Friday, November 20, 2026
Dilip Hiro
- The West’s desire to restrain radical Islam everywhere leaves it dangerously ambivalent towards the Turkish military’s current challenge to the Islamist Welfare Party — a position that is in itself a problem for democracy in Turkey.
The current stand off between civilian Islamist forces and the staunchly secularist military leadership, raises the very real possibility of the generals mounting a coup, as they have done thrice since 1960, the last time in 1980.
But before the military hierarchy moves on the coalition government led by Islamist Welfare party leader Necmettin Erbakan, it must consider the response its action might elicit in Washington and the European Union.
Were it simply a confrontation between the elected representatives of the people in a multi-party democracy, such as that broadly enjoyed in Turkey — with interruptions — since World War II, against a group of unelected generals, there would be little doubt as to which side the United States and the European Union would favour.
But the generals in Turkey have adopted a high profile agenda of taking on the Islamists, who, in the form of the Welfare Party have emerged as the largest single group in the country’s parliament.
The U.S.-trained military leaders in Turkey, who are close to Washington, have familiarised themselves with the history of U.S. intervention to “safeguard democracy” in Latin America during the Cold War. Then it actively encouraged, and often conspired with, senior soldiers to mount coups against elected leftist governments or as a means to averting an expected electoral victory by leftists.
Since the end of the Cold War, Islamic fundamentalism has been portrayed in the leading Western capitals as a mortal threat to Western interests. A corollary of this viewpoint is that whatever tactics were used in the past to destroy the Marxist adversaries could now be deployed to decimate the Muslim fundamentalist forces.
But a more recent example is Algeria. In the first round of the first multi-party parliamentary poll on Dec. 26, 1991, the Front of Islamic Salvation (FIS) won absolute majorities in 188 of 430 electoral districts, with its nearest secular rival winning 15 seats.
Before the second round, which was set to yield at least another 135 seats to the FIS, could be held on Jan. 16, the top generals — the defence minister, the military chief of staff and the interior minister — mounted a coup on Jan. 12, and cancelled the second round of the polling.
Washington issued a formal statement condemning the military takeover. But 24 hours later a U.S. State Department spokesman retracted the statement and instead called for ‘a peaceful resolution’ to the crisis.
Given this, the Turkish generals are likely to conclude that any precipitate action they take against Erbakan will meet with the approval of the United States.
As the active architect of Turkey’s policy of befriending Muslim countries worldwide, irrespective of their political colouring, Erbakan has made himself thoroughly unpopular in Washington. While he has traversed the Muslim world from Indonesia to Nigeria and Libya, he has yet to visit a single Western country as premier.
He has signed a 20 billion dollar contract with Teheran for supply of Iranian natural gas. And he has initiated a process to set up an ‘Islamic Common Market’ of the eight most populous Muslim states, including such pro-Western countries as Indonesia and Egypt.
Undoubtedly the US would like to see Erbakan thrown out of office. On the face of it he appears vulnerable. Since the government’s majority is narrow — it defeated a previous no confidence motion by a mere seven votes in a house of 550 — a few defections could bring down the present administration.
But, despite strenuous behind the scenes efforts by the anti- Erbakan element, this has not come to pass. Washington was as much disappointed as the Turkish generals were with the failure so far of the opposition to topple the Erbakan government.
At the same time the military men in Ankara must take into account the response of the EU governments. Since January 1996 Turkey has enjoyed a customs union with the EU and has been an associate member of the EU since 1963. But its appeals for full membership have been in vain. One of the major arguments offered by the Europhiles in Ankara is that full acceptance of Turkey in the EU would help the secularist camp and diminish the appeal of Islamists.
The EU’s objections to a full membership for Ankara revolve around three major areas: its poor human rights record, especially in the Kurdish majority region, under military backed ’emergency case’ rule; the weakness of its economy; and the shortcomings of its democratic reform.
Those who fault Turkey on the democratic front cite the meeting of the military-dominated National Security Council (MGK) which at its meeting on Feb. 28 demanded that the government must implement a 20-point programme to uphold secularism. If it did not, the MGK would impose ‘sanctions’.
Erbakan’s retort was that of a democrat, it had to be conceded.
“Supreme power belongs to parliament, not to the MGK, and the government is accountable only to parliament,” Erbakan told his party deputies in a special meeting Tuesday. “Legislation is made in parliament not in the MGK,” he asserted. “The coalition will rule the country until the year 2000.”
Under the circumstances, were the generals to mount a coup, they would have to bid goodbye to any lingering hopes of EU membership for Turkey. Also, if the Erbakan government has violated Turkey’s secular constitution perhaps the matter can be put right by referring it to the constitutional court.
Those who point out the Turkish generals had issued a similar warning in December 1979, which went unheeded by the politicians in power, and that the military finally struck nine months later, forget that the international conditions are altogether different.
The Cold War is over, and all the members of the former Soviet bloc have adopted a multi-party democratic system. Turkey’s military hierarchy cannot afford to be short-sighted about this glaring reality.