Friday, November 20, 2026
Julio Godoy
- Maritime measures to prevent spills from oil tankers will be off the agenda at the G8 meeting due in June.
Japan scuttled a German proposal to list the issue on the agenda, according to documents from preparatory discussions among environment ministers of the eight countries. The Russian delegation is reported to have backed the Japanese objections.
Environmental ministers from the G8 countries were meeting in Paris over this weekend to discuss the environment issues that need to be taken up at the G8 meeting.
Leaders from the G8 countries (Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, the United Kingdom, the United States, and the Russian Federation) are due to meet in Evian in France June 1-3.
The environment ministers "are not in a position to prejudge the discussion by G8 leaders in Evian," Japanese officials are reported to have argued.
Japanese officials strongly opposed a ban on single hull frame oil tankers at the preparatory talks. They also opposed proposals to place greater legal responsibility on ship owners and on oil companies renting the ships.
These issues have become a prime concern among European environmentalists, governments, and fishermen since the oil tanker Prestige sank in Spanish territorial waters last November.
The Prestige, a single hull frame oil tanker carrying some 77,000 tonnes of oil, sank November 19 about 300 kilometres northwest of the Spanish coast. Oil spills from the Prestige polluted hundreds of kilometres of the Spanish and French Atlantic coasts, and led to a temporary trade ban on seafood from the regions.
The disaster followed the accident involving the Erika in December 1999. The wreckage of the Erika spilled about 20,000 tonnes of oil on to the French Atlantic coasts.
The Erika was also a single hull ship. Both the Prestige and the Erika were manufactured in Japan.
"The Japanese position at the preparatory meetings was to block any initiative to enhance maritime transport safety," Helene Ballande from Friends of the Earth told IPS.
The German proposal had read: "The G-8 countries agree that the heavy grades of oil shall only be transported in double-hulled tankers. Members shall undertake not to accept single-hulled tankers carrying the heaviest grades of oil into or out of their ports, terminals or anchorage areas."
The Japanese delegation argued: "Drastic elimination of single-hulled tankers may have a serious impact on the shipping industry and stable energy supply, and such an economic impact needs to be duly considered." They said "specific measures (to enhance maritime transport safety) should be flexible, because national circumstances should be taken into account."
The Japanese delegation opposed inspections of tankers at ports, controlled navigation in narrow waters, and a requirement to report evident defects in ships and deficiencies in the performance of crews to authorities. It asked for deletion of a paragraph on "strengthening of liability rules" from any declaration at the G8 summit.
"The documents show that the Japanese government wants to weaken every commitment the G8 environmental ministers intend to make on maritime transport," Ballande said. "Under the present liability regime mandated by the IMO (International Maritime organisation), oil companies chartering unsuitable vessels do not carry full responsibility for the transport of oil."
The Spanish government says the Prestige spill has so far cost more than a billion dollars. Under the present liability regime, the maximum compensation for victims from the wreckage is only 180 million dollars. This sum does not cover environmental liabilities.
"The G8 countries are home to most of the world’s multinationals," Ballande said. "The G8 governments are the most responsible for exploitation of the world’s resources and must deliver rights for communities to redress environmental crimes by multinationals."
Several environmental organisations such as Greenpeace say the G8 is an "an illegitimate forum" to treat issues of world interest.
The summit is due to take up development in Africa, privatisation of water, good international governance and the ethical responsibility of private enterprises. Under strong pressure from the U.S., terrorism will be an important subject to be taken up at the summit.