Development & Aid, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

UNITED NATIONS: U.N. Reform Sparks North-South Confrontation

Thalf Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Oct 18 1997 (IPS) - U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan’s wide-ranging proposals for restructuring the ailing United Nations threaten to trigger a rancourous North-South debate and put the entire reform exercise in jeopardy.

The United States and the 15-member European Union (EU) want the reform package adopted as a whole within a limited time frame – and with no significant cuts.

The Western view, which also reflects those of Annan, was best expressed by British ForeignSecretary Robin Cook who said that member states should accept “Annan’s package as a package.” “If they start to pick apart what they don’t like, the whole package could fall apart,” he warned.

But the 132 developing countries of the Group of 77 and the 116- member Non-Aligned Movement – collectively representing more than two-thirds of the membership of the world body – are refusing to be rushed into a hasty decision and are seeking to dissect the package line by line.

“It is our firm view that all the proposals on reform should be discussed in detail and transparently in a format that will allow the widest and most effective participation of all member states, especially those with small delegations,” Ambassador Timothy Bandora of Tanzania said, speaking on behalf of the Group of 77.

When the 185-member General Assembly met informally last week to discuss the reform package for the first time, the meeting was not only held behind closed doors but the President of the Assembly Hennadiy Udovenko of Ukraine also made sure there were “no records, press releases or sound recordings” of the discussions. This exercise was meant to ensure that delegates could be candid and forthright in their comments – and still change their minds later, if they so desire, since there is nothing on record to nail them down.

Addressing the meeting, Ambassador Ahmad Kamal of Pakistan set the stage for a possible North-South confrontation when he criticised the attempt “to steamroll the Secretary-General’s proposals through a so-called ‘package’, and this within a short time frame of a few days.” “This will not be possible or acceptable…” he warned.

The package, introduced in July, includes propoals for the creation of a U.N. Development Group, a Deputy Secretary-General, a new Office of Development Financing, a Department for Disarmament and Arms Regulation, a system of multi-year pledges for development cooperation, and a one-billion-dollar U.N. Revolving Credit Fund to assist cash-short member states to help pay their U.N. dues on time.

Additionaly, the package also includes proposals to rationalise and streamline U.N. operations both at headquarters and in the field, and the creation of a Senior Management Group and a Strategic Planning Unit that will enhance accountability in the U.N. system.

“I ask all of you to move expeditiously to consider the package of reforms that is before you, with the aim of reaching political consensus and providing budgetary authority before this session ends (in December),” the Secretary-General told delegates in September.

“Reform may be gradual, but it should not be piecemeal,” he said responding to member states who are seeking to dilute his package by selectively picking some proposals while rejecting others.

Annan admitted that while some of the proposals have to be aproved by the General Assembly, there were several he could implement on his own authority. The former include a set of 15 “recommendations” he has made to the Assembly, and the latter a series of 29 “actions” he plans to take himself. But the Pakistani envoy said that some of the “actions” that Annan plans to take will still have to be approved by the U.N.’s Budgetary Committee and then voted by the General Assembly making it virtually impossible for Annan to get a free ride.

That is why, said Kamal, “an imposed and hasty time-frame cannot be accepted, as has been clearly stated by the Non-Aligned Movement and the Group of77.”

“It is obvious that the time-frames will differ from proposal to proposal. Some, in fact, will go through very quickly, others will take more time for their consideration, and some may not go through at all,” he told the closed-door meeting.

While admitting that reform could well be the central focus of the General Assembly this year, Kamal said “reform cannot be hasty or ill-considered, nor canit be based on anything other than the most widely-held consensus on this floor.”

Speaking on behalf of the European Union, Ambassador Jean-Louis Wolzfeld of Luxembourg said the United Nations should engage in “a serious discussion of the package “without delay” “We do not have the benefit of unlimited time.” he added.

He pointed out that there was obviously much support for the reform package during the three-week debate of the General Assembly last month. “The package was ambitious and realistic and should lead to a more effective organisation,” he added.

Just after the package was introduced, the United States expressed reservations over two of Annan’s proposals: the creation of a U.N. Revolving Credit Fund and a new Department for Disarmament and Arms Regulation. But since then, it has not raised these two issues.

Annan himself admitted that some of the U.N. Funds and Programmes under his overall command had initially expressed reservations over some of his proposals to restructure the United Nations. “I am glad they spoke out. It is the healthy and right thing to do,” he said.

“Once I made the decision to go ahead, they have all come on board,” Annan said after presenting his package in July. “They are proposals that are bold but not suicidal,” he added.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags

Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

UNITED NATIONS: U.N. Reform Sparks North-South Confrontation

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Oct 14 1997 (IPS) - U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan’s wide-ranging proposals for restructuring the ailing United Nations threaten to trigger a rancourous North-South debate and put the entire reform exercise in jeopardy.
(more…)

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags