Saturday, November 21, 2026
Thalif Deen
- The world’s poor would be better served if money that is currently being wasted on sparsely attended, U.N. economic policy meetings were spent directly to meet their needs, according to a member of the U.S. delegation.
Rather than abandoning these costly, high-level meetings, other diplomats argue, more should be done to encourage better representation from member states and the international financial institutions that shape global economic policy.
Ambassador Melinda Kimble of the U.S. delegation said last week’s meeting of the Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) on the Bretton Woods institutions — the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) — was disappointing primarily because of poor attendance.
The six-hour meeting of the U.N.’s highest economic policy- making body, she pointed out, cost about 30,000 dollars. The 5,000- dollars-per-hour cost included interpretation in six of the U.N. languages — English, Spanish, Chinese, French, Russian and Arabic.
“But was the money well spent?” Kimble asked.
According to World Bank estimates, she said, homeless in developing countries could be housed at a cost of between 23 dollars and 150 dollars. “That meant that 200 people could have been housed with the 30,000 dollars spent on the meeting,” she added.
The heads of both institutions — IMF Managing Director Michael Camdessus and World Bank President James Wolfensohn — failed to attend, as did Renato Ruggiero, the director-general of the World Trade Organisation (WTO).
All three opted to attend the meeting of the Group of Seven industrialised countries in Lyons, France.
The U.N. meeting was expected to address international trade and global economic policies, as well as increased collaboration between the United Nations and the Bretton Woods institutions
The Bank was represented by a vice president and the IMF by a deputy managing director. “There was no explanation for the lack of representation by WTO,” Kimble said.
“How could the United Nations have a policy dialogue with the IMF, World Bank and WTO without participation by their heads,?” asked one Third World diplomat, speaking to IPS on the condition of anonymity.
“Both the Bank and the IMF,” he complained, “have a tendency to ignore the United Nations, although they are sister institutions.”
Sven Sandstrom, Managing Director for Corporate Planning and Resource Management of the World Bank, said Wolfensohn “had very much wanted to attend the Council’s high-level policy dialogue, but could not because of illness.”
Prabhakar Narvekar, deputy Managing Director of the IMF, expressed regrets at the inability of Camdessus to join the Council’s deliberations “due to commitments in Europe.”
Ambassador Ahmad Kamal of Pakistan, a former ECOSOC president, also criticised the lack of high-level representation at the meeting.
Kamal expressed disappointment that the heads of IMF, World Bank and WTO could not attend the current session. “Their absence,” he said, “may diminish the work of the Council.”
His government, Kamal said, had several questions for which he was seeking clarification, particularly from the WTO. He explained that he wanted to question WTO officials, who have been placing a great deal of stress on capital mobility, what they are doing to place the issue of labour mobility on the global agenda.
Additionally, he said he had intended to ask when the WTO was going to include environmental and humanitarian clauses in multilateral trade regimes.
In his capacity as ECOSOC president last year, Kamal was critical of poor representation at its meetings. The Council, he said, has “not fired the imaginations” of U.N. ambassadors or government ministers.
Member states, he said, are required to send decision-makers to ECOSOC meetings, who, at the political level, should be ministers, and in their absence, ambassadors. But meetings, he noted, are regularly attended by low-level diplomats.
“The level of attendance at almost all meetings has remained disappointingly low, with part of the time being lost in paying mere lip service to ideas of reform and revitalization, and the rest of the time being devoted to stubborn and unimaginative rejection of each other’s ideas on reform even they are good or unexceptionable,” he said.
Kamal said there was little evidence of any shared sense of urgency or of any consensus that economic development is indeed going to be a central part of the agenda of the next century.
“The whole thing adds up to an ECOSOC which is living in an Alice-in-Wonderland charade of business as usual,” he added. “Meanwhile, the whole world burns on the bonfire of poverty and debt and lost economic opportunities.”