Asia-Pacific, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

POLITICS: India, Israel in ‘Anti-terrorism’ Tango

Commentary - By Praful Bidwai

NEW DELHI, May 22 2003 (IPS) - India and Israel, for decades on opposing sides of the fight for Palestinian statehood, are set to become close strategic allies.

If the Indian government, led by the ultra-conservative Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), has its way, the two states would join the United States in forming ”the core” of an all-new, unique, ‘democratic’ alliance to fight ‘international terrorism’.

To this end, New Delhi has invited Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon on an official visit in the second week of June – at a time when most Western governments would hesitate to extend such an invitation and thereby endorse Sharon’s extremely hardline approach to the Palestinian crisis.

However, it is by no means certain that either a Sharon visit or the U.S.-India-Israel anti-terrorism ‘axis’ will materialise anytime soon. After last week’s suicide-bomb attack in Jerusalem, Sharon has cancelled his visit to the United States.

There are too many likely impediments to the formation of the proposed triangular alliance, including the United States’ reluctance to antagonise other allies, including Pakistan and the Arab states.

Above all, there is likely to be stiff popular resistance within India to any strategic axis which centrally involves Israel. Most political parties have sharply criticised the proposed triad. And the larger public is likely to assert itself. Civil society opinion cannot be easily ignored.

The U.S.-India-Israel axis was proposed by India’s national security adviser Brajesh Mishra in Washington on May 8. Significantly, Mishra was addressing the annual meeting of the American Jewish Committee (AJC), a Zionist group considered the single most powerful lobby in the United States and active for nearly a century in shaping a staunchly pro-Israel policy in Washington.

White House chief of staff Andrew Card also addressed the meeting. Among the audience were several U.S. congressmen and Spanish Prime Minister Jose Maria Aznar, known for his proximity to President George W Bush and support for the war on Iraq.

Mishra outlined his proposal while lavishing praise upon the AJC and ”celebrating” the ”alliance of free societies” in combating global terrorism. He said, ”The U.S., India and Israelà face the same ugly face of modern-day terrorism”.

Therefore, ”a core, consisting of democratic societies” must ”take on international terrorism in a focused manner (to) ensure that (that) campaign is pursued to its logical conclusion”.

Mishra urged that the U.S.-Israel-India ‘triad’ should form the core of such a ‘democratic’ alliance, which would have ”the political will and moral authority to take bold decisions”. He added: ”Stronger India-U.S. relations and India-Israel relations have a natural logic.”

Mishra attacked what he called ”diversionary arguments”, in particular the ”motivatedly propagated” fallacy that terrorism can only be eradicated by addressing its ‘root causes’. This is nonsense”. What is needed are measures like ”blocking (terrorists’) financial supplies, disrupting networks, sharing intelligence, simplifying extradition procedures”.

This view parallels the right-wing, Likud-led Israeli government’s approach, which disconnects ‘terrorism’ from ‘root causes’ like its illegal occupation of Palestinian territory.

Mishra’s proposal is the culmination of growing political-military contacts between India and Israel since full-scale diplomatic relations were established in 1992.

India’s BJP-led government has elevated these contacts to a high level over the past five years. Since 1999, Mishra, Home Minister Lal Krishna Advani and Foreign Minister Jaswant Singh have visited Israel. India is now one of the world’s biggest buyers of Israeli weapons.

Even more important than the military contacts has been collaboration between the American Jewish Committee and pro-BJP lobbies of Indians settled in the United States known for their ”long-distance” nationalism. Indian-Americans are the United States’ richest ethnic minority, consisting almost entirely of affluent professionals.

Over the years, they have with the AJC’s help established the Congressional India Caucus, with as many as 160 members – the largest single-country group in the House of Representatives.

The ‘axis’ proposal represents a new kind of India-Israel intimacy. It is based on a certain notion of ”terrorism”. For the Sharon government, all forms of resistance to the Israeli occupation, whether peaceful civil disobedience or indiscriminate armed attacks on civilians, are tantamount to ”terrorism”.

Through the ‘axis’ proposal, New Delhi has endorsed this notion – and in effect condemned the Palestinian struggle for statehood, to which it pays lip service.

This is a major break with past policy and India’s full-throated support for numerous Non-Aligned Movement resolutions expressing solidarity with the Palestinian cause. India maintained close relations with the Palestine Liberation Organisation for decades – until the Arafat leadership got marginalised following the collapse of the Oslo Accords.

New Delhi’s motives in building a special strategic alliance with Israel are threefold.

First, it wants to marginalise Pakistan and offer itself as an especially important ally of the United States by endearing itself to Washington’s pro-Likud Zionist lobby. This is something Pakistan cannot do.

The ‘axis’ could help India claim pre-eminence in the U.S. scheme of things for South Asia and reap potential benefits as the United States’ junior partner, especially in the ‘war on terror’.

Second, the ‘special alliance’ will help the Hindu-sectarian BJP in further polarising Indian society along religious lines.

So far, the Palestinian cause has attracted broad-based secular support in India. But after the war on Iraq, many Muslims feel alienated and discriminated against. Right-wing Hindu extremists allied to the BJP revel in this, some supported the Iraq war, which polls show that over 85 percent of Indians opposed.

An India-Israel alliance will probably widen the gap – to the BJP’s political advantage.

Third, the BJP is genuinely fascinated by the highly militarised nature of Israeli society and its state’s willingness to use massive force against the Palestinians, and by the jingoism and machismo of Likudists like Sharon.

Some BJP leaders have the same contempt and hatred for India’s religious minorities as Sharon has for the Palestinian people. This was in evidence last year in Gujarat, where 2,000 Muslims were massacred in a pogrom.

Some Hindu ideologues are also driven by Islamophobia to posit a historic ‘civilisational’ alliance between Hinduism and the Judeo-Christian tradition against Islam.

The ‘axis’ has dire implications not just for India’s foreign policy, but for its domestic politics too. Besides globally aligning India with conservative and ethically indefensible forces, a special alliance with Israel will be a blow to secularism and pluralism domestically.

The ray of hope is that this will be resolutely opposed by the Indian public.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags