Headlines, North America

POLITICS: UN Elevates Political Status of Palestine

Thalif Deen

UNITED NATIONS, Jul 7 1998 (IPS) - The United Nations has elevated Palestine from ‘observer’ status in the world body, inching it toward the ‘non-member state’ category over objections from the United States and Israel.

The 185-member General Assembly Tuesday voted overwhelmingly in favour of a resolution that will grant additional rights and privileges moving Palestine closer to the ranks of the only two ‘non-member states’ in the organisation: Switzerland and the Holy See.

The resolution, which stopped short of declaring Palestine a non-member state – or nation with sovereign rights which is not a dues-paying UN member – was adopted by a vote of 124 in favour and four against (the United States, Israel, Micronesia, and Marshall Islands), with 10 abstentions (Bulgaria, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Honduras, Liberia, Malawi, Paraguay, Poland, Romania, Rwanda and Zambia).

“The message from the General Assembly was a slap in the face for Israel,” one Third World delegate told IPS, noting that the resolution was, in effect, an answer to continued political harassment of Palestinians under the administration of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.

U.S. Ambassador Bill Richardson told the UN’s highest policy- making body that he opposed the resolution as having “serious repercussions for political relations among UN member states and… a deleterious effect on the orderly conduct of United Nations business.”

This is the first time that an ‘observer’ at the United Nations has been elevated to a higher rank. According to Alex Taukatch, spokesman for the president of the General Assembly, “It is an unusual and important move by the General Assembly.”

Palestine has been granted the right to participate in the general debate of the Assembly, the right of inscription on the list of speakers, the right of reply and the right to raise points of order related to the proceedings on Palestinian and Middle East issues.

Additionaly, Palestine will have the right to co-sponsor draft resolutions and decisions on Palestinian and Middle East issues and the right to intervene during General Assembly debates. However, Palestine will not have the right to vote or to put forward candidates for office.

In an institution governed by rigid protocol, Palestine now will be seated in the company of Switzerland and the Holy See. Previously, it has had the same status as the International Committee of the Red Cross, the Sovereign Military Order of Malta and intergovernmental organisations such as the Organisation of African Unity, the European Community, the Commonwealth Secretariat and the Organisation of the Islamic Conference (OIC).

“By overturning decades of practice and precedent in the General Assembly governing the participation of non-members and observers, others who do not now enjoy full-member status in the UN may well press their own claims for enhanced status,” Richardson warned.

The US envoy also predicted the resolution will undermine current efforts to get the Middle East peace process on track “and hurt everyone’s interests, including those it is most intended to help.”

“Exchanging momentum toward real progress on the ground for symbolic progress in this chamber does not strike us as a good bargain,” Richardson said.

Nasser al-Kidwa, the current Permanent Observer for Palestine, said the resolution was important both for Palestine and for the United Nations, which had dealt with the question of Palestine since its inception.

“The Assembly had upgraded the representation of the Palestinian delegation in spite of pressures, campaigns and threats,” he said, adding that this would bolster Palestinians’ pride and belief in the justice of their cause.

Ambassador Dore Gold of Israel said the attempt to secure additional rights and privileges with the intention of obtaining a symbolic shift in status contradicted the bilateral basis of the Arab-Israeli peace process.

Ambassador Robert Fowler of Canada said he voted in favour of the resolution because it would permit the Palestinians to participate better in the work of the United Nations.

The status of Palestine at the United Nations has undergone several changes over the last three decades. In 1974, the General Assembly voted to grant ‘observer’ status to the then Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO). The Assembly in 1988 decided to recognise ‘Palestine’ in place of the PLO.

Currently, Palestine is a full member of the League of Arab States, the Non-Aligned Movement, the OIC, and the developing nations’ ‘Group of 77’. It also enjoys full membership in the Group of Asian States at the United Nations and also in the Beirut- based Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia.

Over the last few years, the United States has made several attempts to dismantle UN programmes relating to Palestinians, primarily due to pressure from Israel or as part of austerity measures to reduce spending in the world body.

In early 1996, Washington wanted to axe all UN bodies and committees it considered redundant or wasteful. Two politically- significant committees singled out for the chopping block dealt with Palestinian rights.

The United States declared it was “strongly opposed” to the ‘Special Committee to Investigate Israeli Practices’ and the ‘Committee on the Exercise of the Inalienable Rights of the Palestinian People.’

“These Committees are outdated, irrelevant and not supportive of the (Middle East) peace process,” Ambassador David Birenbaum, a US delegate to the United Nations, said at the time. The two bodies so far have survived.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags