Environment, Headlines, North America

ENVIRONMENT-CLIMATE: US Public Wants Action on Global Warming

Danielle Knight

WASHINGTON, Dec 14 1998 (IPS) - The U.S. Congress, in its opposition to the international treaty on reducing emmissions of greenhouse gases, is out of step with most other countries and the majority of the American public, according to a new study by a university think tank.

Analysing the results of more than 20 separate nationwide polls, the Programme on International Policy Attitudes at the University of Maryland declared that the majority of the public favour the Kyoto Treaty on Global Warming. This agreement aimed to reduce emissions caused by the burning of gasoline, coal and oil, which most scientists held responsible for global warming trends.

Republicans in Congress, however, refused to ratify the treaty, unless developing countries also committed themselves to binding limits.

According to the study, a majority of the U.S. public believed that even if developing countries do not commit to limiting their greenhouse gas emissions, the United States should proceed with the treaty. The study analysed polls from a variety of sources, including the Cable News Network (CNN), the Pew Foundation and the Mellman Group, a polling company.

“There is definitely a gap between policy makers and public opinion on the treaty,” said Steven Kull, director of the group that conducted the study. “If all the industrialised countries and probably a few developing countries would be prepared to commit to the agreement and the US Senate were to confront the decision of ratification, the question of public support may well become highly relevant.”

An overwhelming majority (90 percent) of Americans also supported the idea of providing technology and training to developing countries if they were willing to limit their emissions, he reported.

About 60 percent were willing to accept the level of additional energy costs sufficient to fulfill the requirements of the Kyoto Treaty, but only if the United States obtained credit for purchasing emission permits from other countries – which would lower the cost to the United States.

The study showed, however, that the public remained divided in its opinion on trading such permits.

Such a permit scheme was being hotly debated by nations that have signed onto the treaty, the basic framework of which was hammered out last December in Kyoto, Japan. This agreement mandated industrialised countries to cut the emission of six greenhouse gases by an average of six percent from 1990 levels, and to complete the reductions between 2008 and 2012.

If such emissions were not reduced, an international panel of experts predict that global temperatures could rise by an average of 6.3 degrees Fahrenheit over the next century. Such a temperature increase would have major climatological and environmental effects, ranging from sharp increases in sea level to the northward spread of malaria into what currently were temperate zones.

Scientists have reported the average global temperatures over the last two years were the hottest on record.

Despite the dire predictions, the Kyoto Protocol remained an anathema to Republicans in Congress and the industry-backed Global Climate Coalition – which launched a multi-million dollar advertisement campaign against the treaty claiming the agreement unfair to industrialised nations.

Yet, according to Kull’s analysis of many polls, the U.S. public mostly supported the treaty but specific percentages varied depending on the poll. The group’s own poll in October found that 59 percent favoured ratification. A September poll by the Mellman Group, however, found 79 percent in support.

A 1997 poll conducted by the New York Times found that 76 percent said the United States should take steps to reduce emissions, regardless of the actioons of other countries.

An earlier poll by the Mellman Group this year found that 66 percent said that the US “should take action to reduce its carbon dioxide emissions regardless of what other countries do.” In the poll conducted by the Programme on International Policy Attitudes in October this number was still a majority, but slightly lower at 53 percent.

Polling data differed, however, regarding the attitude toward whether the United States should be allowed fulfill its requirements by buying emissions rights from other countries where it is cheaper to control emissions, rather than making all the cuts domestically. In a poll conducted by the Programme on International Policy Attitudes in April, 61 percent responded negatively to the idea of such a trading regime.

Other groups found similar results. In the Mellman Group’s poll, 56 percent opposed the idea while 32 percent were in favour. But, the New York Times came up with different results when they included a question on the U.S. public’s knowledge of trading permits.

About 49 percent said they did not know enough while 15 percent thought it was a good idea and 17 percent was against it. Yet, when people being polled were presented arguments on both sides of the issue, as well as the actual cost tradeoffs, a strong percentage was found to favour such a system.

Once respondents were explained how the trading system would work, 65 percent said it was a good idea, according to the poll by the Programme on International Policy Attitudes.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags