Asia-Pacific, Economy & Trade, Headlines, Human Rights, Labour

RIGHTS-BURMA: Migrant Workers Push Key Legal Test in Thailand

Simrin Singh

MAE SOT, Thailand, Jul 22 2003 (IPS) - The cool, air-conditioned confines of a labour court in this northern Thai town have become the venue for a small but big struggle – the country’s first-ever labour dispute pressed by Burmese migrant workers.

The proceedings by a local judge – the second hearings were held Jul. 11 – are historical, to say the least, and their implications profound for the over one million primarily undocumented Burmese migrants in Thailand.

They live and work in sweatshop conditions and in hostile, insecure and often life-threatening environments in parts of the country, including in this town on the Thai border with Burma.

This is despite their significant contributions to the Thai economy. According to Thai Department of Labour estimates, the total economic contribution made by registered Burmese migrants was 99 million baht (2.3 million U.S. dollars) in 2000, though other studies cite this as being closer to 350 million dollars a year.

In October 2002, 60 registered workers from Nut Knitting factory here were dismissed from their jobs and severely beaten for protesting against the unfair treatment of 19 other colleagues whom the factory had failed to register with the Thai authorities.

As a result, the 19 workers were arrested by the police and deported, despite an assurance from the employer to bail them out.

Under threat from their employers, the police, and immigration officials and unable to find work any more in Mae Sot as they had been blacklisted, most of the workers fled.

However, with the support of a local worker’s organisation, Burma Labour Solidarity Organisation – since then renamed Yaung Chi Oo Worker’s Association – and a non-government organisation, the MAP Foundation for the Health and Knowledge of Ethnic Labour in Chiang Mai, 33 of the workers decided in October to file charges against their employers.

By February 2003, the Labour Protection Office of Tak province, where Mae Sot is located, had passed a landmark order instructing Nut Knitting’s employers to pay over 4.6 million baht (109,500 U.S. dollars) in compensation to the migrants for lost earnings.

The employers defied this order and were consequently sued by lawyers from the Law Society of Thailand, since the Labour Office had by then failed to pursue the case.

Despite the minimum wage being set at 133 baht (3.2 dollars) a day, the Burmese workers were paid less than half of this wage, and made to work 15-hour shifts with inadequate overtime payment. They had no days off, their living conditions cramped and miserable.

Of factories in Mae Sot, about half are garment and knitting factories, most of which export their products to the United States, and include big brand names like Camel, Nike and L L Bean.

"I work hard but I still do not get my wages,” says one of the workers’ representatives in the Nut Knitting case, who did not want to be named. "I don’t get treated fairly and my work has no value. We cannot survive in Burma because we have no money and no job, so we have to go to another country to find work.”

Attempts to reach a compromise on the payment of compensation to the migrants, as ordered by the court in February, were not successful at the first two court sessions, including the one on Jul. 11. The trial begins in late August.

Ironically, it was a decision by the Thai government in 2001 – allowing illegal migrant workers the right to register for a one-year period at a time – that opened for the workers of Nut Knitting Factory a window of opportunity. That registration meant that officially came under Thai labour law.

"Thai labour law gives Burmese workers the same benefits as Thai workers – a minimum wage, health and employment benefits and other social security measures," explains Somchai Homlaor, a human rights lawyer with the Bangkok-based non-governmental organisation Forum Asia.

Some 50 percent of all Burmese workers in Thailand registered during the first year, but by 2002 this had declined to around 30 percent.

In Mae Sot alone, there are over 80,000 migrant workers of whom 30,000 are registered. They work in export-processing factories, including garments and canning factories, in addition to the fisheries, agriculture and construction sectors, and as domestic workers.

"Although the workers are given a work permit for one year, they pay a hefty fee for this and despite this have no security,” explains Moe Shwe from the Yaung Chi Oo Worker’s Association. ”The employer keeps their work permits and may give them a photocopy, but when picked up by the police this is of no use, and they are usually deported back to Burma."

The cost of a one-year work permit is 4,500 baht (107 dollars), deducted from the wages of the workers who are usually paid between 50 to 80 baht (one to 1.2 dollars) a day.

If they receive 1,500 baht (35.7 dollars) in wages a month, most of this goes toward registration fees, accommodation and food. They receive only some 300 baht (7.1 dollars) in cash at the end of the month, if they are lucky.

But registration has been more of a bane than a boon. Not only must they pay for this, it also ties them down further, and gives them no security. They do not have the right to change jobs without their present owners’ signed permission. If fired, they become illegal again, and are immediately deported back to Burma.

Or they must prove that they were not fired because of any fault of their own, and find an alternative employer within seven days – an almost impossible situation, given the time involved in court proceedings, and the collusion between employers who ensure that they are blacklisted and can find no other employment.

The nexus between the police, immigration officials and employers further guarantees that their chances of staying in Thailand, or of putting forward their case, are extremely bleak, activists here say.

"Even today no one believes that these workers (from Nut Knitting) could actually sue their employers,” says Pranom Somwong from the MAP Foundation. "After the Nut Knitting case," she explains, "all factory workers in Mae Sot have had to sign documents saying that they receive minimum wages”.

The physical risk and intimidation is very high. Not only have the 33 workers from Nut Knitting had to hide in a safehouse during the trial, but Yaung Chi Oo Worker’s Association members face intimidation and harassment, as has MAP Foundation, critics say.

Challenges like the Nut Knitting case are rare, but it has boosted the morale of Burmese workers in Thailand like nothing else has in recent years.

In the months following the landmark Labour Protection Office order that sought compensation for the Burmese, workers at five other factories in Mae Sot went on strike demanding the payment of minimum wages and better working conditions.

 
Republish | | Print |

Related Tags