Thursday, November 19, 2026
Mark Bourie
- The president of the European Union (EU), Romano Prodi, on the eve of a meeting with U.S. president Bill Clinton, said Thursday that EU nations had no immediate plans to drop its high tariffs on Central American bananas, a policy that has infuriated Washington.
Prodi appeared to ignore a request made Dec 1 by Edison James, prime minister of Dominica, for the Europeans to change their import policies on bananas.
James, speaking on behalf of Jamaica and the Windward Islands, said the Caribbean nations would be willing to lose much of their special status with Europe if the trade dispute could be ended.
He proposed an compromise on the EU import system that was applauded by US banana growers in Central America officials who have long maintained they have suffered because EU rules protected former colonies in the Caribbean and Africa.
In retaliation, the United States slapped 100 per cent duties on 191 million dollars worth of European imports.
James proposed a two-tiered system which would allow the EU to levy a tariff at 115 euros to the tonne on Central American bananas, down from the EU’s proposed duty of 275 euros a tonne. The Caribbean countries and Africa would have no tariff on their bananas.
Central American bananas, most of them grown by giant U.S. fruit companies such as Dole and Chiquita, would end up with about 80 per cent of the European market, leaving the Caribbean and Africa with 20 per cent.
ON Monday, chief U.S. agricultural trade negotiator Peter Scher wrote to the European Commission to express support for the James proposal. “The United States can endorse the basic features of the Caribbean proposal and finds it a good foundation for reaching a solution to this long-standing dispute,” he said.
“(Since) the most vulnerable countries endorse this proposal, it achieves another EU goal of providing [those] countries the protection they need to continue exporting bananas.”
Prodi, who visited the Canadian capital Thursday before heading to Washington to meet Clinton, said the EU intended sticking to the tariff program that it outlined Nov. 19.
“We already have taken a decision on the banana (tariff issue) to change the relations in due time,” Prodi said at a news conference here. “…Things are going in the right direction now.”
In its Nov. 19 announcement, the European Commission said it had adopted a proposal to bring its tariff regime into line with the commitments of the World Trade Organization while “respecting the Lome Convention and protecting the interests of European Union (EU) producers and consumers.”
It proposed a two-step approach: a transitional tariff rate quota (TRQ) system, which would maintain both the current GATT-bound quota of 2.2 million tonnes and the autonomous quota of 353,000 tonnes, both with a tariff of 75 euro/tonne and open to all suppliers.
A new third quota of 850,000 tonnes would be opened to all suppliers “at a level of tariff which would ensure that the TRQ is filled,” the EU said. Within this quota bananas from favored nations would have a maximum preference of 275 euro/tonne. In Phase 2, a tariff-only system would automatically enter into force after the transition period on 1 January 2006 at the latest.
In September 1997 the Dispute Settlement Body of the WTO ruled that aspects of the EU common market rules for bananas imports were not in conformity with the WTO. The deadline for amending the regime was the end of 1998.
On July 20, 1998 the EU council adopted tariff changes for bananas that took effect on Jan. 1 this year.
After complaints were filed by the United States, the WTO dispute settlement body ruled that the revised banana regime was not fully compatible with WTO rules and the Washington was given authorization to levy its 191 million dollars sanctions against EU imports.