Europe, Headlines

DISARMAMENT: New Study Sees Progress Despite Setbacks

Ramesh Jaura

BONN, Jul 9 1998 (IPS) - Despite some setbacks, such as the recent nuclear tests by India and Pakistan, the world-wide disarmament process set in motion in the mid-80s has not yet come to a halt.

According to a new study by the Bonn International Centre for Conversion (BICC), 85 out of 157 countries surveyed are disarming and most industrialised nations have scaled down their armaments over the last decade, an average cut of 34 percent.

BICC’s report, ‘Conversion Survey 1998’, analysed extensive data on disarmament and on the conversion of military hardware into goods for civilian use. It found that Europe, source of the world’s bloodiest warfare this century, was taking a lead in this area.

The developing world presents a varied picture. Despite an average reduction in arms of nine percent, “many developing countries — above all, those in areas of war or crisis — are pumping considerable resources into their armed forces and weapons arsenals”, says the report.

The report is published for a third year and also updates the so- called BICC3D index, the three D’s standing for disarmament, demilitarisation and demobilisation.

The report was completed before fighting broke out between Ethiopia and Eritrea, when Ethiopia was highly ranked in BICC’s top ten index of disarming nations. That ranked Nicaragua, Ethiopia, Iraq, Bulgaria, Cuba, the Czech Republic, Russia, Hungary, Pol and and Germany as the principal disarmers.

“The reason for the positive developments in these countries,” says BICC director Herbert Wulf, “is of course the end of the Cold War or the conclusion of wars within the region, partly encouraged by the fact that the previous scale of militarisation could not be maintained because of economic bottlenecks and, in the special case of Iraq, disarmament that has been forced from abroad.”

On the lower ranks of the BICC3D index, that is, countries which have been arming themselves, are “primarily those which are engaged in wars and which are, as they perceive it, in a crisis situation”.

They include Turkey (ranked 128 on the index), Indonesia (129), Papua New Guinea (141), Colombia (144), Sierra Leone (146), Myanmar (150), Armenia (151), Sudan (153), Burundi (155), Sri Lanka (156) and Rwanda (157).

The report noted that demobilisation of soldiers continued in 1996, the year for which it has latest data. The total number of soldiers worldwide dropped from 28.8 million in 1987 to 23.5 million in 1995 and roughly 22.7 million in 1996. This was a decre ase of six million troops, or 21 percent, within a decade.

Further large-scale demobilisations were planned not only in France, China and Russia but also in several African countries said BICC.

On the other hand, says the BICC study, the pace of closure of military bases has “clearly slowed down” after a first great wave at the beginning of the 1990s.

“The closure of military bases is frequently delayed or prevented because of political considerations resting on the often exaggerated negative economic consequences and because of high initial investment costs,” says the report.

Numerous positive examples in Germany show that base conversion is much more of a chance than a problem, argues the study.

BICC finds the world’s stocks of surplus weapons more “problematical”. In 1996, the armed forces discarded more conventional weapons than in the previous years. Stocks shrank from 491,000 to 456,000 heavy weapons — armoured vehicles, artillery pieces, fighter aircraft and warships.

“Some of these weapons are being exported,” notes the report. And, while stocks continue to be reduced in terms of quantity, modernisation is providing more effective new weapons.

The authors also noted that 1997 saw a greater public awareness of the need to abolish land mines and control small arms.

“The existence of treaties containing bans and/or code of conduct for trade in weapons perhaps does not yet mean that mines have been cleared and machine guns scrapped; nevertheless these are important political framework conditions,” says the BICC.

The end of the Cold War has in fact facilitated disarmament on a scale comparable only to the end of major ‘real’ wars. In the 20th century, it was only after World Wars I and II that reductions in global military expenditure were larger than in the late 1980s and the 1990s.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags