Economy & Trade, Headlines, North America

TRADE-US: Clinton Narrowly Averts Blow to WTO’s Power

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Aug 7 1998 (IPS) - President Bill Clinton has narrowly averted a major blow to the authority and reach of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) by U.S. supporters of the use of economic sanctions by state and local governments against foreign countries.

The House of Representatives voted 228-200 Wednesday night to reject an amendment that would have barred the federal government from legally challenging any state or local sanctions laws which were found by a WTO panel to violate international trade accords.

The Clinton administration strongly opposed the amendment, co- sponsored by an unusual coalition of left-wing Democrats and right- wing Republicans, and argued that it was “unnecessary and ill- advised.”

The vote, which split both Republicans and Democrats, was the latest in a series of recent struggles over the use of unilateral sanctions against foreign countries.

More than 600 of America’s largest corporations, organised in the National Foreign Trade Council (NFTC), have held a year-long campaign against unilateral sanctions. They claimed such measures were not only ineffective in achieving their aims, but also cost US business about 20 billion dollars a year in lost commerce.

The NFTC, with at least the tacit support of key players in the Clinton administration, focused most of its efforts on Congress which, in recent years, enacted far-reaching economic sanctions against such countries as Iran, Cuba, Libya, and China as punishment for alleged for human rights abuses or weapons proliferation.

At a second level, however, the NFTC and the administration have pressed state and local jurisdictions to repeal or reject so- called “selective purchasing” laws against companies which invest or do business in target countries. Launched by the anti- apartheid movement in the late 1970s, these laws typically forbid such companies from bidding on state or local contracts.

Their purpose is to force companies to choose between doing business with local and state governments, some of which award hundreds of millions of dollars in contracts each year, and maintaining ties with target countries. Selective purchasing laws were largely credited with decision by dozens of U.S. companies to withdraw from South Africa during the anti-apartheid campaign.

About two dozen states, counties and cities throughout the United States have such laws on the books, most of them directed against Burma but also aimed at Indonesia, Nigeria, Cuba, and Switzerland. The most controversial law is one enacted by the Massachusetts legislature in 1996 imposing a 10 percent penalty on all bids on state contracts by companies doing business in Burma.

The NFTC earlier this year sued Massachusetts on the grounds that the law violates provisions in the US constitution which give the federal government supreme authority over foreign policy and commerce.

The Massachusetts law, however, also drew the attention of the European Union (EU) which brought the matter to the WTO. They argued that the law, which applies to foreign as well as US-based companies, violates the 1994 Government Procurement Agreement which requires that procurement decisions by governments, including most U.S. states, be made on economic grounds only.

The EU filed an “amicus curiae” brief supporting the NFTC lawsuit and threatened to ask the WTO to formally convene a three- person panel to rule on the Massachusetts law in September. That threat helped galvanise the coalition which rallied behind the amendment. If it became law, the administration would be barred from taking legal action to enforce any WTO ruling.

Organisational sponsors included several major Jewish groups, which have spearheaded the campaign against Swiss banks for their complicity with the Nazis during World War Two; the Sierra Club, a large environmental lobby which has backed sanctions against Burma and Nigeria; Transafrica and the Africa Fund.

“The members of Congress who are co-sponsoring this legislation, progressives and conservatives, disagree on a lot of things, but what we do not disagree about is that the American people in their cities and their towns and their states have the right to make decisions which affect their own best interests and have the right not to be overriden by a secretive trade organisation in Geneva,” said Rep. Bernie Sanders, a leftwing independent from Vermont.

Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, a staunchly anti-Castro Cuban- American from Miami and co-sponsor of the amendment, agreed. “This amendment insures that the ultimate fate of subnational policies and laws are decided by the American political system and not by foreign bureaucrats,” she declared.

Foes of the amendment circulated a letter from U.S. Trade Representative Charlene Barshefsky who insisted that the WTO had no authority to compel Washington to follow its rulings or to sue local or state jurisdictions to ensure compliance. “Only the United States can decide how it will respond, if at all, to panel reports,” she wrote, adding that the federal government had never sued a subnational body in the 50 years in which the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, the WTO’s predecessor, had issued rulings.

But one amendment sponsor, Peter DeFazio, questioned these assurances. “We have been told that it is absolutely unnecessary to have this amendment because the United States government has never used the power of the courts to preempt state and local laws, and it will never do that,” he said. “If that is the case, then why do they not just accept the amendment?”

Despite their defeat, the amendment’s supporters did see a silver lining to the debate. “The administration has managed to box itself in politically,” said Simon Billeness, a leader in the Burma sanctions campaign in Massachusetts. “By saying it has no intention of suing states over WTO rulings, it will be that much more difficult to do so.”

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags