Headlines, Human Rights, Latin America & the Caribbean

LATAM-HUMAN RIGHTS: Police Abuses are Widespread, Reports HRW

Mario Osava

RIO DE JANEIRO, Sep 19 1997 (IPS) - Police brutality and abuses are a widespread problem in Latin America, but several cases demonstrate that adequate policies can contribute to improving respect for human rights, said the director of Human Rights Watch (HRW) Americas.

In Colombia, “where the worst reports usually come from,” there is perhaps “one single piece of good news”: reporting of police abuses has improved, thanks to a restructuring and a new internal discipline policy, said Jose Miguel Vivanco, the executive director of the U.S.-based international rights watchdog.

Police officers with poor records with respect to drug trafficking, corruption and human rights violations can now be dismissed as an administrative sanction, “without having to go through penal processing,” Vivanco told foreign correspondents Thursday in Rio de Janeiro.

The new discipline gave rise to the dismissal of some 6,000 police in Colombia, as well as greater professionalism and less violations, in the midst of what continues to be an “extremely grave” panorama of violence in Colombia – ranked the most violent country in Latin America by a World Bank report released earlier this year.

The progress made in Colombia demonstrates that “making dismissal policies more flexible could resolve a large part of the problem,” said Vivanco.

But the measures implemented in Colombia contrast with the difficulties of removing police officers in Brazil, even those who have committed serious crimes.

The president’s signature is needed to dismiss a federal police officer, said Vivanco. And he cited a case in which efforts by a state police force to remove an officer who had killed 44 people were unsuccessful.

Police violence affects all countries in the region, constituting “one of the most serious obstacles to the full democratisation of Latin America,” said Vivanco, a Chilean lawyer.

Even in countries like Argentina and Chile, where the restoration of democracy allowed “major progress to be made in the question of human rights,” forced disappearances and torture persist, while many police continue to be “trigger-happy,” he lamented.

The executive director of HRW Americas was in Brazil this week to participate in a seminar in Brasilia and meetings with national authorities.

Brazil remains one of HRW’s top priorities, along with Colombia, Cuba, Mexico and Peru, countries with “extremely serious violations of human rights, widespread in nature and with a high degree of impunity.”

Vivanco and HRW representative in Brazil James Cavallaro, praised the Brazilian government of Fernando Henrique Cardoso for adopting a National Programme of Human Rights, and for a “significant reduction of reports of slave labour.”

But they said the delay in applying the programme was worrisome, and added that a majority of the positive measures announced were still “only paper, not reality.”

They pointed out, for example, that plans to put military police accused of serious crimes under the jurisdiction of civil justice, rather than military courts where the corporate spirit favours impunity, have not yet been approved.

Public security policies vary from state to state in Brazil and are “totally contrary to human rights” in some states, such as Rio de Janeiro, where police receive raises for “acts of valor” – usually meaning they killed alleged criminals, according to Cavallaro.

Latin America’s human rights record continues to be poor, but “it is not static” and can improved, Vivanco stressed.

He cited the case of Guatemala, which had the worst record in the entire region, with 60,000 people ‘disappeared’, “six times the number documented in Argentina” in spite of the fact that Guatemala has 10 million inhabitants compared to Argentina’s 30 million. But in the past year, only one politically-motivated summary execution was verified, he underlined.

Guatemala’s peace process and the on-going presence of 450 U.N. functionaries have contributed to a drastic reduction of politically-motivated extrajudicial executions, especially of indigenous people, said Vivanco.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags