic Bay freeport on Nov. 25.
Asian activists held anti-APEC meetings at the 1995 APEC summit in Osaka, but the deluge of protests in Manila are getting as much, if not more, space in the local press. At least four parallel international conferences, hosted by rival activists, are to be held in the country over the next week.
It does not help that individual action plans deal with tedious details like tariff rates and schedules, and no longer the headline-grabbing visions of APEC’s past few years.
One group, the Manila People’s Forum on APEC, placed newspaper ads that branded “true lies” statements by the government that APEC is a ticket to global competitiveness. Another group, the Asia-Pacific Sustainable Development Initiative (APSUD), warns against “U.S. style, undirected, cowboy liberalisation”.
APSUD succeeded in getting the Philippine government to insert in its individual plan, language stressing sustainability, which says it says could curb an overzealous push toward free trade.
Success in getting more language on sustainable development in the Philippine document, leaders’ statement and other APEC documents would help curb APEC’s free-trade bias in succeeding summits to be hosted by Canada next year and Malaysia in 1998, Dan Songco of APSUD said.
“This is the opening we want the Philippines to provide” in taming APEC’s free trade push, he added.
On the free-trade front, the Philippine government wants to preside over a Manila Action Plan For APEC that would exceed commitments under the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and project APEC as a pacesetter in trade liberalisation at the WTO’s first ministerial meeting in Singapore next month.
“Once APEC, which has developed as the most dynamic region in the world, achieves regional liberalisation and then goes on to call for greater liberalisation on a global scale, its influence will grow tremendously,” said Taro Nakayama, a former foreign minister of Japan.
But even Filipino officials concede that new and drastic reductions of tariff barriers are not forthcoming, prompting a search for new initiatives to set this summit apart.
In recent weeks, Manila has launched a bid asking the seven- member Association of South-east Asian Nations (ASEAN), of which the Philippines is a member, to extend to APEC tariff concessions it is pursuing in the ASEAN Free Trade Area.
Said a Filipino diplomat: “ASEAN should take the lead in trying to accelerate free trade and investment.”
Ramos also urged APEC members to endorse a U.S.-proposed agreement to eliminate tariffs on information technology by 2000, an initiative Washington is pushing at the WTO meeting.
Drafts of the individual action plans of APEC members leaked to the Press earlier this month show that earthshaking tariff reductions are unlikely.
Many Asian governments repeated commitments already in effect under other free-trade efforts or under WTO, and others did not have specific numbers, said Walden Bello of the Manila People’s Forum on APEC, which leaked the individual action plans.
The United States has largely played it low-key in APEC this year, after pushing free trade to the top of the forum’s agenda when it hosted the Seattle summit in 1993. Elections this year also prompted the Bill Clinton administration to steer clear of controversial trade initiatives.
Bello says this shows that despite their rhetoric, countries will continue to use trade policy to suit national interests.
The Philippines also wants to leave its mark at this year’s APEC meetings by among other things, pushing a framework on ‘economic and technical cooperation’ that focuses not only on trade and investments, but on social costs that come with free trade.
Ramos says APEC has to nurture ties beyond geography and free trade, and “develop a culture for solving problems out of a deep sense of obligation to build a community of APEC economies”.
“However important trade and investments are, they do not encompass the whole APEC agenda,” said Roberto Romulo, chair of the APEC Business Advisory Council that groups businessmen from the 18 APEC economies.
Buffeted by different, at times conflicting, pressures, APEC’s agenda and identity is far from complete at this point. Debates about its priorities and pace show that many questions that have dogged it since its creation in 1989 remain unresolved — and will likely remain so for some time yet.