Development & Aid, Economy & Trade, Europe, Headlines

DEVELOPMENT-BRITAIN: Think Tank’s Call To Scrap Food Aid Under Fire

Dipankar De Sarkar

LONDON, Jul 24 1998 (IPS) - A senior United Nations official has slammed a well-known British development think tank for its view that all food aid to developing countries should be phased out, except in the direst emergency.

“We don’t accept the argument that food aid should only be used in dire emergencies and phased out elsewhere,” John Powell, Director of Strategy and Policy at the U.N.’s World Food Programme (WFP). “Food aid has a clear role in the eradication of hunger.”

He was responding to the conclusions of the London-based Overseas Development Institute (ODI) and a paper it has produced for the British government — well known sceptics when it comes to judging the value of crisis aid.

The paper, based on the ODI’s own research, argued that the two billion dollars worth of food aid shipped to poor countries every year is not the best way to assist the long term development of these countries.

“Two thirds of all food aid is either sold on local markets, or used to support food-for-work programmes or supplementary feeding of children,” says Edward Clay, lead researcher of the paper, The Future of Food Aid. “Providing jobs and feeding children are both worthwhile, but our research shows that sending food aid is not the best way to do it.”

The ODI study, prepared for the British government’s Department for International Development, supports a long-held British official view that food aid is better for emergencies than for development.

Britain spent about 128 million dollars on food aid in the year up to April 1997, including 80 million dollars, shipped as part of European Union food aid, 38.4 million dollars for aid routed through the WFP, and eight million dollars to non-governmental organisations.

In contrast Washington spent a billion dollars on food aid in the same period, as the United States — and in general, the EU, Canada, Australia and others — takes the opposite line to Britain, according to Powell.

The Rome-based WFP plays a key role in delivering food aid to the developing world, both for long-term development purposes and for emergencies. It organised 600 million dollars worth of aid in 1997, including 330 million dollars for development activities such as food-for-work programmes.

Some 111 countries received food aid in 1996, but half of it went to only 10 countries, the report says. At the same time food aid has declined in volume by two-thirds in four years to only 4.9 million tonnes in the year up to June 1997 — a 50 year low.

“The results of the study will shock aid agencies,” the ODI says in a press release. “The WFP delivers development food aid to over 60 countries, but could now be obliged to close its operations in large countries like China, India and Pakistan.”

The debate itself is not new, but has been rekindled by the increasing number of conflict situations and emergencies that have needed quick shipments of food aid worldwide. In Britain the publication of the ODI report follows a shift in development policy in favour of longer term development aimed at eliminating poverty.

In the main, the research paper argues that developmental food aid in the 1990s has proved relatively ineffective as an instrument for combating poverty and improving the food consumption and nutritional and health status of very poor and vulnerable people.

This, it says, is true of both the two main types of development food aid, ‘Project’ and ‘Programme’.

Programme food aid, which is provided to governments for sale at subsidised prices, is described as “a particularly ineffective and blunt instrument.” And evidence on the impact of project food aid, which is tied to specific projects and provides food directly, is said to be “surprisingly lacking”.

The ODI report cites a critical evaluation of the WFP in 1993 by the donor countries Canada, Netherlands and Norway — but Powell says that every one of the recommendations made by the report have been implemented by the WFP.

“In fact two of the principal authors of the report were quite surprised that we took their recommendations so seriously. In that sense the ODI report is a little bit disingenuous,” he added.

Powell maintains that project food aid finances things, such as food-for-work programmes, which no donor would otherwise fund.

“In China, for instance, we work in poor areas selected from the Chinese government’s poverty map, usually with 100,000 to 200,000 people living in absolute poverty. We provide the food aid which enables the participating families to put in labour to build irrigation canals, and in preparation of land or re-forest denuded hillsides for environmental protection.

“This brings lasting benefit,” he said. “There is a clear connection in our minds between the provision of food, the consumption of that food and the creation of lasting assets which poor people have the use of.”

Powell also critcised the ODI report for comparing the impact of food aid with the effects of simple provision of cash. The issue — another ‘development controversy’ dating back several years — revolves around the idea forwarded in 1989 by the Indian economist Amartya Sen, that doling out cash for labour may be better than handing out food, in some circumstances.

Advocates of the idea hold that cash strengthens the food market while free food weakens it by discouraging local food production.

Cash-for-work schemes have been successfully tried out in India and Botswana. However, other economists hold they can work only in places where trade is free and markets are strong.

Powell disagrees, saying he is “dismayed” by the comparison.

“There is no donor I know who would provide cash to build an irrigation canal in China, or send a child to school or send malnourished pregnant woman to a clinic. They do other good things with the cash — it is a comparison which just doesn’t exist.”

Others argue that the debate is wider than concerns that food aid creates aid dependency or ‘hand-out syndrome’ among poor countries and communities.

Phil Bloomer, a senior policy adviser with Oxfam, the international aid agency, says rich countries often dump their excess food, produced with the aid of huge domestic subsidies, in the guise of food aid.

Bloomer said Oxfam has been calling for phasing out development food aid since 1982. “There is a lot of excess grain people want to get rid of in the U.S. and Europe and these subsidies skew decisions on whether to procure food locally and regionally.”

There are strategic concerns too. ODI academic Nisha Pillai, who worked on the food aid report, said lack of funding for food aid is making it more and more difficult to plan development programmes. For example, food aid currently forms just four percent of Britain’s overseas development assistance package.

“Different countries unilaterally cut their food aid, so it is increasingly difficult to plan development programmes based around food aid,” she added.

Others like to turn the argument on its head — falling aid levels does not mean aid has to be phased out, they say. “In many ways, development itself is under siege. It’s the future of development we are talking about, not just the future of food aid,” said one U.N. official.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags