Environment, Global, Global Geopolitics, Headlines

ENVIRONMENT: UNEP Confident of Return of Three Western States

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Mar 20 1997 (IPS) - The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) is confident that three disgruntled Western nations will come back into its fold later this year.

The three — Britain, Spain, and the United States — are withholding their 1997 contributions from a financially ailing UNEP, on the grounds that a handful of developing nations are blocking attempts to reform the Nairobi-based U.N. agency.

“I am very optimistic that the three countries will not pull out of the organisation,” says UNEP Executive Director Elizabeth Dowdeswell, adding that the three countries “are very committed to a strong U.N. environmental programme.” She says that together they contribute “less than 50 percent and more than 25 percent” of UNEP’s annual budget.

UNEP budgets have been on the skids over the last few years, declining from 160 million dollars in 1991-92 to 75 million dollars in 1998-99.

The executive powers of UNEP are split between the Governing Council and a Committee of U.N. Permanent Representatives based in Nairobi. And the two have been engaged in a tug-of-war, as was evident at the last Governing Council meeting in Nairobi in February. Dowdeswell says the “controversial issue” at the meeting was one on governance.

“We have a governing body that meets only every two years, and we have a Committee of Permanent Representatives in Nairobi who have functions but not all of the policy functions,” she says. “And if UNEP is going to be relevant, it clearly needs good, sound, and timely policy advice from governments. So we are trying to find the right formula.”

The three countries have said they will withhold funds until the issue of governance is settled. Dowdeswell says she hopes the issue will be resolved at the resumed session of the UNEP Governing Council in Nairobi Apr. 3.

Eileen Claussen, U.S. Assistant Secretary of State for International Environmental Affairs, says the dispute is “all about bureaucracy, control, and turf.” The deadlock is, in part, due to “a small group of ambassadors with a very particular point of view.”

“Today, UNEP suffers from a loss of focus, strategic vision and influence,” she adds. “Instead of doing a limited number of things effectively, its work plan is disjointed and lacks clear priorities.”

One of those ambassadors with “a very particular point of view” is T.P. Sreenivasan of India, chairman of the Committee of Permanent Representatives. He says that since the last Governing Council session, industrial nations have been calling for a review of the governing structures of UNEP “even though the need of the hour is to improve the resource position and to provide leadership to UNEP.”

At the insistence of the industrial nations, the Executive Director proposed the creation of an Executive Board as “a panacea for all the ills of UNEP,” he says.

“The developing nations unanimously rejected it, because the proposal struck at the very root of democratic decision-making and the importance of Nairobi as the headquarters of UNEP,” Sreenivasan points out.

He also notes that the creation of a small Executive Board of environment ministers as an intersessional body would deprive the larger membership of the Governing Council of the opportunity to have their say in the administration of UNEP. Moreover, the intention of the new Board was to meet in different parts of the world in conjunction with major international conferences.

On the other hand, the existing Committee of Permanent Representatives is a representative, transparent body and it functions in Nairobi where many countries maintain diplomatic missions to serve U.N. offices based there, he notes.

“The controversy therefore was not about the merits of ministers as against ambassadors — as is being made out by some developed nations, but about the merits of an existing democratic system of governance as against an exclusive club,” he contends. “It is also about maintaining the primacy of Nairobi as the centre of environmental activities.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags