Friday, November 20, 2026
David Bacon
- The crackdown on immigrants entering the United States has had the unwelcome effect of returning exploitative conditions in the workplace reminescent of the last century.
The enforcement of imigration laws also has undermined the ability of migrant workers to fight for better pay and treatment, and the effectiveness of unions which try to help them. The Immigration Reform and Control Act (IRCA) of 1986, which made employer sanctions part of federal law, formalized the creation of a special category of U.S. residents who have significantly fewer rights than the population as a whole – who cannot legally work or receive social benefits.
Undocumented workers, about 1 percent of the total U.S. population, are a permanent and constant part of the U.S. population and have been for decades. According to the Urban Institute, the number has fluctuated from between 3 million to 5 million in 1886 and 2-3 million in 1988 to between 2.7 million and 3.7 million in 1992.
The National Immigration Forum calculates that undocumented immigrants pay about 7 billion dollars annually in taxes, subsidizing funds like Social Security and unemployment insurance from which they cannot collect benefits. In California, which accounts for about 43 percent of the nation’s undocumented population, or about 1.4 million people, undocumented immigrants pay an additional 732 million dollars in state and local taxes.
A study by the University of California and Los Angeles (UCLA) found that undocumented workers contribute approximately 7 percent of California’s 900 billion dollars gross economic product, or 63 billion dollars.
The contribution by each undocumented immigrant therefore is about 45,000 dollars, counting children, the unemployed and those too old or ill to work. Almost all undocumented workers receive wages near, and sometimes below, the legal minimum, which at 5.75 dollars per hour equals an annual income of 11,960 dollars.
The labor of undocumented workers pumps tens of billions of dollars into the state’s economy, but the workers themselves receive only a small percentage of it. That difference is a source of extra profit for those industries dependent on a workforce made up largely of undocumented workers – agriculture and food processing, land development (including the residential construction and building services industries), tourism (including the hotel and restaurant industries), garment production and light manufacturing, transportation, retail trade, healthcare and domestic services.
When that workforce is made more vulnerable by immigration legislation, it also becomes cheaper for employers.
Nevertheless, undocumented workers have not been passive victims of exploitation. Over the last decade, they have been the backbone of many strikes and organizing drives. Employers have used their vulnerability, however, in an effort to stop growing support for unions.
A report issued this week on the impact of raids by the agents of the Immigration and Nationalisation Service (INS) the National Network for Immigrant and Refugee Rights details a number of cases in which immigration enforcement has been used to deny immigrants their workplace rights.
A typical example involved the current joint organizing drive by the Teamsters Union and the United Farm Workers in Washington state’s apple industry.
The Stemilt Fruit Company told workers that union support would bring on immigration raids. According to one employee, Mary Mendez, Stemilt’s anti-union consultant told workers that “there hasn’t been a union here yet, and the INS hasn’t done any raids. But with a union, the INS is going to be around.”
Using those threats, the company was able to defeat the union in a representation election. Afterwards, however, the National Labour Relations Board (NLRB) issued a bargaining order because of Stemilt’s illegal actions.
Employer sanctions set up a process in which employers are required to request documents from workers to verify their legal right to reside in the U.S., and record those documents on “I-9” forms. Since IRCA passed in 1986, many employers have used this process as a mechanism for firing pro-union workers.
Even in the absence of direct union organizing, the pressure of immigration raids keeps wages low among some of the most vulnerable sections of the workforce. In the San Francisco Bay Area, such raids have focused on fast food workers, car wash workers, and day laborers seeking jobs on the street corner. Enforcing low wages among these workers undermines wages generally in the service, fast food and construction industries.
The INS has great latitude in the selection of enforcement targets. In Georgia in the spring of 1998, the agency began raids in onion fields outside Vidalia. After growers protested that enforcement activity was interfering with their operations, the local INS district director agreed to suspend raids and deportations until the onion crop had been harvested.
“Workers in the garment industry won’t complain about workplace violations if it gets out that the DoL and the INS are working together,” says UNITE organizer Cristina Vasquez. “Manufacturers and contractors will use it to scare and threaten workers.” A Department of Labour survey released this summer shows that less than 40 percent of the licensed garment factories in Southern California are in compliance with labor and employment laws.
Similar raids also followed a 1998 campaign by the Korean Immigrant Workers Association to enforce wage and hour laws in restaurants in Los Angeles’ Korean community. Just weeks after DoL inspectors were called in over wage and hour violations, the INS began a wave of checks and deportations.
At a Staten Island laundry plant, Launderall, employees earning 300 dollars for a 72-80 hour week called in Department of LLabour this fall. After workers made a claim for 159,000 dollars in back wages, the INS conducted a raid.
In addition to opening up the prospect of deportation, employer sanctions also increase the risk for union activity in other ways. An undocumented worker considering whether to organize a union has to take into account the possibility of being fired, as do other workers. But sanctions make finding another job harder and riskier. The period of unemployment is likely to be longer.
Because sanctions also disqualify a fired worker from unemployment benefits, food stamps or other sources of income, a fired worker is forced to take whatever job is available, at whatever wage. And under National Labor Relations Board rulings, if an employer shows that a worker fired for union activity is undocumented, it is not obligated to rehire her or him.
When it becomes harder and riskier for workers to make demands for social services, or to assert their rights at work or in the community, the price of their labor drops. Immigrant wages are already depressed, and getting worse. According to UCLA professor Goetz Wolff, in women’s apparel in Los Angeles, the average hourly wage fell from USD 6.37 to 5.62 between 1988 and 1993. Some 120,000 people work in LA’s garment sweatshops, almost all immigrants, mostly undocumented.
The history of the union struggles of immigrant workers in California is by-and-large a history of success. According to veteran union organizer Joel Ochoa, “the immigrant community is looking for ties with labor. People are coming here from Mexico and all over Latin America, with a tradition and culture that gives them a rich repertoire of tactics for fighting the companies.”
Many California unions have realized that they will grow, and become more effective, as immigrant workers organize and contribute their traditions to the broader labor movement. Increasingly they are calling for an end to the use of immigration law as a weapon of employers.
Repealing employer sanctions is a position now shared by the Service Employees International Union, the Union of Needletrades, Industrial and Technical Employees, the United Electrical Workers and the California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO.
Speaking before the Asian-Pacific American Labor Alliance in San Francisco last year, AFL-CIO Secretary Treasurer Richard Trumka reminded delegates that “we are all agitators — we are all illegals. No matter how many years we’ve been here, in the eyes of the bankers of Wall St. we’re all immigrants from Europe or Central America or Mexico, on our knees, digging in the dirt.”
Winning justice for immigrant workers, ending sweatshop conditions and defending the right of unions to organize requires translating those sentiments into concrete political opposition to employer sanctions, and the use of immigration law to deny workers’ rights.