Saturday, November 21, 2026
Mario Osava
- Cuba’s exclusion from talks on the Free Trade Area of the Americas (FTAA) is “realistic” for the time being, according to Cesar Gaviria, the secretary-general of the Organisation of American States (OAS).
The former Colombian president said this week’s ministerial- level meetings did not discuss Cuba, a question that was already defined at the 1994 Miami Summit of the Americas, which gave rise to the idea of a pan-American free trade area.
“As long as ways of resolving the differences with the United States are not found,” Cuba’s participation will be difficult, he conceded, while admitting the possibility of future diplomatic and political efforts toward Cuba’s inclusion.
Gaviria made his statements in this eastern Brazilian city, where the trade ministers of all countries in the hemisphere, except Cuba, met Thursday and Friday, seeking to remove the obstacles standing in the way of formal negotiations for the creation of a continent-wide free trade area.
Referring to the exclusion of civil society from the talks, the secretary-general of the OAS said he recognised, on a personal level, “the legitimacy of the participation of unions and other actors.”
A group of countries headed by Mexico vetoed the creation of a Union Forum, which had been proposed by Brazil and backed by the United States. Only business representatives gathered in an official parallel Business Forum this week.
In the future, “it will be necessary to create mechanisms to hear all those who have something to contribute,” said Gaviria, who justified the absence of civil society with the argument that the preparatory talks basically involve the 34 governments.
Small farmers also complained about being left out of the talks, at a gathering – Our America Parallel Forum – organised by sectors of civil society.
According to Victor Suarez, director of a national association of Mexican businesses selling rural products, the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) has put Mexico’s peasant farmers in a terrible situation, and should serve as a lesson for the rest of Latin America and the Caribbean.
Suarez said NAFTA was based on false arguments, such as the ideas that expanded trade in and of itself brings a rise in well- being, each country should only produce goods in sectors in which it is most competitive, and family agriculture hinders the modernisation and export capacity of the countryside.
Although Mexico was given 15 years to eliminate agricultural subsidies, the government removed them in the first three years of the treaty, Suarez underlined. Some 500,000 peasant farmers were thus forced to leave the countryside, while small farming for domestic consumption was hurt, and the country’s agricultural trade deficit in NAFTA swelled, he added.
Small farmers must fight, in the process of creation of the FTAA, to ensure each country’s right to produce basic food products, as well as for a clause on sustainable food security, translated into national policies, the Mexican leader urged.
He also called for criteria fomenting complementariness rather than competitiveness or substitution in accords on agriculture.
The FTAA should create a forum on family agriculture, Suarez added. He praised the Southern Common Market’s (Mercosur) formation of an Economic and Social Forum, where all sectors of society have guaranteed participation to influence the bloc’s decision-making.
The freeing up of trade was also disastrous for Brazil, said Adriano Campolini, with the Brazilian Forum on Sustainable Rural Development. Imports of foodstuffs in that country rose from one billion dollars in 1990 to six billion in 1996, he pointed out.
The growth in imports was a consequence of the dismantling, since 1990, of systems that protected national production, he said, and also a result of Mercosur, which pushed up Brazil’s agricultural imports from Argentina and Uruguay.
Campolini added that U.S. emphasis on intellectual property rights in the FTAA talks was an effort to seek technological dominion, which would further handicap Latin American agriculture, especially small farmers.