Friday, November 20, 2026
Michael Keats
- The House of Representatives voted Saturday to impeach President Bill Clinton for lying under oath about his sexual misconduct and set the stage for the second trial in U.S. history on whether a President should be removed from office.
Capping a day of high drama, lawmakers voted along party lines to approve two of the four articles lodged against Clinton, formally recommending that he be tried in the Senate for committing perjury before a grand jury and obstructing justice. The perjury article , involving Clinton’s lying about his affair with White House intern Monica Lewinsky, passed 228-206 while the obstruction charge passed 221 -212.
Lawmakers rejected two other articles accusing the president of perjury in a sexual harassment suit, brought by Paula Jomnes, and abuse of his presidential powers.
The votes followed an extraordinary day for Congress with the stunning resignation of the incoming speaker, Bob Livingston, a protest walkout by Democrats over the failure of a censure motion and public soul-searching by politicians in the House.
The outcome puts Clinton’s fate in the hands of the Senate where a two-thirds majority is required to remove him from office. In the only previous presidential trial in the Senate 130 years ago, President Andrew Johnson stayed in office by one vote.
The White House had no immediate comment on the action of the House, but Clinton has remained adamant he would not resign.
Speaker-elect Livingston, who admitted earlier this week to his own series of extra-marital affairs, said he believed he should set an example for the president.
“I cannot do the job or be the kind of leader that I would like to be under under the current circumstances,” Livingston told a shocked House. “So I must set the example that I hope President Clinton will follow: I will not stand for Speaker of the House on January 6.”
Livingston added he would stay as a backbencher only for another six months, before quitting altogether.
In the surreal political atmosphere of Washington today, Livingston fell victim to the investigative work of the country’s most notorious pornographer, ‘Hustler’ magazine publisher, Larry Flynt. On Thursday, Livingston, apparently warned that Flynt would soon expose embarrassing parts of his sexual history, tried to pre- empt the story by admitting to fellow-Republicans that he had engaged in adultery more than once during his career in Congress.
While he initially received a strong vote of confidence from the republican caucus, the more hard-line elements from the party’s increasingly powerful Christian Right wing reportedly concluded that Livingston’s admission had weakened their crusade against Clinton.
Demiocrats quickly seized on Livingston’s resignation as an example of the need to end the “sexual McCarthysim” that has deeply divided lawmakers – a reference to the anti-communist witch hunts conducted by Sen. Joe McCarthy in the 1950’s.
To drive home the point, the Democratic leader in the House, Richard Gephardt, called on Livingston to reconsider, calling his decision a “terrible capitulation to the negative forces which are consuming our political system and our country.”
To the extent that the dust had settled at the end of the day, it had become clear that:
– Clinton’s fate will now move to the Senate which, under the constitution, will conduct a trial over the Lewinsky affair.
– House Republicans had fallen into almost total disarray.(alternate phrase: that House Republicans were now engaged in an unnatural act of self-cannibalism.)
Even before Livingston’s shock announcement, the Republicans’ standing with the electorate had been in free fall, according to the latest polls.
The percentage of the public with a favourable opinion of the Republican Party plummeted from 42 percent before the debate to a mere 33 percent after the first day of debate, according to a New York Times/CBS poll released Saturday. That level, roughly the same percentage as has long favoured Clinton’s impeachment, is the lowest in recent history.
At the same time, the approval rating for the Democratic Party stood at 56 percent and for Clinton, an enviable 65 percent – a full 40 percent higher than Richard Nixon just before he resigned from office in the face of a certain House impeachment in 1974.
These kinds of figures lent weight to the argument, cited by Democrats during the debate, that the Republican majority was “out of touch with the American people” in its pursuit of Clinton. Democrats argued, unsuccessfully, that Clinton should be “censured,” not impeached, since the acts alleged against him did not rise to the level of “high crimes and misdemeanors,” for which the constitution prescribed impeachment.
Outside the exalted rhetoric of the House chamber and the self- important observations of TV pundits, most of the U.S. public, however, agreed that while the real story was about sex it also underlined the “culture wars” which have raged between self- described social conservatives and much of the rest of society since the late 1960’s.
The Christian Right and its allies have long focused their outrage on Clinton as the epitome of the 1960’s and all the connotations which they have attached to it – draft-dodging, drugs, moral relativism and permissiveness, and sexual promiscuity.
“Young men and young ladies who are thinking about going into politics now are also going to be thinking of moral fidelity, integrity and a lifestyle that will not hurt them later in life,” exulted Jerry Falwell, founder of the now-defunct Moral Majority, on the eve Saturday’s impeachment vote and Livingston’s resignation.
That kind of talk lent weight to the charges of “sexual McCarthyism” which Democrats now say appears to have captured the Republican Party.
Impeachment having been voted, the lawmakers will now disperse to their home districts for the Christmas and New Year’s holiday until the new Congress, with a reduce Republican majority, returns to Washington to survey the wreckage next month.
Republicans will have to elect a new House speaker, which, if the succession is contested, will likely exacerbate strains between the party’s right-wing and more moderate members, many of whom voted for impeachment only very reluctantly.
In the Senate, the Republican leadership must decide whether to follow through on Majority Leader Trent Lott’s pledge earlier this week to carry out a trial or to quickly make a deal with the White House for the kind of censure which his colleagues in the House rejected.
All lawmakers were left to ponder the words of Massachussetts Democrat Martin Meehan that thundered across the House during the debate: “My God, what kind of country are we becoming?
“What kind of institution are we becoming?”