Asia-Pacific, Headlines, North America

DISARMAMENT: U.S. Wants India, Pakistan to “Cool It”

Jim Lobe

WASHINGTON, Jun 3 1998 (IPS) - President Bill Clinton Wednesday called on permanent members of the U.N. Security Council to forge a “common strategy” to push India and Pakistan away from possible conflict following their recent nuclear tests.

Clinton sent U.S. Secretary of State Madeleine Albright to Geneva for meetings with the foreign ministers of the other permanent member nations – Britain, China, France and Russia – and labelled the Indo-Pakistani weapons programmes “self-defeating, wasteful and dangerous.” He added that the drive toward nuclear weapons in the two countries “will make their people poorer and less secure.”

“Our goal is to forge a common strategy to move India and Pakistan back from their nuclear arms race and begin to build a more peaceful, stable region,” Clinton said. His remarks were the first since he slapped far-reaching sanctions against Pakistan after it conducted the first of two test series last Thursday.

Pakistan exploded six nuclear devices after India’s detonation of five devices May 11 and 13. Both countries have now declared themselves nuclear powers and indicated they may arm their missiles with nuclear warheads.

The tests brought tensions to the boil between the two South Asian nations, who have gone to war three times in the past 50 years. They also poked a gaping hole in the Clinton administration’s non-proliferation policy and may have derailed Senate ratification of the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty (CTBT), at least for this year.

The administration has worked feverishly this week to persuade Indian and Pakistani leaders to tone down their rhetoric and retract some of the threats they have hurled at each other. Washington especially was alarmed at the possibility of war breaking out between the two countries in Kashmir.

In testimony here Wednesday, Assistant Secretary of State for South Asian Affairs Karl Inderfurth, noting continuing “worrisome activity along the line of control” in the disputed territory, described the situation as moving “in a very dangerous direction.”

Inderfurth said that Pakistan should follow up India’s unilateral moratorium on further testing with a similar decision to end all further tests. A joint declaration that neither country will “weaponise” or deploy their ballistic missiles could also help defuse the situation, he said. Washington favours a summit between Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif and Indian Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee.

Albright said she was leaving Washington with three major goals.

In the near term, she said, the United States and the other four permanent members of the Security Council – all of whom are nuclear powers – must persuade both sides “to cool it, take a deep breath and to begin to climb out of the hole they have dug for themselves.”

“Our message to India and Pakistan must be that there should be no further nuclear testing, no deployment or testing of missiles, no inflammatory rhetoric, and no more provocative military activity,” she told reporters.

Second, Albright said , the five great powers and the rest of the international community should do what they can to “avert a regional arms race and re-examine options for easing the underlying political problems between India and Pakistan, including Kashmir.”

Washington has ruled out playing any mediation role on Kashmir, although it does not oppose a “multilateralisation” of the issue along the lines of the 1991 Madrid conference to address the Arab- Israeli conflict. Inderfurther said Washington also wants to see new discussions between India and China, which Delhi has identified as its principal strategic threat, an assertion strongly rejected by Beijing.

Finally, Albright said Washington will try to bolster the global nuclear nonproliferation regime so that other countries will not follow the “disastrous example set by India and Pakistan.” Such an effort would begin with US ratification of the CTBT.

But, she stressed, the United States will not support amending the 1970 Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) to include India and Pakistan as nuclear states because that would reward them for not abiding by the Treaty and provide a dangerous precedent for other aspiring nuclear powers, such as Iran. Nor will it consider easing sanctions which it has imposed against both nations, as required by a law passed by Congress in 1994.

Those sanctions include a cut-off of all non-humanitarian economic assistance; a ban on the export of products to either country which could be used by their military or nuclear-weapons programmes; the cancellation of most export and investment credits and guarantees; and opposition to pending loans by international financial institutions, such as the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

Both countries are expected to be hit hard by these measures, although India, with an economy roughly five times larger than its nearly bankrupt western neighbour, is considered more able to ride them out. Already, more than one billion dollars in loans for India, pending before the World Bank’s executive board have been indefinitely delayed.

Albright, however, stressed that it would be a mistake for Washington or the other major powers to try to “isolate” the two countries. “We have to draw a very fine line here… They clearly are the problem, (but) they need to be part of the solution.”

No other country has imposed such sweeping sanctions against India and Pakistan, although Canada and Japan, a key aid-giver for both countries, have generally backed Washington’s tough position.

Some independent analysts believe the administration is setting too ambitious an agenda and beginning with the wrong forum.

In testimony to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, former Bush administration official Richard Haass criticised the “whole rush” to bring this to the P-5. “This is exactly the discriminatory grouping that in some ways provokes India,” he told lawmakers, precisely because their possession of nuclear weapons is legalised under the NPT.

Haass, who heads international programmes at the influential Brookings Institution, also belittled chances that both India and Pakistan would formally sign the CTBT or even agreet to no-first- use pledges. Washington should focus on a more modest package designed to gain agreement on no further testing, not arming or deployment of missiles, and no transfer of nuclear or missile technology to third countries, he said.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags