Headlines, North America

EDUCATION-RIGHTS: US Schools Confront Issue of Racial Preference

Kenneth Rapoza

BOSTON, Dec 6 1998 (IPS) - When Sarah Wassman failed to gain entry to the competitive Boston Latin School last year her parents went to court – and won.

A Federal court on Nov 19 voted 2 to 1 in favor of 10th grader Sarah who had complained the prestigious public school didn’t admit her because of the school’s racial quotas.

Wassman is white and she scored higher than 10 African, Asian and Latin American students who were accepted to the Boston Latin School in the Fenway district of Boston after the usual stiff entry examinations.

Now the Boston School Committee has announced it will appeal the ruling, making this the first public high school affirmative action case to go to the Supreme Court. The outcome could lead to a new look at discrimination that bedevils the U.S. public school system.

“Any time courts rule on issues of race specific matters it can have a domino effect at other institutions,” said Hector Garza, vice president of access and equity at the American Council on Education in Washington.

“Racial quotas are illegal,” maintained U.S. Student Association official Jennifer Lin. “When race is overwhelming the only factor in a decision it is unconstitutional. It’s not clear in Boston Latin’s case whether or not they were just looking at numbers or truly trying to serve the community.”

“Quality” schools in the United States have long been embroiled in arguments over filling desks with minorities. In the 1960s, Affirmative Action legislation was created to promote women’s and African-American involvement in public and private educational institutions.

Racial diversity was seen as a compelling public and legal interest and was to be used to remedy the effects of centuries of discrimination against non-whites.

But in 1978, a landmark affirmative action ruling against the University of California in the Supreme Court (Bakke v. University of California Regents) ruled that race could just be one factor in considering whom to accept at schools and that candidates needed to be considered under a range of diversity – class, geographic, artistic, athletic, as well as race.

The Bakke case stated diversity was acceptable if it was for learning’s sake and did not discriminate based on race. Boston Latin School’s policies were ruled as unconstitutional, because they offerered different entrance requirements for minorities.

Boston Latin in the 1970s was asked by the state to prescribe a different admissions formula for students of color because of the city’s segregation problems.

The white student population in Boston public schools is 17 percent while it is 49 percent for blacks and 27 percent for Hispanics. Boston Latin left 35 percent of its seats open for minorities.

Therein lies the problem and schools like Boston Latin are finding themselves caught “between the rock and a hard place.”

Preferential treatment for school pupils under affirmative action, when disputed in the courts, are falling out of favour. The Lowell School, a publicly-funded “magnet” school for arts and sciences in San Francisco, is in court because the school board decided against admitting more Chinese students due to an overpopulation of Chinese students already at the school.

Eugene Volokh, a law professor at the University of California at Los Angeles said “Multi-culturalism and diversity mean different things to different people. Affirmative action is not in jeopardy when you talk about non-race preferences, but race is in jeopardy.”

Volokh is a legal advisor who helped draft Proposition 209, a state law which eliminated race-based affirmative action in California.

But the situation remains confused in other states. In Arlington, Virginia, when Lara Tito – a white preschooler – did not get into a popular alternative school, her parents sued the district for discrimination policies that set aside half the 46 slots for minority children.

With these cases, the longstanding debate over affirmative action in education – for years centred on universities and professional schools – is shifting to public schools where an increasing number of parents , mostly white, are complaining of policies they say are unfair to their children.

U.S. college race policies differ from the high schools, explains Jonathan Alger, counsel with American Association of University Professors. “Colleges recruit for diversity from across the country and around the world; they look for students who don’t necessarily have high grades but can contribute to dorm life, extra-curricular activities and academic life.”

The biggest obstacle to racial divseristy is a massive shift in demographics in the large American states like Florida, Texas, New York and California.

In California, Los Angeles county has a Hispanic majority. Watts, formerly a majority black neighborhood, now is 50 percent Hispanic.

Professor of government at Claremont McKenna College in California, Frederick R. Lynch, observed that, as the country’s racial makeup changed, affirmative action needed to look at a wider range of diversity.

“The biggest variable here is socioeconomics. You have a 25- year-old policy that everyone is afraid to talk about – out of fear of being dubbed a racist – that assumes all Blacks are poor, Latinos are poor and all Whites are rich,” he said. “It’s bad sociology. Current affirmative action looks at two dimensions of inequality and there are a lot more.”

Opponents of affirmative action want the question of race beiung a criterion for admission to public schools dropped altogether. The University of Michigan, a state school in the grips of an affirmative action lawsuit, is attempting to defend its race- sensitive admissions policy in a case that could go to the Supreme Court. If it does it could set a precedent whether the federal government will deem such policies unconstitutional across the board.

“It’s not because people oppose diversity,” said Debra Humphrey’s of the Association of American Colleges and Universities (AACU). “There is an emerging research base that suggests diversity does have an educational impact…and most people are all for it, if it’s fair.”

In the last three years, diversity issues have been examined nationwide. While some critics have challenged the usefulness of diversity management, the 1997 publication of the AACU’s “Diversity Works”; compiles social-scientific research from 300 campuses nationwide that found racially-mixed student populations have positive effects on retention, college satisfaction, and social and intellectual self-confidence.

“I’m a believer in diversity,” said Volokh of UCLA, “but “I’m not a believer in discriminating against other groups to get diversity.”

“If we all had equal backgrounds, had educated parents, and had the same schooling, we wouldn’t need this ” said Elizabeth Miranda, a graduate of a Boston school that, like Boston Latin, conducts entry examinations. Her parents immigrated from Cape Verde and Miranda now attends Wellesley College, from where U.S. First Lady Hillary Clinton graduated.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags