Sunday, November 22, 2026
Jim Lobe
- President Bill Clinton, seeking to defuse a festering protest that has united Puerto Rico against the US Navy, promised Friday to phase-out in five years all military training on Vieques Island, the main live-fire training ground for the US Atlantic fleet since 1941.
Until then, according to a Pentagon recommendation accepted by Clinton, training will be limited to dummy bombs and shells.
Live-fire training will be resumed only if the people of the island agree, according to the plan, which also calls for training exercises to be halved from the 180 days per year to 90 days.
If training is resumed, the Navy, which runs the base, will provide 40 million dollars in community development programmes designed to compensate the 9,300 islanders who have endured the exercises for nearly 60 years.
In addition, Clinton has ordered the aircraft carrier USS Eisenhower and its battle group to proceed to other training sites off the mainland and Scotland before steaming to the Mediterranean for its regular tour.
Washington will not resume any training at Vieques until next Spring, according to the plan which calls for the intervening period to be used for consultations between the Navy and the people of Vieques.
“I am convinced that this plan meets my essential responsibility as Commander-in-Chief to assure that our military forces are satisfactorily trained and ready while, at the same time, addressing the legitimate concerns of the people of Vieques,” Clinton said in a statement issued by the White House.
The plan was announced after intensive negotiations led by Clinton himself over the last week between the Pentagon and Puerto Rican Governor Pedro Rossello and other Puerto Rican leaders.
While it marks a significant climbdown from the Pentagon’s long-held position that the firing range was irreplaceable, it may still prove unacceptable both to the islanders and the general public in Puerto Rico, which has rallied behind demands that the facility be closed immediately.
Rossello’s press secretary said only two weeks ago that the governor’s position was, “live or non-live, no more bombs, not one more.”
Early rumours of the Pentagon’s recommendation reportedly sparked claims of victory in Puerto Rico early Friday by some of the dozens of protestors who have camped out on the bombing range for months in an act of civil disobedience that has galvanized the Commonwealth.
But the fact that Clinton himself referred to the period of time between now and when the next training exercises are scheduled in the Spring as a “breathing space” suggests that serious negotiations between Puerto Rico and the Navy lie ahead.
“We do not have here in the present arrangement a definitive solution,” said Navy Secretary Richard Danzig. “It needs to be worked through between the Navy and the people of Vieques.” This is not a done deal,” said another administration official.
It is also politically risky. Republicans are almost certain to assail the administration for not ensuring navy pilots the best possible training facilities before sending them into hazardous duty. In the last year, warplanes on US aircraft carriers have been used to attack sites in Iraq and Yugoslavia.
The fact that First Lady Hillary Clinton is campaigning to become a US senator in New York state, home to hundreds of thousands of Puerto Rican voters, is bound to add fuel to the Republican fire. Hillary has called publicly for the Navy to abandon the island.
Last August, Danzig, a political appointee, argued that “the loss of Vieques would degrade the readiness of our sailors and Marines for battle.” He insisted Friday, however, that all servicemen will be ready for any contingency by the time the Eisenhower battle group takes up positions in the Mediterranean.
Puerto Rico came under US control in the opening days of the Spanish-American War 101 years ago. Puerto Ricans gained US citizenship in 1917, but, despite repeated opportunities, have always declined to vote either for full independence or for statehood.
Vieques, which is 135 square kms in size, lies just off the east coast of Puerto Rico, opposite Roosevelt Roads Naval Station, the Navy’s largest military base.
Pro-independence forces in Puerto Rico have long called for the complete withdrawal of US military facilities from the Commonwealth, but have been unable to translate that platform into more than about four percent of the vote.
Since World War Two, the island, about two-thirds of which is owned by the Navy, has been used for targeting practice by warplanes and naval vessels. The Navy has also rented out the firing range to its NATO allies and some Latin American navies and air forces, as well.
Danzig said Friday that the bombing range has operated safely for 58 years without a single off-range incident until last April, when a Marine Corps aircraft accidentally dropped two bombs near an observation post, killing a civilian security guard.
But local residents have complained for years about the noise and explosions – which go on day and night during exercises. Local fishermen, the island’s only indigenous industry, have led the protests against the Navy.
With some of the Caribbean’s most beautiful beaches, Vieques could attract investment in tourism, according to experts, but this is impossible so long as the exercises continue. Even then, it may take years to clean the range, given the millions of tonnes of explosives and toxics which have fallen on it. Danzig said Friday the clean-up costs are likely to range in the hundreds of millions of dollars.
Clinton indicated his own support for the Viequans’ cause last June in a private letter to his national security adviser in which he agreed with a Puerto Rican friend that Vieques was being treated like a “colonial commonwealth. This is wrong,” he went on.
“I think they don’t want us there. That’s the main point. The Navy can find a way to work around it.”
But the Pentagon proved very resistant to doing so, arguing that the island was absolutely unique in the Atlantic for the “multi-dimensional” training opportunities it offered.