Asia-Pacific, Headlines | Analysis

POLITICS-INDIA: Bigger Role for Military

Analysis - Rahul Bedi

NEW DELHI, Mar 26 1998 (IPS) - India’s new government plans to plug the country’s long standing security gap by establishing a National Security Council to undertake the first ever defence review to evaluate military, economic and political threats and formulate a nuclear policy.

The alliance led by the right-wing Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) which has several retired generals in its ranks has pledged to increase defence spending, modernise the military and explore the possibility of building nuclear weapons in keeping with the Council review.

India’s new Defence Minister George Fernandes, meanwhile, has already revived the defunct Defence Ministers Committee (DMC), after a gap of nearly 20 years to “actively involve” the three service chiefs in security issues.

Besides the chiefs of staff of the army, navy and air force the Committee includes the cabinet secretary and civil service heads of key ministries like home, finance and science and technology. Its weekly meetings will focus on specific security issues and work towards ending the existing antagonism between the military and civilian establishments.

In the “National Agenda for governance”, the new government’s agreed list of policy objectives, Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee stated his government’s resolve to “re- evaluate” India’s neutral nuclear posture. For 24 years, India has pursued a peaceful nuclear policy after its first and only underground test alongside a defensive military posture.

Succeeding all-party Parliamentary Defence Committee’s have lamented the deficiency of a security doctrine. A recent report said the “absence of clearly defined national security objectives and military aims leads to proposals being examined on a general basis”.

Senior military officials also said the lack of a security doctrine affected operational planning, establishing a credible deterrence and pursuing an organised equipping policy for the military. They said India needed to take hard military decisions, sandwiched as it is between Pakistan with its clandestine nuclear weapons programme and a militarist and nuclear China, the longer term threat for India, rapidly modernising its military strength.

Chinese naval activity in the region has also multiplied in South Asia with the installation of signal intelligence facilities in the Great Cocos island, 30 nautical miles from India’s chain of Andaman islands in the Bay of Bengal.

Beijing is also helping Burma modernise two ports and construct a naval base giving rise to fears of enhanced Chinese presence in the Indian Ocean for the first time. These fears gained credence two years ago after a Chinese trawler, equipped with sophisticated tracking and surveying equipment was detained by India’s Coast Guard allegedly for spying, but released under diplomatic pressure from Beijing.

And, though relations between the two neighbours have improved and troop pullbacks effected on both sides of the Line of Actual Control (LOAC) between the two, military officials are sceptical about future Chinese intentions and worried that no serious attention is being paid to what could emerge as a serious threat after 2000.

Even Nepal, long considered an ally was wanting to re- negotiate its old treaty with New Delhi in a bid to come closer to China, which wants to increase is sphere of influence in the Himalayan region bordering Tibet.

And, the bitter power struggle in Afghanistan between rival Islamic fundamentalist groups is threatening to unwind downwards into Kashmir. According to latest intelligence bureau estimates, around 500 Afghan mercenaries are dominating the insurgency in the disputed principality today.

Military officers said India was one of the few democratic nations where the military had the least input into security matters. None of the service chiefs, for instance, were consulted during the protracted negotiations at the Disarmament Conference at Geneva for the Comprehensive Test Ban Treaty two years ago.

The increased involvement of the army in internal security duties has diluted its authority even though civil strife is the responsibility of India’s para-military forces totalling around 600,000 and massive state police forces and provincial armed constabularies.

Besides civil law enforcement duties had “compromised” efficiency through lack of training opportunities. “We are looked upon simply as better organised, experienced and disciplined riot police,” said a senior officer involved in combating insurgents in Kashmir.

The army’s apprehensions over frequent deployment on internal security duties have been ignored by successive governments who maintain that the military remains the only force disciplined and capable of maintaining peace in India.

Senior defence officers said they had to operate in a system where the military and the government are invariably at variance, unable to execute or initiate any long term planning. They had to deal with an uninformed and antagonistic yet omnipotent bureaucracy which was inexperienced in military matters but the final arbiter of all key decisions.

In 1986, however, then prime minister Rajiv Gandhi tried to initiate change by constituting a Policy Advisory Committee which included junior ministers from the foreign, defence and home ministries, the cabinet secretary, the head of Research and Analysis Wing (RAW), India’s external intelligence gathering agency and director of the Institute for Strategic Studies and Analyses (IDSA) at New Delhi.

The three service chiefs, however, were again excluded from this Committee but within three years the Committee wound up following the failure of the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF) in Sri Lanka.

Arbitrarily dispatching the IPKF to disarm Tamil Tiger guerrilla’s under the India-Sri Lanka accord in 1987 proved disastrous. India’s peace keeping mission led to the death of 1,155 Indian soldiers, including scores of officers but failed to end the Tigers fight for an independent homeland which continues.

Once again in 1990, the coalition government of prime minister Vishwanath Pratap Singh which withdrew Indian troops from Sri Lanka announced the establishment of a NSC but the government collapsed after 11 months and the experiment remained untested till in 1993 prime minister Narasimha Rao told Parliament that the security council would be set up.

This never happened and its successor, the United Front coalition was too busy surviving politically to bother itself with security issues, leaving it to the Hindu nationalists to vindicate their promise of instituting a security council.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags